Public Sector Innovation Assessment
- Introduced by
- OECD Observatory of Public Sector Innovation
- Year
- 2008
- Type
- Framework for assessing public-sector innovation and capacity
- Family
- Public innovation and capacity assessment
What does it do?
Public sector innovation assessment is a structured method for examining how, how much and how effectively a government organization innovates — generating and implementing novel services, processes, policies and governance arrangements that create public value.
Drawing on the work of the OECD Observatory of Public Sector Innovation and on Mark Moore and Jean Hartley's analysis of innovations in governance, it classifies the types of innovation under way, assesses the conditions that enable or block them, evaluates their outcomes, and rates the organization's innovation capacity. Unlike private-sector innovation metrics built around patents and market share, public-sector assessment centers on public value, legitimacy and the distinctive incentives and constraints of government.
The intuition behind the method
Innovation in government is easy to celebrate and hard to pin down. One agency launches a slick new app, another quietly redesigns how it pays benefits so fewer people fall through the cracks, a third creates a new way for citizens and officials to co-produce a service. Are these all innovation, and is any of them actually working? Public sector innovation assessment is like a structured health check that first asks what kind of innovation is happening — a new service, a new internal process, a new policy, or a new way of governing — then asks whether the soil is right for it: leadership support, room to experiment, tolerance of failure, and resources. Finally it asks the only question that matters in government: did it create genuine public value, not just novelty for its own sake.
History
Interest in public-sector innovation grew with the new-public-management reforms of the 1980s and 1990s and the later turn toward public value and collaborative governance. Mark Moore's work on public value and his 2008 Public Management Review article with Jean Hartley, 'Innovations in Governance,' reframed innovation as the creation of public value through changed relationships rather than mere novelty. The OECD established the Observatory of Public Sector Innovation in 2014 to study, classify and support innovation across governments, developing frameworks for innovation types and facets and a large repository of cases. Together these strands underpin contemporary assessment of how and how well governments innovate.
When to use it
Use public-sector innovation assessment when a government organization wants to understand or strengthen its capacity to innovate, evaluate whether an innovation initiative is creating public value, or benchmark innovation across units or jurisdictions. It is well suited to informing innovation strategies, public-management reform and the design of innovation labs or funds. The method assumes that innovation can be meaningfully classified and assessed, that enabling conditions and outcomes can be evidenced, and that public-value criteria are the right yardstick. It is less appropriate when 'innovation' is invoked as a slogan with no concrete activity to assess, when only short-term outputs are available and outcomes have not matured, or when the real need is routine performance measurement rather than innovation analysis.
Limitations and considerations
- Innovation outcomes, especially public value, are hard to measure and often materialize only over long horizons.
- Composite capacity scores depend on subjective weighting and rating, so apparent precision can mask judgment calls.
- Self-assessment of innovation invites optimism bias, with organizations overstating novelty and impact.
- Frameworks risk encouraging innovation theatre — visible but shallow initiatives — if not tied to genuine public-value evidence.
Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.
Strengths
- Centers assessment on public value, legitimacy and equity rather than importing private-sector metrics that fit government poorly.
- Distinguishes innovation types and degrees of novelty, preventing routine improvement from being mislabeled as innovation.
- Diagnoses the enabling conditions — culture, leadership, resources, risk tolerance — that explain why public innovation succeeds or stalls.
- Supports benchmarking and strategy through a structured, repeatable framework backed by OECD reference frameworks and cases.
Applications
- Diagnosing an agency's innovation capacity to inform an innovation or digital-transformation strategy.
- Evaluating whether a specific innovation initiative or pilot created public value before scaling it.
- Benchmarking innovation activity and conditions across departments, agencies or jurisdictions.
- Designing and assessing innovation labs, challenge funds and experimentation programs in government.
- Identifying and addressing cultural and structural barriers — risk aversion, silos, lack of slack — that suppress public innovation.
How it works
How it works
The assessment begins by defining what counts as innovation in the organization's context and what the assessment is for — diagnosing capacity, evaluating a specific initiative, or comparing units. Following Moore and Hartley, public-sector innovation is understood as discontinuous change that alters relationships with citizens and other organizations to create public value, which distinguishes genuine innovation from routine improvement and frames the scope of inquiry around public-value creation rather than novelty alone.
Observed or planned innovations are classified by type, commonly distinguishing product or service innovations, process and organizational innovations, communication or relational innovations, and policy or governance innovations, along with their degree of novelty (incremental, radical or systemic). Classification, drawing on OPSI's frameworks, clarifies what is actually changing and prevents the assessment from lumping together very different activities under a single label.
The conditions that enable or constrain innovation are assessed: leadership support and political backing, an organizational culture that tolerates experimentation and learning from failure, slack resources and funding, staff skills and autonomy, data and digital infrastructure, and external pressures or partnerships. Because public organizations face accountability and risk-aversion pressures that often suppress innovation, diagnosing these enabling conditions explains why innovation flourishes or stalls and where intervention is needed.
The outcomes of innovation are evaluated against public-value criteria rather than commercial ones — improvements in service quality, efficiency, accessibility, citizen trust and democratic legitimacy, as well as unintended effects. This step asks whether the innovation delivered demonstrable benefit and for whom, recognizing that in government a novel initiative that erodes equity, accountability or trust is not a successful innovation however inventive it appears.
Evidence across the dimensions is synthesized into an innovation-capacity score, formed as a weighted sum of dimension scores with weights reflecting their assessed importance and the dimension scores summarizing enabling conditions, activity and outcomes. The composite provides a comparable indicator for benchmarking units or tracking change over time, while the underlying dimension scores preserve the diagnostic detail about specific strengths and weaknesses.
Formula
I = \sum_{d=1}^{D} w_d \, s_d, \quad \sum_{d=1}^{D} w_d = 1Findings are interpreted to inform innovation strategy: which enabling conditions to strengthen, which types of innovation to prioritize, how to manage the risks and accountability concerns specific to public innovation, and how to scale or diffuse what works. Because public innovation must reconcile experimentation with stewardship of public resources, the assessment translates the diagnosis into concrete, context-sensitive actions rather than generic exhortations to 'be more innovative.'
Common pitfalls
- Counting visible, high-profile launches while ignoring quieter process and policy innovations that create more value.
- Assessing innovation activity without evaluating whether it produced public value, rewarding novelty for its own sake.
- Treating a strong innovation-capacity score as an end in itself rather than a means to better public outcomes.
- Overlooking the accountability, equity and risk constraints that legitimately shape what innovation is appropriate in government.
Frequently asked questions
How does public-sector innovation differ from private-sector innovation?
Private firms innovate primarily to gain competitive advantage and profit, and they can measure success through market share, revenue and patents. Public organizations innovate to create public value — better, fairer, more legitimate services and outcomes — under accountability, equity and risk constraints that have no commercial equivalent. So public-sector innovation assessment judges success by public value and legitimacy, not market performance, and it pays close attention to enabling conditions like risk tolerance, since government's accountability pressures tend to discourage the experimentation innovation requires.
What are the main types of public-sector innovation?
Common typologies, including those used by the OECD Observatory of Public Sector Innovation, distinguish service or product innovations (new or improved services to citizens), process and organizational innovations (new internal ways of working), communication or relational innovations (new ways of interacting with citizens and partners), and policy or governance innovations (new policy approaches or modes of governing). Innovations are also graded by novelty as incremental, radical or systemic. Classifying type and degree keeps the assessment from treating very different activities as one.
How do you measure whether a public innovation actually worked?
By evaluating outcomes against public-value criteria rather than novelty: did service quality, efficiency, accessibility, trust or legitimacy improve, for whom, and at what cost, including any unintended effects? This usually combines quantitative performance indicators with qualitative evidence and stakeholder views, and it requires enough time for outcomes to materialize. An initiative that is inventive but erodes equity, accountability or trust does not count as a successful public innovation, which is why outcome evaluation is central to the assessment.
Related methods
Sources
OECD Observatory of Public Sector Innovation (OPSI). Frameworks and case studies on public-sector innovation. Paris: OECD.
Open publication referenceCopied.Moore, M., & Hartley, J. (2008). Innovations in Governance. Public Management Review, 10(1), 3–20.
Open DOI referenceCopied.