Skip to content
Back to search results

Balanced Scorecard Performance Measure

Introduced by
Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton
Year
1992
Type
Organizational performance measurement and management system
Family
performance-management
Font size

What does it do?

The Balanced Scorecard (BSC) is a strategic management system that translates organizational strategy into a coherent set of performance measures across four perspectives: Financial, Customer, Internal Process, and Learning and Growth.

Developed by Kaplan and Norton (1992) in Harvard Business Review, the BSC addresses a fundamental management gap: most organizations measure what is easy to measure (financial results) while neglecting what drives results (customer satisfaction, operational efficiency, employee capability). By balancing financial outcomes with non-financial drivers, the BSC enables organizations to understand and manage strategy execution, identify causal relationships between performance drivers, and align organizational actions with strategic objectives.

The intuition behind the method

Traditional financial reporting measures the 'what'—did we make profit? The Balanced Scorecard answers the 'how'—through what customer experiences, operational processes, and capabilities did we create that profit? A firm might boost short-term profit through cost-cutting (financial perspective) but damage customer satisfaction (customer perspective), compromise product quality (internal process perspective), and demoralize employees (learning and growth perspective). Months later, customer churn and reduced innovation create financial crisis. The BSC links short-term results to long-term health by forcing organizations to measure and manage the chain of causation: investments in employee capability → improved processes → better customer experience → profitable growth. The four perspectives work together: financial results are outcomes; customers and processes are intermediate drivers; learning and growth are foundational capabilities. Balanced measurement prevents short-term financial optimization that destroys long-term value.

History

Kaplan and Norton introduced the Balanced Scorecard in Harvard Business Review (1992) as a solution to management's over-reliance on financial metrics. Their 1996 book extended BSC into a comprehensive strategy management framework including strategy mapping and cascading. Niven (2002) adapted BSC for nonprofit and public sector organizations, recognizing that financial metrics are less relevant in these sectors. The framework has been implemented by thousands of organizations across private, public, and nonprofit sectors. Evolution has added perspectives (some organizations add regulatory/social responsibility), strategic mapping (visually linking cause-effect), and governance integration. Current practice often combines BSC with other frameworks (OKRs, strategy mapping) for more comprehensive strategy management.

When to use it

Implement Balanced Scorecard when translating strategy into operational objectives, diagnosing strategy execution problems, aligning organizational performance management, enabling accountability for strategic outcomes, or supporting organizational change initiatives. Particularly valuable during strategic transitions (new strategy, merger, turnaround) when organizations need shared understanding of strategic direction and measures of success. Use when financial metrics alone obscure what is driving performance, or when organizations struggle with strategy execution despite clear strategic intent.

Limitations and considerations

  • Implementation complexity: developing, cascading, and sustaining balanced scorecards is time-consuming and requires strong change management; many organizations abandon scorecards after initial implementation
  • Metric selection difficulty: determining the 'right' metrics that truly reflect strategic outcomes is challenging; poor metric selection creates misaligned incentives or focuses effort on non-drivers
  • Information requirements: BSC requires robust data collection and systems; organizations lacking data infrastructure struggle with implementation
  • Strategy assumption risk: BSC measures execution of stated strategy but cannot validate whether strategy itself is correct; poor strategy executed perfectly still yields poor results
  • Gaming risk: when BSC metrics become accountability measures (tied to compensation), individuals may optimize metrics rather than underlying objectives (e.g., maximizing customer satisfaction survey scores rather than actual satisfaction)

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Strategy translation: BSC forces explicit strategy translation into operational measures, exposing strategy ambiguity or unrealistic assumptions
  • Causal clarity: by linking financial outcomes to customer and process drivers, BSC makes visible the cause-effect chain underlying performance—enabling management to intervene at root causes rather than symptoms
  • Balanced accountability: by measuring financial AND customer AND process AND learning outcomes, BSC prevents short-term financial optimization that destroys long-term value
  • Organizational alignment: cascading scorecards through the organization ensure all levels understand their contribution to strategy; clarifies decision authority and priorities
  • Learning system: regular scorecard review creates dialogue about strategy assumptions, results, and adjustments; enables adaptive strategy execution

Applications

  • Strategy execution tracking: organizations use BSC to monitor progress toward strategic objectives; monthly/quarterly scorecard reviews identify execution gaps early, enabling corrective action before quarterly results are evident
  • Organizational alignment and accountability: cascading scorecards ensure all levels understand how their work contributes to overall strategy; makes accountability transparent and enables line-of-sight from employee work to organizational outcomes
  • Business unit and divisional performance evaluation: BSC provides balanced view of performance (not just profit) enabling fair comparison of units with different strategic roles (growth divisions may show lower financial metrics but high customer/learning metrics)
  • Strategic initiative prioritization: BSC results reveal which strategic initiatives are delivering expected value; enables reallocation of resources from underperforming to high-performing initiatives
  • Post-merger integration success: BSC integration tracks whether merger is achieving intended strategic synergies; reveals execution problems (strategies look good on paper; integration reveals operational blockers) enabling mid-course correction

How it works

How it works

1

Balanced Scorecard development is a facilitated process, not a questionnaire. Step 1: Define strategic objectives (e.g., 'Increase market share,' 'Improve product quality,' 'Develop digital capabilities'). Step 2: Translate each objective into specific, measurable performance metrics. Step 3: Organize metrics into the four perspectives—Financial (ROI, revenue growth, profit margin), Customer (satisfaction, retention, market share), Internal Process (quality, efficiency, cycle time), and Learning and Growth (employee engagement, capability development, innovation). Step 4: Establish targets for each metric and identify strategic initiatives to achieve targets. Step 5: Cascade scorecard through the organization (business units develop supporting scorecards aligned to corporate strategy). Step 6: Establish reporting cadence (monthly, quarterly) to track progress. Typical scorecards contain 15–25 metrics, with 4–6 metrics per perspective. Development takes 2–4 months; implementation and refinement take 1–2 years.

Formula
Define strategic objectives and develop measures across four perspectives; establish targets and initiatives
2

Scorecard measurement involves tracking actual performance against established targets for each metric. Scoring frameworks vary: (1) Percentage of target achievement (e.g., metric achieved 87% of target = 0.87 score), (2) Traffic light status (green = on target, yellow = at risk, red = off target), (3) Balanced scoring matrix assigning weights to metrics based on strategic importance. Perspective scores are the average of metric scores within that perspective (or weighted average if importance differs). The overall Balanced Scorecard score is the average of the four perspective scores. Many organizations display results in a dashboard showing each metric's trend (improving/stable/declining), actual vs. target, and status. The scorecard is typically reviewed monthly or quarterly with focus on variance analysis: why did metric X miss target? What initiated the variance? What corrective action is needed?

Formula
Measure organizational performance on selected metrics; assess actual vs. target performance; calculate perspective and overall scorecard scores
3

Balanced Scorecard results reveal both short-term performance and long-term health signals. Strong Financial perspective with weak Customer perspective indicates unsustainable short-term profit (customer dissatisfaction will erode future revenue). Strong Learning and Growth with weak Internal Process indicates capability investment not yet translating to operational improvement (implementation delay expected). Weak Financial perspective with strong other perspectives indicates strategic investments ahead of payoff (verify strategy is correct before changing course). Ideally, all four perspectives show balanced strength (65–80% of targets achieved); sustained imbalance (one perspective consistently weak) suggests strategic misalignment or execution problem. Interpretation requires understanding the causal chain: is weak Financial performance due to execution failure (processes not improving as planned) or strategy flaw (objectives misaligned with market realities)?

Formula
Analyze performance results; identify causal relationships between measures; adjust strategy and initiatives based on results

Common pitfalls

  • Treating BSC as a reporting tool rather than management system: some organizations implement scorecards as monthly dashboards without strategic dialogue or course correction; this loses the primary benefit of BSC as a learning and adaptation mechanism
  • Over-weighting financial metrics: despite the name 'balanced,' organizations often revert to financial focus, treating other perspectives as secondary; true balance requires equal weight and attention to all perspectives
  • Cascading without strategic coherence: cascading scorecards to lower levels without ensuring alignment to corporate strategy creates isolated local scorecards unconnected to overall strategy; ensure cascade reflects strategic cause-effect chain
  • Static scorecard: scorecards should evolve as strategy evolves or environmental conditions change; organizations that treat scorecards as fixed tools miss changing strategic priorities
  • Confusing correlation with causation: BSC metrics may be correlated (e.g., employee engagement and customer satisfaction both improved) without causal relationship; analysis must verify causal links before assuming metric relationships

Frequently asked questions

How many metrics should a balanced scorecard include?

Typically 15–25 metrics for the overall corporate scorecard; 3–5 metrics per perspective. Quality matters more than quantity—fewer well-designed metrics that drive behavior are better than many disconnected metrics. If a metric doesn't drive strategy, remove it; scorecard creep (adding metrics over time) dilutes focus. Individual metric importance varies; leading organizations often identify 5–10 'critical few' metrics that get primary focus.

What if strategic objectives and financial targets conflict?

This reveals strategy conflict that must be resolved explicitly. A stated objective of 'increase quality' conflicts with a financial target of 'reduce costs 15%' if the organization cannot achieve both; choose which is primary or adjust targets. BSC forces these conversations; avoiding them creates confused execution. Sometimes apparent conflicts resolve through better processes (technology, efficiency improvements); sometimes trade-offs are real and strategic priority must be clear.

Can BSC be used in nonprofits or public sector organizations?

Yes. Adapt the Financial perspective to sustainability/funding metrics; replace Profit with Program Impact or Stakeholder Value. Nonprofits often emphasize Customer (stakeholder) and Learning and Growth; governments emphasize Internal Process (service delivery) and societal outcomes. BSC principles (balance, cause-effect, strategic translation) apply universally; implementation details adapt to sector context.

What if an organization is new and lacks historical data for targets?

Set targets based on industry benchmarks, competitor performance, or best practices initially. As data accumulates (6–12 months), refine targets based on actual organizational capability. Start conservative (achievable targets) to build credibility; gradually raise targets as performance improves. Targets should challenge the organization (60–70% initial achievement is typical) without being unattainable (which demotivates).

How does BSC relate to compensation and incentives?

Some organizations tie compensation to BSC performance; this focuses behavior but risks gaming (optimizing metrics rather than underlying objectives). Best practice: tie compensation to a portion of BSC (e.g., 20–30% of bonus to balanced metrics), not entirely; maintain some compensation on individual/team performance and company financial results. Ensure metrics cannot be gamed (e.g., customer satisfaction is multifaceted, not based solely on survey scores).

Related methods

Sources

  1. Kaplan, R. S., & Norton, D. P. (1992). The balanced scorecard: Measures that drive performance. Harvard Business Review, 70(1), 71–79.

    Open publication reference
    Copied.
  2. Kaplan, R. S., & Norton, D. P. (1996). The balanced scorecard: Translating strategy into action. Harvard Business School Press.

    Open publication reference
    Copied.
  3. Niven, P. R. (2002). Balanced scorecard step-by-step: Maximizing performance and maintaining results. John Wiley & Sons.

    Open publication reference
    Copied.