La Prospective Morphological Scenarios
- Introduced by
- Michel Godet (LIPSOR, Conservatoire national des arts et metiers)
- Year
- 2006
- Type
- Combinatorial scenario-construction pipeline within La Prospective
- Family
- Futures studies / French prospective school
What does it do?
Within the French school of la prospective developed by Michel Godet, morphological scenario construction is the integrating stage that turns the outputs of structural and actor analysis into a small set of coherent images of the future.
Building on Fritz Zwicky's morphological method, Godet decomposes the studied system into a set of dimensions or components, attaches to each a few mutually exclusive hypotheses about how it might evolve, and treats the Cartesian product of these hypotheses as the morphological space of all conceivable futures. Because that space is combinatorially large, the method's analytical work lies in reducing it: pruning combinations that are internally incoherent, implausible, or incompatible with the strategies of key actors, until a handful of contrasted, self-consistent scenarios remain. Distinct from general morphological analysis, this is the scenario-building application that consumes the variables identified by MICMAC and the actor positions mapped by MACTOR.
The intuition behind the method
Imagine the future of a system as a set of dials, one for each key dimension — the economy, technology, regulation, social values — and each dial able to click into one of a few distinct settings. Every full configuration of the dials is one possible future, and multiplying the settings together gives an astronomically large space of combinations. Most of those combinations make no sense: a setting on one dial may flatly contradict a setting on another, or be ruled out by what the powerful actors in the system would never allow. Godet's morphological method embraces this picture but then does the hard work of throwing away the nonsense. Starting from the variables that earlier structural analysis flagged as truly driving the system, and respecting the alliances and conflicts that actor analysis revealed, the analyst keeps only the dial-combinations that hang together as believable worlds. What survives is a small family of richly specified, mutually contrasting scenarios — each a coherent path from today's configuration to a particular settled future.
History
The morphological method originated with the astronomer Fritz Zwicky, who in the mid-twentieth century proposed decomposing a problem into parameters and exhaustively combining their possible values to map a solution space. Michel Godet, working at the Conservatoire national des arts et metiers and founding the LIPSOR laboratory, adapted morphological analysis as the scenario-building component of la prospective, the distinctively French strategic-foresight tradition that integrates structural analysis (MICMAC), actor analysis (MACTOR), and probabilised expert methods (SMIC Prob-Expert). Godet articulated the full toolbox in works including The Crisis in Forecasting and the Emergence of the Prospective Approach and, in English, Creating Futures: Scenario Planning as a Strategic Management Tool (2006). Bishop, Hines and Collins catalogued morphological scenario construction among the established scenario-development techniques in their 2007 survey, situating the French school within the wider international scenario literature.
When to use it
Use Godet's morphological scenario construction when you need a systematic, traceable way to generate a small set of internally coherent scenarios for a complex system whose drivers and stakeholders have already been analysed. It fits naturally as the synthesising stage of a full la prospective study, downstream of structural analysis with MICMAC and actor analysis with MACTOR, where the goal is to anchor scenarios in the system's genuine variables and power relations rather than in unaided imagination. The combinatorial transparency makes it valuable when stakeholders demand to see that the possibility space was systematically explored. It is less suited to quick, lightweight foresight exercises, to problems where the dimensions cannot be cleanly separated into discrete hypotheses, or where the upstream structural and actor analyses have not been done and the morphological table would rest on shaky foundations.
Limitations and considerations
- The morphological space explodes combinatorially, so reducing it depends on judgement-heavy coherence and plausibility filtering.
- Forcing each dimension into a few mutually exclusive hypotheses can flatten continuous or finely graded uncertainties.
- It presupposes the substantial upfront work of structural and actor analysis, making a full study lengthy and resource-intensive.
- Results can appear deceptively rigorous while still resting on subjective hypothesis definitions and elimination choices.
Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.
Strengths
- Systematically enumerates the full space of possible futures, reducing the risk of overlooking a plausible configuration.
- Anchors scenarios in the system's real drivers and actor power relations through its integration with MICMAC and MACTOR.
- Makes the construction transparent and traceable, since every retained scenario is a defensible combination of explicit hypotheses.
- The coherence and actor-compatibility filters yield scenarios that are internally consistent and politically credible, not just imaginable.
Applications
- Synthesising the final scenarios in a full la prospective study after structural and actor analysis.
- Generating coherent long-term scenarios for national, regional, and sectoral strategic planning in the French and European tradition.
- Exploring the futures of a firm's competitive environment grounded in its key driving variables and stakeholders.
- Systematically mapping the possibility space for technology, energy, or territorial foresight where comprehensiveness is demanded.
- Providing a traceable, auditable scenario set for public decision-making where stakeholders require evidence of thorough exploration.
How it works
How it works
The method does not start from scratch but from the system base assembled in the earlier phases of la prospective. Godet insists that scenario building rest on a delimited set of key variables identified through structural analysis — typically the influential and dependent variables surfaced by MICMAC — together with the map of actor strategies, power relations, and stakes produced by MACTOR. This base fixes which dimensions of the system genuinely matter and how the principal actors are positioned. Grounding the scenarios in this structured diagnosis is what distinguishes Godet's approach from free-form storytelling: the futures explored are anchored in the system's real drivers and its political dynamics.
Formula
B = \{V_1, \ldots, V_m\}\ \text{key variables from structural analysis, with actor map from MACTOR}Each retained component of the system is then characterised by a small number of mutually exclusive hypotheses describing how it could plausibly stand at the horizon — for instance whether a regulatory regime tightens, holds, or liberalises. Godet stresses keeping the hypotheses few, distinct, and exhaustive enough to span the relevant range without overlapping, so that exactly one applies in any given future. This decomposition into dimensions and configurations is the morphological heart inherited from Zwicky: by breaking the future into independent sub-questions, the analyst makes a vast and vague space of possibilities into something that can be systematically enumerated and reasoned about.
Formula
\text{for each component } C_j:\ H_j = \{h_{j1}, \ldots, h_{jk_j}\}\ \text{mutually exclusive future configurations}Combining the hypotheses across all dimensions defines the morphological space: the Cartesian product whose elements are complete configurations, each picking one hypothesis per component. The size of this space is the product of the numbers of hypotheses, so it grows multiplicatively and quickly becomes enormous. Godet treats this full enumeration as the field of the possible — every theoretically conceivable future the chosen dimensions can express. Laying out the space explicitly, often as a morphological table, ensures that no candidate future is overlooked simply because it was not imagined, even though the great majority will later be eliminated.
Formula
\Omega = H_1 \times H_2 \times \cdots \times H_p,\quad |\Omega| = \prod_{j=1}^{p} k_j\ \text{combinations}The decisive analytical step is reducing the morphological space to a tractable set of credible scenarios. Godet applies several filters: internal coherence, removing configurations whose hypotheses contradict one another; plausibility, discarding combinations that are theoretically possible but unbelievable; and compatibility with actor strategies, eliminating futures that the balance of power and the conflicts and alliances revealed by MACTOR would prevent. Tools such as probabilised cross-impact (for example SMIC Prob-Expert) and consistency checks can support this pruning. What remains after the filtering is a small number of robust, mutually distinct configurations that together cover the meaningful range of futures.
Formula
\Omega^{*} = \{\,\omega \in \Omega : \text{coherent}(\omega) \wedge \text{plausible}(\omega) \wedge \text{compatible with actor strategies}\,\}Finally each surviving configuration is developed from a static image of the future into a dynamic scenario by constructing the path that leads from the present state of the system to that endpoint. Godet emphasises that a scenario is not just a snapshot but a coherent and plausible sequence of events, decisions, and actor behaviours linking now to then. Bishop, Hines and Collins place this kind of structured, combinatorial scenario building among the recognised scenario-development techniques, noting its strength in systematically covering the possibility space. The completed scenarios then feed strategic reflection, helping the organisation prepare for and influence the futures the analysis has shown to be coherent.
Formula
\text{scenario } = \langle \text{base} \to \omega^{*} \rangle,\quad \text{trajectory from present image to coherent future image}Common pitfalls
- Defining hypotheses that overlap or are not exhaustive, so configurations are double-counted or genuine futures fall through the gaps.
- Pruning the morphological space by intuition alone without explicit coherence and actor-compatibility criteria, hiding the reasoning.
- Building scenario endpoints without constructing the paths to them, leaving static images that cannot guide strategy over time.
- Skipping or short-cutting the MICMAC and MACTOR foundations, so the dimensions chosen do not reflect the system's true drivers.
Frequently asked questions
How does this differ from general morphological analysis?
General morphological analysis is the broad Zwicky-derived technique of decomposing any problem into parameters, listing each parameter's possible values, and exploring the resulting configuration space, used across design, policy, and problem-structuring. Godet's morphological scenarios are a specific scenario-building application of that logic inside la prospective. The distinctive features are that the dimensions and hypotheses are drawn from prior structural analysis (MICMAC) and the elimination of configurations respects the actor strategies and power relations from MACTOR, and that the endpoints are developed into dynamic paths from present to future.
Why is reducing the morphological space the crucial step?
Because the full morphological space is the product of the number of hypotheses across every dimension, it grows multiplicatively and quickly contains far more configurations than anyone could analyse, the vast majority of which are incoherent or impossible. The value of the method comes from disciplined reduction: applying internal-coherence, plausibility, and actor-compatibility filters to keep only the handful of configurations that form believable, mutually distinct worlds. Without rigorous, explicit reduction the enumeration is merely overwhelming, so the elimination criteria are where the analytical judgement and traceability of the method reside.
Do the scenarios get probabilities?
Morphological construction itself produces coherent qualitative configurations rather than likelihoods, but within la prospective it is often combined with probabilistic tools. In particular, SMIC Prob-Expert can be applied to the underlying hypotheses to elicit and correct expert probabilities and rank scenario combinations by their probability. So while the morphological stage focuses on which futures are coherent and which actors would permit them, the broader toolbox allows the resulting scenarios to be weighted, helping decision-makers distinguish the more from the less probable among the retained set.
Related methods
Sources
Godet, M. (2006). Creating Futures: Scenario Planning as a Strategic Management Tool (2nd ed.). Economica.
ISBN: 9782717852448Copied.Bishop, P., Hines, A., & Collins, T. (2007). The current state of scenario development: an overview of techniques. Foresight, 9(1), 5-25.
Open DOI referenceCopied.