MACTOR Actor Strategy Analysis
- Introduced by
- Michel Godet (LIPSOR)
- Year
- 2006
- Type
- Matrix-based pipeline for mapping actor power, positions, and alliances
- Family
- Futures studies / French prospective school
What does it do?
MACTOR — Matrix of Alliances and Conflicts: Tactics, Objectives, and Recommendations — is the actor-analysis method in Michel Godet's la prospective toolkit, designed to study the strategy game among the players who shape a system's future.
Where structural analysis with MICMAC maps variables, MACTOR maps actors: it builds a matrix of the direct means of action each actor can exert on the others, from which it derives competitive-strength coefficients (the Ri ratios) that gauge each actor's power, and a second matrix recording where each actor stands, for or against, on the contested objectives at stake. By weighting actors' positions by their power and comparing them objective by objective, MACTOR computes the convergences and divergences among actors, revealing potential alliances, latent conflicts, and the balance of power. The result is a strategic diagnosis that informs scenario construction by exposing which futures the actor field would support or resist.
The intuition behind the method
The future of any contested system is not decided by impersonal trends alone but by the players pushing for different outcomes — governments, firms, unions, communities — each with goals they pursue and leverage they can apply. MACTOR turns this messy political reality into something analysable. First it asks how much muscle each actor has over the others, building a grid of who can pressure whom and distilling it into a single strength score per actor. Then it asks where each actor stands on every objective that matters, marking them favourable, opposed, or neutral. Putting these together, weighted by power, lets the analyst see which actors want the same things and which are pulling in opposite directions. Two powerful actors aligned on many objectives are natural allies; two opposed on the high-stakes objectives are a brewing conflict. The picture that emerges is a map of the political battlefield: where alliances might form, where fights will erupt, and how strong each side is — exactly the knowledge needed to judge which scenarios are politically feasible.
History
MACTOR was developed by Michel Godet and colleagues at the Conservatoire national des arts et metiers and the LIPSOR laboratory as the actor-analysis component of la prospective, complementing the structural analysis of MICMAC. Recognising that scenarios anchored only in variables ignored the strategic players who shape outcomes, Godet formalised a method to analyse the game of actors — their objectives, their means of action, and their alliances and conflicts. The method, whose name expands to Matrix of Alliances and Conflicts: Tactics, Objectives, and Recommendations, was documented alongside the rest of the prospective toolbox in works including Creating Futures: Scenario Planning as a Strategic Management Tool (2006), and LIPSOR distributed free MACTOR software that carried it into widespread use in European foresight, public policy, and corporate strategy, where stakeholder dynamics are central to anticipating change.
When to use it
Use MACTOR when the evolution of a system is strongly shaped by the strategies of identifiable stakeholders and you need to understand the power relations, alliances, and conflicts among them before constructing scenarios. It fits the actor-analysis stage of a la prospective study, downstream of MICMAC's variable diagnosis, in problems — public policy, territorial development, industry transformation, contested transitions — where who wants what and who can do what is decisive. It is most useful when a knowledgeable panel can credibly assess actors' mutual influence and their stances on the key objectives. It is less appropriate when the actor field is diffuse or unidentifiable, when the system is driven mainly by impersonal forces rather than strategic players, or when stakeholders' positions cannot be reliably judged, since the analysis is only as sound as the expert assessments of power and position that feed it.
Limitations and considerations
- It depends entirely on expert judgements of actor influence and positions, which are subjective and may be contested.
- Actors' real strategies are often ambiguous, hidden, or shifting, so a static snapshot can mislead about future behaviour.
- Reducing power to a single Ri coefficient and positions to a few categories simplifies rich political dynamics.
- It does not model how alliances and conflicts evolve over time, treating the actor game as fixed at the moment of assessment.
Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.
Strengths
- Makes the strategic game among stakeholders explicit, mapping alliances and conflicts that trend-based analysis ignores.
- Weights actors' positions by their power through the Ri coefficients, so the picture reflects capacity to act, not just preferences.
- Captures both direct and indirect leverage among actors, surfacing influence exerted through third parties.
- Produces actionable convergence and divergence maps that directly inform which scenarios are politically feasible.
Applications
- Analysing the stakeholder game behind a contested policy or planning decision before building scenarios.
- Mapping alliances and conflicts among firms, regulators, and interest groups in an industry transformation.
- Supporting territorial and regional foresight by diagnosing the power relations among local actors.
- Assessing which actors would support or block each candidate scenario to judge its political feasibility.
- Informing negotiation and strategy by revealing potential coalitions and likely antagonists around key objectives.
How it works
How it works
The analysis opens by identifying the relevant actors and the objectives over which they contend. Actors are the individuals, organisations, or groups whose decisions and strategies materially influence the system — typically the same field surfaced when interpreting the key variables from structural analysis. The objectives, or stakes, are the contested goals tied to those variables: the things actors are trying to achieve, prevent, or control. Godet stresses that a clear, shared definition of each actor's identity, levers, and aims is the foundation of the whole analysis, because every later matrix depends on knowing precisely who the players are and what they are fighting over.
Formula
A = \{a_1, \ldots, a_n\},\quad O = \{o_1, \ldots, o_p\}\ \text{actors and contested objectives}Experts then construct the direct-influence matrix among actors, often called the MID, recording for each ordered pair how much one actor's means of action bear on another — its capacity to constrain, pressure, or enable the other. This actor-by-actor matrix is the analogue of MICMAC's variable matrix but applied to the players rather than the factors. Godet notes that completing it forces an explicit reckoning with each actor's real leverage over the others, distinguishing nominal importance from actual capacity to act. The matrix captures the raw distribution of means of action from which the competitive-strength coefficients are computed.
Formula
MID = [d_{ij}],\quad d_{ij} = \text{direct means of action of actor } a_i \text{ on actor } a_jFrom the influence matrix MACTOR derives each actor's overall competitive strength, summarised in the Ri coefficients. An actor's strength rises with the total influence it exerts on others and falls with the influence others exert on it, and the calculation also accounts for indirect leverage exerted through third actors. The resulting ratio places every actor on a common scale of power within the field, distinguishing dominant actors from dominated ones. These coefficients are central because positions on objectives are afterwards weighted by them: a powerful actor's stance counts for more than a weak actor's, so the analysis reflects not just what actors want but their capacity to get it.
Formula
R_i = \frac{I_i}{I_i + D_i}\cdot\frac{I_i}{\sum_k I_k},\quad I_i = \sum_j d_{ij},\ D_i = \sum_j d_{ji}Next experts fill the actor-by-objective position matrix, the MAO, recording each actor's stance toward each objective — favourable, opposed, or indifferent — and, in fuller versions, how intensely the actor cares and how much it would mobilise. Weighting these valued positions by the Ri power coefficients turns a simple ledger of preferences into a power-weighted map of where the influential actors stand on each contested goal. Godet uses this to gauge each objective's mobilisation: which goals command broad powerful support, which face powerful opposition, and which leave actors divided. This step joins the question of what actors want to the question of how strong they are.
Formula
MAO = [p_{io}],\quad p_{io} \in [-,0,+]\ \text{stance of } a_i \text{ on } o,\ \text{weighted by } R_iFinally MACTOR computes the convergences and divergences among actors by comparing their positions across all objectives. Two actors converge to the extent they take the same side on the same objectives and diverge to the extent they oppose each other, and summing these agreements and disagreements, weighted by power and intensity, yields convergence and divergence matrices and the associated network diagrams. Godet reads these as a map of potential alliances and latent conflicts: clusters of aligned actors who might cooperate and pairs of antagonists likely to clash. This actor-strategy map feeds directly into scenario building, indicating which futures the balance of power would favour or block.
Formula
CONV(a_i,a_j) = \sum_o \mathbb{1}[\text{same sign}],\quad DIV(a_i,a_j) = \sum_o \mathbb{1}[\text{opposite sign}]Common pitfalls
- Misidentifying or omitting a pivotal actor, which distorts the power balance and the entire convergence-divergence map.
- Reading convergences as firm alliances when shared positions on objectives need not translate into actual cooperation.
- Ignoring the intensity and mobilisation behind positions, treating a lukewarm stance as equal to a vital one.
- Taking the Ri power scores as objective fact rather than as a model of leverage built on debatable influence judgements.
Frequently asked questions
What do the Ri coefficients measure?
The Ri coefficients summarise each actor's competitive strength or power within the field. An actor's score rises with the total means of action it exerts on the other actors and falls with the influence others exert on it, and the calculation also folds in indirect leverage transmitted through third actors. The resulting ratio places every actor on a common scale from dominant to dominated. The coefficients matter because MACTOR weights actors' positions on objectives by their Ri, so the analysis reflects not merely what each actor wants but how much capacity it has to make that want prevail.
How does MACTOR relate to MICMAC?
They are complementary modules of la prospective addressing different objects. MICMAC performs structural analysis on the system's variables, classifying them by influence and dependence to find the key drivers. MACTOR performs actor analysis on the players, mapping their power, positions, and alliances. The usual sequence runs MICMAC first to identify which variables govern the system, then MACTOR to analyse the stakeholders who contest those variables, and finally morphological scenario building informed by both. MICMAC tells you what factors matter; MACTOR tells you who is fighting over them and who is likely to win.
What is the difference between convergence and divergence?
Convergence and divergence describe how actors relate across the set of objectives. Two actors converge to the degree they take the same side — both favourable or both opposed — on the same objectives, signalling a potential alliance. They diverge to the degree they take opposite sides, signalling latent conflict. MACTOR sums these agreements and disagreements across all objectives, weighted by actor power and the intensity of positions, to produce convergence and divergence matrices and network maps. Reading them shows which clusters of actors might cooperate and which pairs are antagonists, which is the core strategic insight the method delivers.
Related methods
Sources
Godet, M. (2006). Creating Futures: Scenario Planning as a Strategic Management Tool (2nd ed.). Economica.
ISBN: 9782717852448Copied.