Skip to content
Back to search results

Innovation System Functions Analysis

Introduced by
Marko Hekkert, Roald Suurs and colleagues
Year
2007
Type
Functional analysis framework with event-history method
Family
Innovation systems studies
Font size

What does it do?

Functions of Innovation Systems analysis explains technological change by examining how well an innovation system performs seven key functions—entrepreneurial activities, knowledge development, knowledge diffusion, guidance of the search, market formation, resource mobilisation, and the creation of legitimacy.

Associated with Hekkert, Suurs, and colleagues at Utrecht, the approach operationalises these functions through event-history analysis: a chronological dataset of innovation events is coded, functional performance is tracked over time, and the reinforcing feedback loops—the 'motors' of cumulative causation—that drive a system's rise or stagnation are identified.

The intuition behind the method

Imagine an engine made of seven interacting cylinders. No single cylinder makes the car move; what matters is whether they fire in a sequence that builds momentum. Entrepreneurs run experiments, which generate knowledge, which spreads through networks, which sharpens shared expectations about where to head, which helps create markets, which attracts resources, which builds legitimacy—and legitimacy in turn draws in more entrepreneurs. When this loop catches, it becomes a self-reinforcing 'motor' of cumulative causation that propels the technology forward. Functions analysis is the diagnostic that reconstructs, event by event, whether such a virtuous cycle ignited, sputtered, or stalled—and why.

History

The functions approach crystallised the functional turn in innovation-systems research during the mid-2000s. Marko Hekkert and colleagues at Utrecht University set out the seven functions in their 2007 paper in Technological Forecasting and Social Change, proposing them as a new way to analyse technological change dynamically rather than statically. Roald Suurs's doctoral work, including the 2009 study of biofuels in the Netherlands with Hekkert, developed the event-history method and the concept of cumulative-causation 'motors of innovation,' demonstrating how reinforcing loops among the functions drive a system through its formative phases. The approach is complementary to the Bergek et al. TIS scheme, with which it shares the functions vocabulary, and the two are frequently used together.

When to use it

Use functions analysis when you want a fine-grained, dynamic explanation of how a technological innovation system formed or stalled over time, and when rich chronological source material—especially trade press—is available to build an event history. It suits longitudinal single-technology case studies and comparisons of the same technology across countries or periods. The approach assumes that the seven functions capture the essential processes of system development and that events can be reliably coded to them. It is less appropriate when sources are too thin to construct a credible event history, when a static structural snapshot suffices, or when the question concerns whole-system regime change rather than the dynamics of one technology.

Limitations and considerations

  • Building the event history is labour-intensive and depends heavily on the coverage and bias of the available sources, especially trade press.
  • Coding events to functions and scoring their contributions involves judgement, raising inter-coder reliability and comparability concerns.
  • The seven functions overlap and their boundaries are contestable, so different analysts may attribute the same event differently.
  • Its single-technology, function-internal focus gives limited purchase on the surrounding landscape, regime, and broader political economy.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Makes innovation-system dynamics concrete and traceable by grounding them in a dated, coded record of real events.
  • Captures temporal dynamics and feedback explicitly, revealing the cumulative-causation motors that static frameworks miss.
  • Provides a structured, comparable set of seven functions that supports cross-case and cross-country comparison.
  • Links diagnosis directly to intervention by showing which functions and feedbacks are weak and where policy could ignite a motor.
  • Has a substantial empirical track record across renewable-energy and other emerging-technology cases.

Applications

  • Reconstructing the formation of biofuel innovation systems and explaining their acceleration and stagnation over time.
  • Analysing the development of wind, solar, and other renewable-electricity innovation systems through event histories.
  • Comparing the same emerging technology across countries to explain why functional motors ignited in some and not others.
  • Diagnosing weak functions and absent feedback loops to inform technology-specific innovation policy interventions.
  • Tracing hydrogen, biogas, and heat-pump innovation systems to identify which motors of innovation are driving or failing them.

How it works

How it works

1

Begin by mapping the seven functions onto the focal technological innovation system: F1 entrepreneurial activities, F2 knowledge development, F3 knowledge diffusion through networks, F4 guidance of the search (the formation of expectations and visions that direct attention and resources), F5 market formation, F6 resource mobilisation (capital, human resources, complementary assets), and F7 the creation of legitimacy and the counteraction of resistance to change. These functions define what the analysis will measure.

2

Build an event history: a systematic, chronological dataset of innovation-related events—the founding of firms, R&D projects, conferences, policy changes, investments, demonstration projects, lobbying, and media coverage—drawn primarily from trade journals and professional press, complemented by policy documents and interviews. Each event is dated and described so that the development of the system can be reconstructed over its formative period.

3

Code each event to one or more of the seven functions and assess its positive or negative contribution, then aggregate over time to trace how each function develops across the period. The result is a set of function-by-time trajectories showing which functions are fulfilled strongly, which lag, and how the overall functional pattern evolves through the system's phases.

4

Analyse the interactions between functions over time to identify cumulative causation: the reinforcing feedback loops in which fulfilment of one function strengthens others. Because functions rarely develop independently, the analyst looks for the sequences in which, for example, rising expectations mobilise resources that fund entrepreneurial activity that builds legitimacy, generating the virtuous (or vicious) cycles that explain the system's trajectory.

5

Diagnose the resulting 'motors of innovation'—characteristic patterns of cumulative causation such as the science and technology push motor, the entrepreneurial motor, the system-building motor, and the market motor—that drive the system through successive phases. Identifying which motor is (or is not) running and why it accelerates or breaks down yields a process explanation of the system's formation and concrete leverage points for policy.

Common pitfalls

  • Relying on a single, biased source (one trade journal) so that the event history over- or under-represents particular functions.
  • Scoring functions in isolation and never analysing their interactions, thereby missing the cumulative-causation motors that are the point.
  • Treating function scores as precise quantities rather than as qualitative indicators of relative strength and direction.
  • Inferring a self-reinforcing motor from coincidental co-movement of functions without tracing the actual causal feedback between events.

Frequently asked questions

What are the seven functions of innovation systems?

F1 entrepreneurial activities (experiments and ventures that turn knowledge into business opportunities); F2 knowledge development (learning by searching and by doing); F3 knowledge diffusion through networks; F4 guidance of the search (the articulation of expectations and visions that direct resources); F5 market formation (creating space and demand for the new technology); F6 resource mobilisation (financial, human, and physical resources); and F7 creation of legitimacy and counteraction of resistance to change. The approach asks how well each is fulfilled and how they reinforce one another.

What is a 'motor of innovation'?

A motor of innovation is a recurring pattern of cumulative causation—a self-reinforcing feedback loop among the seven functions—that drives a system through a phase of development. Suurs and Hekkert describe several, including a science and technology push motor (knowledge development driving the system), an entrepreneurial motor (ventures and market formation reinforcing each other), a system-building motor (actors deliberately constructing networks and institutions), and a market motor (demand pulling the system forward). Diagnosing which motor is running explains the system's trajectory.

How does this differ from the Bergek et al. TIS scheme?

Both use the functions vocabulary, but they emphasise different things. The Bergek et al. Technological Innovation Systems scheme is a broader analytic frame that starts from structural components, assesses the functional pattern, compares achieved with desired functionality, and diagnoses inducement and blocking mechanisms for policy. The functions-of-innovation-systems approach here concentrates on the seven functions operationalised through event-history analysis and on identifying cumulative-causation motors over time. The two are complementary and often combined; this library cross-links them.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Hekkert, M. P., Suurs, R. A. A., Negro, S. O., Kuhlmann, S., & Smits, R. E. H. M. (2007). Functions of innovation systems: a new approach for analysing technological change. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 74(4), 413-432.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.
  2. Suurs, R. A. A., & Hekkert, M. P. (2009). Cumulative causation in the formation of a technological innovation system: the case of biofuels in the Netherlands. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 76(8), 1003-1020.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.