Skip to content
Back to search results

Technological Innovation Systems

Introduced by
Anna Bergek, Staffan Jacobsson, Bo Carlsson and colleagues
Year
2008
Type
Systems-of-innovation framework and scheme of analysis
Family
Innovation systems studies
Font size

What does it do?

Technological Innovation Systems (TIS) analysis studies the emergence, growth, and performance of a specific technology by treating it as a system of actors, networks, and institutions that interact to generate, diffuse, and use that technology.

Building on the systems-of-innovation tradition, the influential scheme of Bergek and colleagues combines a structural account of the system's components with a functional analysis of the key processes—or functions—that an innovation system must perform, then compares achieved with desired functionality to diagnose inducement and blocking mechanisms and derive policy.

The intuition behind the method

Think of a new technology—say, offshore wind or biogas—as a developing organism that needs a whole supporting body to thrive. The bones and organs are the structure: the firms, research labs, industry associations, standards, and subsidies. But structure alone is inert; what matters is whether the body actually performs its vital functions—does it breathe (mobilise resources), circulate (diffuse knowledge), grow muscle (form markets), and fend off threats (build legitimacy)? TIS analysis is a clinical examination: first chart the anatomy, then assess each vital function against what a healthy system would need, and finally diagnose what is helping or blocking the patient's development so that the right policy 'treatment' can be prescribed.

History

TIS analysis grew out of the broader systems-of-innovation tradition of the 1980s and 1990s—national, regional, and sectoral innovation systems—narrowed to focus on individual technologies, an approach pioneered by Bo Carlsson and Rikard Stankiewicz. During the 2000s two complementary strands sharpened the functional turn: Marko Hekkert and colleagues at Utrecht proposed a set of innovation-system functions in their 2007 paper, and Anna Bergek, Staffan Jacobsson, and colleagues set out an integrated scheme of analysis in Research Policy in 2008 that combined structural mapping with functional assessment and the diagnosis of inducement and blocking mechanisms. Together these works established TIS as a standard framework for analysing emerging sustainable technologies and informing innovation policy.

When to use it

Use TIS analysis when you want to understand why a particular emerging technology is developing well or poorly and what policy could accelerate it, and when you can assemble mixed evidence on its actors, networks, institutions, and functions. It suits the study of technologies in their formative phase—renewables, fuel cells, electric vehicles, biotech—and the design of technology-specific innovation policy. TIS assumes that performance can be understood through a defined set of system functions and that boundaries can be sensibly drawn around one technology. It is less appropriate for analysing whole sectors or national systems, for very mature technologies where the formative dynamics are over, or where the interest is in broad sociotechnical regime change rather than a single technology.

Limitations and considerations

  • Drawing the system boundary is a consequential judgement call, and different boundaries can yield different diagnoses of the same technology.
  • The functions are partly overlapping and their measurement is often qualitative, raising questions of comparability across studies.
  • Its technology-specific focus can underplay competition and interaction between rival TIS and the surrounding sectoral or geographical context.
  • It says less about the deeper landscape and regime dynamics and about politics and power than transition frameworks such as the MLP.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Combines a structural and a functional view, explaining not just what an innovation system contains but how well it actually works.
  • Provides a clear, replicable scheme of analysis that links diagnosis (functions) to intervention (inducement and blocking mechanisms and policy).
  • Focuses on technology-specific dynamics, capturing formative-phase processes that national or sectoral innovation-system lenses miss.
  • Supports technology-specific innovation policy with concrete, phase-sensitive recommendations.
  • Has accumulated a large comparative empirical base across many emerging technologies and countries.

Applications

  • Diagnosing why renewable-energy technologies such as offshore wind, solar PV, or biogas grow rapidly in some countries and stall in others.
  • Analysing the formative dynamics of hydrogen, fuel-cell, and electric-vehicle innovation systems.
  • Evaluating biotechnology, medical-device, and other knowledge-intensive technology systems.
  • Designing technology-specific innovation and industrial policy by identifying blocking mechanisms to remove.
  • Comparing the same technology's innovation system across countries to explain divergent diffusion outcomes.

How it works

How it works

1

Define and delimit the focal technological innovation system: choose the technology, product, or knowledge field of interest and decide whether to study it in terms of knowledge, a product, or a competence field, and within which spatial and temporal boundaries. Clear delimitation is crucial because the same technology can be analysed at different levels (a component, a product, or a whole system) with very different boundaries.

2

Map the structural components of the system: the actors (firms, universities, public bodies, users, industry associations), the networks (learning, supply, advocacy, standard-setting) that connect them, and the institutions (regulations, standards, norms, and cognitive routines) that shape their behaviour. This structural snapshot establishes what the system is built from before its dynamics are assessed.

3

Assess how well the system performs its key functions—the sub-processes through which it develops, such as knowledge development and diffusion, entrepreneurial experimentation, guidance of the search, market formation, resource mobilisation, and the creation of legitimacy. Drawing on the functions literature, the analyst characterises the functional pattern: which functions are strong, which are weak, and how they reinforce or constrain one another over the system's phase of development.

4

Compare the achieved functional pattern with the functionality the system would need given its phase and goals, and identify the inducement and blocking mechanisms behind the gaps. Blocking mechanisms—weak institutions, missing networks, poorly articulated demand, immature technology—explain why functions underperform, while inducement mechanisms explain virtuous dynamics that should be reinforced.

5

Derive policy implications by targeting the diagnosed blocking mechanisms and strengthening inducement mechanisms so as to improve the weak functions. Because interventions must fit the system's developmental phase, the analysis points to concrete, system-specific policy issues—standards, demand creation, network building, legitimacy support—rather than generic prescriptions.

Common pitfalls

  • Drawing the system boundary loosely or shifting it mid-analysis, so that structural and functional claims no longer refer to the same system.
  • Cataloguing structural components while never assessing the functions, producing a static description with no diagnostic value.
  • Reading the functions in isolation rather than as an interacting pattern that varies with the system's developmental phase.
  • Jumping to generic policy advice instead of targeting the specific blocking mechanisms the analysis actually identified.

Frequently asked questions

What are the structural components of a TIS?

Three classes. Actors—firms (incumbents and entrants), universities and research institutes, public bodies, users, and industry associations. Networks—the learning, supply, political, and standard-setting relationships connecting actors. Institutions—the formal rules (regulations, standards, policies) and informal norms and cognitive routines that shape behaviour. These components form the system's anatomy; the analysis then asks how well that anatomy performs its functions.

How does TIS analysis differ from Innovation System Functions Analysis?

They are closely related and share the functions vocabulary, but differ in emphasis. The Bergek et al. TIS scheme is the broader analytic frame: it starts from structural components, assesses the functional pattern, compares achieved with desired functionality, and diagnoses inducement and blocking mechanisms to derive policy. The functions-of-innovation-systems approach associated with Hekkert and Suurs focuses more tightly on the seven functions and operationalises them through event-history analysis and 'motors' of cumulative causation. In practice the two are often combined; this library cross-links them.

What is the difference between a TIS and a national innovation system?

A national innovation system takes a country as the unit of analysis and studies how its overall institutional and organisational set-up supports innovation across all sectors. A technological innovation system takes a single technology or knowledge field as the unit and studies the actors, networks, institutions, and functions specific to it, often across national borders. TIS is therefore better suited to explaining the rise of a particular emerging technology, whereas national systems explain broad cross-sector innovative performance.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Bergek, A., Jacobsson, S., Carlsson, B., Lindmark, S., & Rickne, A. (2008). Analyzing the functional dynamics of technological innovation systems: a scheme of analysis. Research Policy, 37(3), 407-429.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.
  2. Hekkert, M. P., Suurs, R. A. A., Negro, S. O., Kuhlmann, S., & Smits, R. E. H. M. (2007). Functions of innovation systems: a new approach for analysing technological change. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 74(4), 413-432.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.