Skip to content
Back to search results

Advocacy Coalition Framework

Introduced by
Paul Sabatier & Hank Jenkins-Smith
Year
1993
Type
Theory of the policy process
Family
Policy-process theory
Font size

What does it do?

The Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) is a theory of the policy process developed by Paul Sabatier and Hank Jenkins-Smith from the late 1980s and consolidated in their 1993 volume Policy Change and Learning.

It explains policy stability and change over long periods by analysing competing coalitions of actors within a policy subsystem who are bound together by shared beliefs. Policy change is understood as a function of the interaction among these belief-based coalitions, the policy-oriented learning that occurs over time, and external events and shocks that can shift the balance of power among them.

The intuition behind the method

Why does policy in an area like clean air or drug control sometimes stay frozen for years and then suddenly shift? The ACF answers: look not at individual agencies but at the whole subsystem of people who care about the issue — legislators, bureaucrats, scientists, journalists, interest groups — and notice that they cluster into rival coalitions that share deep beliefs about the problem. These coalitions fight, but because their core beliefs are sticky, the policy stalemate can persist for a decade or more. Real change usually needs an external jolt — an economic crisis, a disaster, a change of government — that reshuffles resources, or it comes through slow policy-oriented learning where evidence gradually moves the more negotiable, secondary beliefs. The unit to watch is the coalition and its beliefs, over a long horizon.

History

Paul Sabatier and Hank Jenkins-Smith developed the Advocacy Coalition Framework in the late 1980s as part of a broader effort to build better theories of the policy process, dissatisfied with the descriptive 'stages heuristic' then dominant. They set it out fully in the 1993 edited volume Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Over the following decades the framework was repeatedly revised — adding internal shocks, negotiated agreements and refinements to the belief and learning hypotheses — and tested in hundreds of studies worldwide, becoming one of the most prominent and empirically applied theories of the policy process.

When to use it

Use the ACF to understand and explain policy stability and change in a contested issue area over a long period, especially where technical information and competing belief systems are central — environmental, energy, health and regulatory politics are classic domains. It suits research questions about why coalitions form, how beliefs drive behaviour, and what conditions produce major versus minor change. It assumes a definable subsystem observable over roughly a decade and access to data on actors' beliefs and positions. It is less suited to short-term analysis, to settings without organised competing coalitions, or where the priority is forecasting a single decision rather than explaining long-run dynamics. It is one of several complementary lenses alongside multiple streams and punctuated equilibrium.

Limitations and considerations

  • Requires long time horizons and rich data on actors' beliefs that are demanding to obtain.
  • The boundaries of a subsystem and the membership of coalitions can be hard to define operationally.
  • Originated in pluralist U.S. settings and travels imperfectly to other political systems.
  • Tends to explain change after the fact better than it predicts when major change will occur.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Explains long-run policy stability and change, not just isolated decisions.
  • Centres the role of beliefs and learning, integrating ideas and technical information into policy analysis.
  • Provides a clear structure — subsystem, coalitions, belief tiers, shocks — that guides empirical study.
  • Has been extensively tested and refined across many countries and policy domains.

Applications

  • Explaining decades-long conflict and change in environmental and energy policy.
  • Analysing belief-driven coalitions in health, tobacco and drug-control policy.
  • Studying water and natural-resource management disputes among competing stakeholder groups.
  • Examining the role of scientific information and learning in technically complex regulation.
  • Comparing how coalitions and shocks drive policy change across different countries.

How it works

How it works

1

Analysis starts by delineating the policy subsystem — the set of actors from public and private organisations who are actively concerned with a policy problem within a geographic and substantive boundary, such as water management in a region. The subsystem, observed over a decade or more, is the ACF's primary unit of analysis, because meaningful policy change and learning play out over long time horizons.

2

Within the subsystem, actors are grouped into advocacy coalitions defined by shared belief systems. The framework distinguishes deep core beliefs (fundamental values), policy core beliefs (basic positions on the subsystem, which bind a coalition together), and secondary beliefs (more specific and negotiable). Mapping who holds which beliefs reveals the rival coalitions and the glue holding each together.

3

The framework then examines the two main engines of change: policy-oriented learning, in which actors revise beliefs in light of experience and evidence (typically affecting secondary rather than core beliefs), and external perturbations — socioeconomic shifts, crises, changes in governing coalition or impacts from other subsystems — that can alter resources and open opportunities for the disadvantaged coalition.

4

Finally, observed policy change is explained as the product of coalition competition shaped by learning and external shocks, sometimes mediated by policy brokers who seek workable compromises. Minor policy change is attributed mainly to learning that shifts secondary beliefs, whereas major change in policy core elements usually requires a significant external shock or, in later versions, an internal shock or negotiated agreement.

Common pitfalls

  • Drawing subsystem boundaries to fit a preferred narrative, biasing which actors count as coalition members.
  • Treating coalitions as fixed organisations rather than belief-based groupings that can shift over time.
  • Attributing major policy-core change to ordinary learning when the theory expects an external shock.
  • Studying too short a period to observe the decade-scale dynamics the framework is built to explain.

Frequently asked questions

What holds an advocacy coalition together?

Shared policy core beliefs. The ACF organises beliefs into three tiers: deep core beliefs (fundamental, near-religious values), policy core beliefs (basic normative and empirical positions about the subsystem), and secondary beliefs (specific, instrumental, more easily revised). It is the policy core beliefs that bind actors into a coalition and motivate sustained coordinated action over time. Because these beliefs are resistant to change, coalitions and the conflicts between them tend to be stable over long periods.

How does major policy change happen under the ACF?

The framework distinguishes minor from major change. Minor change — adjustments to secondary aspects of policy — can result from policy-oriented learning, as coalitions revise instrumental beliefs in light of evidence. Major change to the policy core, however, usually requires a significant external shock such as a crisis, a change in the governing coalition, or impacts from another subsystem that redistributes resources. Later versions added internal shocks and negotiated agreements as additional routes to major change.

How does the ACF differ from the multiple streams framework?

Both explain policy change but emphasise different mechanisms. The ACF focuses on belief-based coalitions competing within a subsystem over a decade or more, with learning and external shocks driving change. The multiple streams framework focuses on the coupling of separate problem, policy and politics streams at fleeting 'windows of opportunity', stressing ambiguity and timing rather than stable coalitions. The ACF is better for long-run, belief-driven dynamics; multiple streams is better for explaining how and when an issue rises onto the agenda.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Sabatier, P. A., & Jenkins-Smith, H. C. (Eds.) (1993). Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

    ISBN: 9780813316499
    Copied.