Policy Network Analysis
- Introduced by
- R. A. W. Rhodes & David Marsh (British school); broader governance-network tradition
- Year
- 1992
- Type
- Analysis of inter-organisational policy relationships
- Family
- Governance and network analysis
What does it do?
Policy network analysis examines policymaking as the product of relationships among interdependent actors — government agencies, interest groups, experts and others — who exchange resources such as information, money, legitimacy and authority.
In the influential British tradition associated with R. A. W. Rhodes and David Marsh, policy networks range along a continuum from tightly knit, exclusive 'policy communities' to loose, open 'issue networks', and the type of network is held to shape policy outcomes. More broadly, the approach applies the concepts and tools of social-network analysis to governance, treating the structure of ties among actors as a key explanatory variable.
The intuition behind the method
Policy is rarely made by a single authority issuing commands; it emerges from a web of organisations that need things from one another — a ministry needs an industry's data and cooperation, the industry needs favourable rules, experts supply legitimacy. Policy network analysis takes that web seriously as the unit of explanation. Instead of asking only what each actor wants, it asks how they are connected: is the network a small, stable club where a few insiders trade resources behind closed doors, or a sprawling, fluid arena where many actors come and go? The Rhodes-Marsh insight is that a closed 'policy community' tends to produce stable, incremental policy, while an open 'issue network' produces more volatile outcomes. Mapping the structure of relationships thus helps explain why policy in an area is stable or changeable, closed or contested.
History
The policy-network concept developed from American work on 'iron triangles' and Hugh Heclo's 'issue networks' in the 1970s and from German and Dutch governance research. The British school, led by R. A. W. Rhodes and David Marsh, systematised it, and their 1992 edited volume Policy Networks in British Government set out the influential continuum from cohesive policy communities to loose issue networks and linked network type to policy outcomes. In parallel, scholars increasingly applied formal social-network analysis to policy, and more recent governance-network research studies collaborative and multi-level networks quantitatively, making policy network analysis both a metaphor for governance and a rigorous methodological toolkit.
When to use it
Use policy network analysis when policymaking in a domain is shaped by relationships among many interdependent organisations and you want to explain the pattern of influence, stability or change. It suits the study of governance, sectoral policymaking, interest-group politics and multi-level or collaborative governance, and the quantitative variant is powerful where relational data can be collected. It assumes a definable set of actors and meaningful ties among them. It is less suited where decisions are made hierarchically by a single authority, where relational data cannot be obtained, or where the priority is individual actors' beliefs rather than the structure connecting them — for which the advocacy coalition framework may fit better. It complements stakeholder analysis and process theories of policymaking.
Limitations and considerations
- Network boundaries are hard to define and choices about them strongly affect results.
- Whether network structure causes outcomes or merely reflects them is contested.
- Quantitative analysis demands complete relational data that are difficult and costly to gather.
- The British typological tradition has been criticised as descriptive rather than genuinely explanatory.
Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.
Strengths
- Captures the relational, inter-organisational reality of modern governance.
- Links the structure of actor relationships to patterns of policy stability and change.
- Spans qualitative typologies and rigorous quantitative social-network methods.
- Identifies key brokers, coalitions and subgroups that actor-by-actor analysis misses.
Applications
- Explaining stability and change in sectoral policy domains such as agriculture or health.
- Analysing the influence of interest groups and their connections to government.
- Studying collaborative and multi-level governance arrangements.
- Identifying brokers and coalitions in environmental and climate-policy networks.
- Mapping how information and resources flow among actors in a policy subsystem.
How it works
How it works
The analyst first delimits the network of interest by defining the policy domain and the boundary criteria for inclusion — which actors count as part of the network around, say, agricultural or health policy. Because networks have no natural edges, setting explicit, defensible boundaries is a critical and consequential step that shapes everything that follows.
The actors within the boundary are identified and the ties among them are mapped — relationships of resource exchange, communication, collaboration, funding or influence — gathered through documents, interviews, surveys or coded data. This produces a relational dataset: not just a list of actors but a record of who is connected to whom and how, the raw material for structural analysis.
The structure of the network is then characterised, either qualitatively in the Rhodes-Marsh tradition — locating it on the policy-community-to-issue-network continuum by its membership, integration, resource distribution and stability — or quantitatively using social-network analysis measures such as density, centralisation and the centrality of individual actors to identify cohesion, key brokers and subgroups.
Finally the analyst relates the network's structure to policy processes and outcomes: arguing, for example, that a dense, closed policy community fosters stable, consensual, incremental policy while a sparse, open issue network produces contested, volatile outcomes. This step turns description of the network into explanation, using its structure to account for how and why policy in the domain develops as it does.
Common pitfalls
- Drawing the network boundary arbitrarily, which can determine the conclusions in advance.
- Inferring causal influence of structure from a correlation between network type and outcome.
- Mistaking missing data for absent ties, distorting density and centrality measures.
- Treating a network snapshot as static when memberships and relationships evolve over time.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a policy community and an issue network?
In the Rhodes-Marsh continuum, a policy community is a tightly integrated, stable and exclusive network with a limited number of members who share basic values, exchange resources frequently and exclude outsiders; it tends to produce consensual, incremental policy. An issue network is the opposite pole: a large, loose, unstable and open set of participants with fluctuating contact and limited consensus, associated with more contested and volatile policy. Most real networks fall somewhere between these ideal types, and locating a network on the continuum is a central task of the qualitative tradition.
How does policy network analysis relate to social-network analysis?
Social-network analysis is the general methodology for studying relationships among any set of entities, with formal measures such as density, centrality and clustering. Policy network analysis applies these ideas to governance, treating policy actors as nodes and their resource exchanges or interactions as ties. The qualitative British tradition uses the network idea more as an organising metaphor and typology, while the quantitative strand uses the full apparatus of social-network analysis to measure structure rigorously and relate it to outcomes. The two strands increasingly converge.
Why is defining the network boundary so important?
Because networks do not have natural edges, the analyst must decide who is in and who is out, and that decision can strongly shape the measured structure and the conclusions drawn. Include too few actors and you may miss the ties that matter; include too many and the network's distinctive features blur. Boundary specification should therefore be explicit and justified — by a positional criterion (formal membership), a reputational one (whom insiders name) or an event-based one (participation in decisions) — and analysts should test how sensitive their findings are to these choices.
Related methods
Sources
Marsh, D., & Rhodes, R. A. W. (Eds.) (1992). Policy Networks in British Government. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
ISBN: 9780198278528Copied.