Skip to content
Back to search results

WFNS Scale: World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies Subarachnoid Hemorrhage Scale

Introduced by
Drake and World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies Committee
Year
1988
Type
Clinician-rated
Family
Subarachnoid hemorrhage severity classification
Font size

What does it do?

The WFNS Scale is a standardized grading system for assessing severity and prognosis in subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) published by the World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies in 1988.

The five-point scale combines the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) with presence of motor deficit to classify SAH severity. The WFNS Scale is more objective than the earlier Hunt-Hess Scale and is increasingly preferred in contemporary neurosurgical practice, particularly in Europe and internationally.

The intuition behind the method

Subarachnoid hemorrhage severity reflects blood volume, lesion location, and degree of intracranial hypertension. The Glasgow Coma Scale quantifies consciousness level (eye opening, verbal response, motor response) on a validated 3-15 point scale, providing reproducible measurement compared to subjective descriptors (drowsy, stuporous, comatose). Adding motor deficit presence captures focal neurological injury. The combination of GCS + motor deficit provides more granular severity classification than Hunt-Hess alone, enabling more precise outcome prediction. WFNS grades I-II represent largely intact consciousness with <10% mortality; grades IV-V represent coma with >50% mortality regardless of intervention. The scale facilitates objective communication across neurosurgical teams and international standardization of SAH severity reporting.

History

The World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies established a committee in 1985 chaired by Charles Drake to develop a more objective, standardized grading scale for SAH severity, addressing limitations of the Hunt-Hess scale. The committee adopted the Glasgow Coma Scale, published by Teasdale and Jennett in 1974, as the consciousness assessment component. Drake published the WFNS Scale in the Journal of Neurosurgery in 1988, proposing the five-grade system combining GCS with motor deficit. The WFNS Scale gained adoption in European and international centers throughout the 1990s-2000s. Modern SAH registries (Subarachnoid Hemorrhage International Research by Endovascular Neurosurgery, SIREN; European SAH registries) predominantly use WFNS grading, though Hunt-Hess remains prevalent in North American centers. Contemporary practice increasingly integrates both scales or favors WFNS for prognostic studies.

When to use it

Indicated for all patients with confirmed subarachnoid hemorrhage (aneurysmal or non-aneurysmal) at admission and reassessed if clinical deterioration occurs. WFNS grade guides: (1) surgical urgency and timing decisions (good-grade patients offered surgery within 48 hours; poor-grade patients emergent or palliative); (2) prognostic counseling of families regarding expected outcomes; (3) ICU resource allocation (intensive monitoring vs comfort care); (4) stratification in clinical trials comparing SAH management strategies. Increasingly preferred over Hunt-Hess in modern practice due to objective GCS component. Used internationally, particularly in Europe, Asia, and increasingly in North America.

Limitations and considerations

  • Ordinal scale without interval properties; Grade I to II may not represent equivalent severity difference as Grade IV to V.
  • Requires trained clinician to perform accurate GCS assessment; inter-rater variability in GCS components (verbal response, eye opening in intubated patient) impacts grade assignment.
  • Does not incorporate imaging severity (CT blood volume, intraventricular hemorrhage, aneurysm size/location), known to independently predict outcome; clinical grade alone may be insufficient.
  • GCS validity limited in sedated or intubated patients (eye opening, verbal response scores unreliable); WFNS grade assessment deferred until sedation cleared or requires GCS adjustment protocols.
  • Motor deficit definition somewhat subjective; absence of documented focal deficit does not exclude minor weakness; minor hemiparesis might be missed in drowsy patient.
  • Limited data comparing WFNS to Hunt-Hess in same cohorts; head-to-head studies show modest differences (correlation r=0.7-0.8) with overlapping prognostic accuracy.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Incorporates Glasgow Coma Scale, an objective, validated consciousness measurement tool reducing inter-rater variability compared to subjective Hunt-Hess descriptors.
  • Distinguishes motor deficit presence, which adds specificity to severity classification beyond consciousness level alone.
  • Published outcome data across large multicenter cohorts (European SAH registries, Japanese multicenter studies); prognostic accuracy well-established across patient populations.
  • More granular than Hunt-Hess: WFNS incorporates GCS 11-14 range separately, better discriminating between moderate-consciousness-level patients.
  • Facilitates comparison across international studies due to standardized GCS use; increasingly adopted in major SAH trials.
  • Simpler algorithm than Hunt-Hess (binary combination of GCS range and motor deficit yes/no) with less subjective interpretation.

Applications

  • SAH severity classification and prognostic communication: WFNS grade provides objective severity quantification enabling standardized family counseling regarding mortality risk, expected functional outcome, and appropriateness of aggressive intervention.
  • Neurosurgical decision-making and operative urgency: WFNS I-II grades are good-grade candidates for elective aneurysm repair; grades III-V trigger urgent or emergent surgical evaluation with shared decision-making regarding prognosis and treatment goals.
  • Clinical trial design and stratification: major SAH intervention trials (CONSCIOUS-1, CONSCIOUS-2, SAHIT) stratify randomization by WFNS grade ensuring balanced allocation and subgroup analyses of treatment effect by grade.
  • Outcomes research and quality metrics: multicenter SAH registries track 30-day mortality and functional outcome by WFNS grade, enabling hospital performance benchmarking and quality improvement targeting.
  • Predictor variable in prognostic modeling: multivariate models incorporating WFNS grade, CT findings (modified Fisher scale), aneurysm characteristics, and treatment variables identify independent prognostic factors and build prediction algorithms.
  • International standardization and data comparison: WFNS adoption facilitates SAH outcome comparison across countries and continents, identifying geographic variations in outcomes and best practices.

How it works

How it works

1

At bedside following confirmed SAH diagnosis (CT showing subarachnoid blood or CSF xanthochromia on LP), neurologist or neurosurgeon performs Glasgow Coma Scale assessment: (1) Eye opening: spontaneous (4), to verbal command (3), to pain (2), no response (1). (2) Verbal response: oriented (5), confused (4), inappropriate (3), incomprehensible sounds (2), no response (1). (3) Motor response: obeys commands (6), localizes to pain (5), withdraws from pain (4), abnormal flexion/decorticate (3), abnormal extension/decerebrate (2), no response (1). GCS total 3-15. Simultaneously, assess focal neurological deficit: presence of motor weakness (hemiparesis, hemiplegia, arm/leg drift, asymmetric strength), speech deficit, pupil abnormality, or other focal sign. Classification into WFNS grade per algorithm combining GCS and motor deficit status. Examination performed once patient stable and not under acute sedation.

Formula
Clinical neurological assessment at admission or within 24 hours of confirmed subarachnoid hemorrhage. Examiner evaluates level of consciousness using Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) and presence of motor deficit on neurological examination. Classification into five grades based on GCS score combined with focal motor deficit presence. Rapid bedside evaluation; no equipment beyond standard neurological examination required.
2

Five-point ordinal scale based on GCS and motor deficit: Grade I = GCS 15, no motor deficit. Grade II = GCS 13-14, no motor deficit. Grade III = GCS 13-14 WITH motor deficit, OR GCS 11-12 WITHOUT motor deficit. Grade IV = GCS 11-12 WITH motor deficit, OR GCS 8-10 with any motor deficit. Grade V = GCS 3-7 with any motor deficit. Motor deficit defined as abnormal strength on neurological examination, aphasia/dysarthria, or pupil abnormality. No intermediate grades; each patient assigned single grade. GCS score documented separately for research purposes.

Formula
Five-grade ordinal scale combining Glasgow Coma Scale and motor deficit: Grade I = GCS 15, no focal deficit. Grade II = GCS 13-14, no focal deficit. Grade III = GCS 13-14, with focal deficit; or GCS 11-12, no focal deficit. Grade IV = GCS 11-12 with focal deficit; or GCS 8-10, any motor deficit. Grade V = GCS 3-7 any motor deficit.
3

WFNS grade stratifies SAH prognosis and surgical urgency. Grade I (GCS 15, no deficit): excellent prognosis, <5% operative mortality, 85%+ favorable outcome; surgery elective within 48-72 hours. Grade II (GCS 13-14, no deficit): good prognosis, 5-10% mortality, 75-85% favorable outcome; surgery urgent within 24-48 hours. Grade III (mixed): intermediate prognosis, 10-20% mortality, 60-70% favorable outcome; surgery urgent within 24 hours. Grade IV (GCS 8-12 or ≤10 with deficit): poor prognosis, 40-70% mortality, <30% favorable outcome; surgery emergent if offered. Grade V (GCS 3-7): very poor prognosis, 50-80% mortality, <10% favorable outcome; surgery considered life-saving but outcome severely limited. Deterioration during hospitalization (rebleed, vasospasm) may upgrade grade, triggering emergent intervention.

Formula
WFNS grade predicts 30-day mortality and functional outcome in SAH. Grade I: ~5% mortality, 80-90% favorable outcome. Grade II: ~5-10% mortality, 75-85% favorable outcome. Grade III: ~15% mortality, 60-70% favorable outcome. Grade IV: 40-60% mortality, 20-30% favorable outcome. Grade V: >50-80% mortality, <10% favorable outcome. Grades I-II considered good grade; IV-V poor grade. WFNS more objective than Hunt-Hess due to GCS incorporation; correlates with Hunt-Hess but with significant overlap.

Common pitfalls

  • Administering WFNS grade during active resuscitation or sedation; GCS cannot be reliably assessed in sedated patient. Grade assignment should occur after initial stabilization and sedation clearance.
  • Confusing WFNS with Hunt-Hess grading; the two systems yield similar but non-identical grades for the same patient. Always specify which system used when reporting outcomes or making clinical decisions.
  • Over-interpreting motor deficit absence as reassuring; subtle hemiparesis or speech abnormality might be overlooked in drowsy patient. Detailed cranial nerve and motor exam required for accurate deficit assessment.
  • Assigning WFNS grade based on radiology findings (CT blood volume) without direct neurological examination; clinical grade determination requires bedside assessment, not imaging alone.
  • Using initial field or paramedic GCS (potentially inaccurate) instead of hospital physician GCS for grade assignment. Neurosurgeon should independently document GCS and WFNS grade.
  • Failing to reassess and upgrade WFNS grade if rebleed or vasospasm-related deterioration occurs; acute change may upgrade grade, changing management (emergency surgery vs comfort care).

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between WFNS and Hunt-Hess scales?

Hunt-Hess uses subjective descriptors (alert, drowsy, confused, stuporous, comatose) and presence of focal deficit. WFNS uses objective Glasgow Coma Scale (3-15) combined with focal deficit. For equivalent severity, WFNS is often lower grade than Hunt-Hess due to different thresholds (e.g., GCS 13-14 is Grade II WFNS but might be Grade II-III Hunt-Hess if drowsy/confused). Both predict outcome with similar accuracy (r=0.7-0.8 correlation). WFNS is more objective; Hunt-Hess is simpler. Most institutions use one system consistently; cite system used in publications.

Can WFNS grade be assigned in intubated patients?

With caution. GCS assessment in intubated patients is problematic: eye opening and verbal response are not evaluable (patient sedated and intubated); only motor response can be reliably scored. Some neurosurgeons use 'sedated GCS' or 'E1VtM3' notation (eye opening 1, verbal intubated, motor 3 example) acknowledging limitation. Better practice is to defer WFNS grade assessment until sedation clearance (24-48 hours post-extubation) when full GCS can be documented. Pre-intubation GCS (recorded by paramedics or ED) can be used if available, but acknowledge limitation.

How does WFNS relate to CT imaging severity scales like Fisher Scale?

WFNS assesses clinical severity (consciousness + neurological deficit); Fisher Scale assesses radiological severity (amount and distribution of subarachnoid blood on CT). The two are imperfectly correlated (r=0.5-0.7): small bleeds can produce severe deficits if in eloquent location; large bleeds can present with minimal deficits. Both WFNS and Fisher Scale independently predict outcome. Combined use (WFNS + Fisher) better predicts 30-day mortality and vasospasm risk than either alone. Report both when available.

What is considered a 'motor deficit' in WFNS grading?

Motor deficit includes: (1) Hemiparesis or hemiplegia (asymmetric strength 4/5 or lower on Motor Scale). (2) Aphasia or dysarthria (language/speech abnormality). (3) Pupil abnormality (anisocoria, blown pupil). (4) Ataxia or coordination abnormality. (5) Cranial nerve deficit (facial droop, eye deviation). Not included: drowsiness alone (part of GCS), headache, photophobia, nuchal rigidity (meningeal signs but not focal motor deficit). Absence of documented focal deficit means no motor deficit for WFNS grade determination, even if subtle weakness might be present.

Does WFNS grade change if patient improves clinically?

WFNS grade typically refers to admission/initial assessment grade used for prognostic correlation. If patient improves clinically (e.g., GCS improves from 13 to 15), the improved GCS is documented but the original WFNS grade stands for outcome analysis. Some centers reassess WFNS at 48-72 hours or after intervention (vasospasm treatment, surgery) to document interval change, but the admission grade remains the prognostic predictor used in outcome studies. Always specify timing of grade assessment.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Drake, C. G. (1988). Report of the World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies Committee on a universal subarachnoid hemorrhage grading scale. Journal of Neurosurgery, 68(6), 985-986.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.