Skip to content
Back to search results

Institutional Venn Diagram

Introduced by
Participatory Rural Appraisal tradition (Robert Chambers and colleagues)
Year
1994
Type
Participatory diagram of local institutions sized and positioned by importance and closeness
Family
Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA)
Font size

What does it do?

An institutional Venn diagram, often called a chapati or relationship diagram, is a participatory rural appraisal tool in which community members represent the organizations and institutions in their lives as circles and arrange them to show importance and relationships.

The size of each circle reflects how important or influential the institution is, and its position — how far from the community and how much it overlaps with other circles — shows how close and how connected it is. The finished diagram is a community-drawn map of its institutional landscape and the social distance between people and the bodies that affect them.

The intuition behind the method

People relate to a tangle of institutions — village councils, churches, cooperatives, clinics, NGOs, government offices, moneylenders — and they have clear intuitions about which ones matter, which are remote, and which work together or against each other. The Venn diagram externalizes that mental map using two simple visual grammars everyone understands: bigger means more important, and closer or more overlapping means more connected. By cutting and placing paper circles together, a group negotiates a shared picture of who holds influence, who is marginal, and where the gaps and overlaps in the institutional web lie — far more vividly than a list of organizations ever could.

History

The institutional Venn or chapati diagram spread through the participatory rural appraisal movement of the late 1980s and early 1990s that Robert Chambers documents in his 1994 account of PRA, where movable paper circles became a favourite way to elicit how communities perceive the organizations around them. In Whose Reality Counts? (1997) Chambers situates such diagramming within his wider argument that local people can analyze their own complex realities visually and that outsiders should hand over the stick. The nickname chapati diagram comes from the resemblance of the overlapping circles to flatbreads laid out and overlapping on a surface.

When to use it

Use an institutional Venn diagram when you want to understand, from the community's perspective, which organizations matter, how close or remote they feel, and how they relate to one another — for example in stakeholder analysis, institutional appraisal, or studies of governance and access to services. It suits settings with a discernible set of named institutions and a group that deals with them. It assumes participants can agree on relative importance and closeness through discussion. It is less useful for mapping interpersonal networks (use sociometric methods), for very large institutional fields, or where the politics of naming institutions makes open discussion unsafe.

Limitations and considerations

  • Size and distance are qualitative judgments, not measurements, so the diagram is interpretive rather than quantitative.
  • Results depend strongly on who is in the room; different groups will draw markedly different institutional maps.
  • Sensitive power relations may go unspoken, especially where powerful institutions are present or represented.
  • It captures a perceived snapshot and does not show how institutional relationships change over time.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Visualizes the relative importance, closeness, and overlap of institutions in a single intuitive picture the group co-creates.
  • Surfaces which bodies are central and which are marginal from the community's own point of view, not the analyst's.
  • Reveals gaps, overlaps, and strained or missing relationships in the institutional web that lists cannot show.
  • Low-literacy and tactile, using movable circles that invite negotiation and make stakeholder analysis participatory.

Applications

  • Stakeholder and institutional analysis for development projects and programme design.
  • Mapping community access to services and identifying which bodies are remote or missing.
  • Studying local governance, power, and the relationships among formal and informal institutions.
  • Evaluating how an intervention or organization is perceived in relation to existing institutions.
  • Comparing the institutional maps drawn by different groups, such as women and men or different wealth strata.

How it works

How it works

1

The group brainstorms all the institutions and organizations — formal and informal, internal and external — that play a role in community life, from local committees and faith groups to NGOs and government departments. Generating the list collectively ensures it reflects what the community actually engages with rather than the researcher's assumptions about who is present.

2

Each institution is given a paper circle (or a drawn one) whose diameter is chosen by the group to represent its importance or influence in their lives: the more significant the institution, the larger its circle. Negotiating relative sizes makes the group debate and reach a shared judgment about which bodies matter most.

3

The circles are then placed on a sheet or on the ground relative to a circle representing the community: institutions felt to be close are placed near it, distant ones far away, and circles are made to overlap to the degree that the institutions interact or share members. Separate circles mean no contact, touching circles mean information flows, and overlapping circles mean active cooperation or joint membership.

4

As the layout takes shape the facilitator draws out the reasoning — why one body is large and central while another is small and remote, what the overlaps and gaps mean, where relationships are strained or absent. This discussion, recorded alongside the diagram, turns the picture into an analysis of access, influence, and institutional gaps.

Common pitfalls

  • Pre-printing a fixed list of institutions instead of letting the group name them, biasing the field of view.
  • Letting dominant participants dictate sizes and positions so the diagram reflects one faction's reality.
  • Treating overlap as if it had a precise meaning without probing what each placement actually represents to the group.
  • Recording the finished circles but not the discussion, losing the explanations that make the diagram analytically useful.

Frequently asked questions

Why is it called a chapati diagram?

Because the circles representing institutions, drawn or cut from paper and laid out overlapping on the ground, look like chapatis — round flatbreads — scattered and overlapping on a surface. The nickname stuck within the PRA community as a friendly, low-jargon name for the institutional relationship diagram.

What do circle size, distance, and overlap each mean?

Size represents the importance or influence of an institution, with bigger circles for more significant bodies. Distance from the community circle represents social or practical closeness, with nearer circles more accessible. Overlap represents the strength of the relationship between institutions, from separate (no contact) through touching (some exchange) to overlapping (active cooperation or shared membership).

How is this different from a stakeholder network map?

A formal stakeholder or network map usually plots actors and labelled ties, often quantitatively. The Venn diagram is a participatory, qualitative tool in which the community itself encodes importance through size and relationship through overlap, prioritizing local perception and shared negotiation over precise network metrics. The two can complement each other.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Chambers, R. (1994). The origins and practice of participatory rural appraisal. World Development, 22(7), 953–969.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.
  2. Chambers, R. (1997). Whose Reality Counts? Putting the First Last. London: ITDG Publishing.

    ISBN: 9781853393860
    Copied.