Skip to content
Back to search results

Valuation Studies Method

Introduced by
Claes-Fredrik Helgesson, Fabian Muniesa, Michèle Lamont
Year
2013
Type
Practice-oriented method for studying valuation
Family
Sociology of valuation and evaluation
Font size

What does it do?

The valuation studies method treats valuation—the production, measurement, ordering, and contestation of worth—as a social practice to be studied empirically rather than a hidden mental act or a settled economic fact.

Consolidated by Claes-Fredrik Helgesson and Fabian Muniesa and complemented by Michèle Lamont's comparative sociology of valuation and evaluation, it follows how rankings, metrics, prices, and evaluation procedures actually do their work, and asks how worth comes to be, by whom, with which devices, and to what effect.

The intuition behind the method

Worth feels natural—a wine is good, a university is top-ranked, a startup is worth a billion dollars—as if value were simply discovered. The valuation studies method refuses this. It treats every act of valuing as work: someone built the ranking, chose the metric, ran the tasting, set the price. So instead of asking 'what is this worth?', the analyst asks 'how is this being made worthy, and by whom, with what tools?'. A university ranking is not a mirror of quality but a device that produces a particular ordering, rewards some behaviours, and provokes disputes. Following that work in action—the 'valography'—is the method.

History

Valuation studies coalesced as a self-conscious field around 2013 with the founding of the journal Valuation Studies, whose opening editorial by Claes-Fredrik Helgesson and Fabian Muniesa, 'For what it's worth', called for the empirical study of valuation as practice. It drew together several streams: the STS and economic-sociology work on market devices and performativity (Callon, Muniesa), Boltanski and Thévenot's orders of worth, and Michèle Lamont's comparative sociology of valuation and evaluation, articulated in her 2012 Annual Review essay. The field rapidly grew across studies of rankings, metrics, markets, and audit.

When to use it

Use the valuation studies method when your object is the social production of worth—how something comes to be ranked, rated, priced, or judged—and you want to study that process empirically as it happens. It suits research on rankings and metrics, markets and pricing, peer review and credit assessment, audit and impact evaluation, and disputes over quality or merit. It assumes valuation is a practice equipped by devices and shaped by competing registers of worth, best accessed through ethnography, documents, and interviews. It is less appropriate when you simply need a valuation produced (the method studies valuing, it does not perform it), or when the relevant valuing is inaccessible to observation.

Limitations and considerations

  • Its interpretive, practice-based stance resists generalisation and quantified comparison across many valuation sites.
  • The breadth of 'valuation' risks conceptual sprawl, making it hard to bound what the method does and does not cover.
  • Close observation of valuation in action requires access to often confidential settings such as rating committees or panels.
  • It analyses how worth is produced but offers little guidance on whether a given valuation is itself good or just.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Reframes value from a given fact into an observable practice, opening rankings, metrics, and prices to empirical scrutiny.
  • Bridges STS, economic sociology, and cultural sociology, drawing on market devices, orders of worth, and comparative evaluation.
  • Foregrounds the reactivity of valuation—how being measured changes the measured—which other approaches treat as mere noise.
  • Reveals the politics and devices behind apparently neutral indicators, exposing whose criteria of worth prevail.

Applications

  • Studying how university, hospital, and journal rankings are constructed and how institutions react to them.
  • Analysing peer review, grant panels, and prize juries as sites where scientific and artistic merit is produced and contested.
  • Investigating credit ratings, ESG scores, and financial valuation devices and their market and political effects.
  • Examining how prices and market valuations are assembled through calculative devices in specific markets.
  • Tracing how impact assessment, audit, and performance metrics reshape public services and professional work.

How it works

How it works

1

Identify a site where valuation is being done: a ranking exercise, a market, a peer-review panel, a credit-rating process, a wine tasting, an impact assessment. Helgesson and Muniesa frame valuation broadly as any social practice of assessing or producing worth, so the analyst chooses a setting where worth is actively at stake and can be observed in the making.

2

Document the valuation practices ethnographically and through documents and interviews: who values, what procedures they follow, what is counted and what is excluded, how disagreements are handled. The emphasis is on valuation as action—'valography', the close empirical study of valuing in practice—rather than on abstract theories of value.

3

Analyse the valuation devices that organise and equip the practice: scoring rubrics, indicators, league tables, pricing formulas, rating scales, software. Drawing on the STS interest in market devices, the analyst shows how these instruments are not neutral measures but active participants that shape what worth turns out to be.

4

Trace the orders of worth and registers of evaluation at play—market value, scientific merit, civic good, aesthetic quality—and how actors invoke, combine, or clash over them. Following Lamont, the analyst attends to the cultural scripts and criteria through which evaluators judge, and to how legitimacy and consensus are produced or contested across settings.

5

Assess the effects and reactivity of valuation: how being ranked, rated, or priced changes the behaviour of those valued, redistributes resources and reputation, and feeds back into the valuation itself. The analysis links the situated practice of valuing to the wider social orderings it helps create and entrench.

Common pitfalls

  • Treating valuation devices as transparent measures of pre-existing value rather than as instruments that help constitute it.
  • Reducing the plurality of registers of worth to economic value alone and missing civic, scientific, or aesthetic orders.
  • Ignoring reactivity—the way actors game and reshape themselves around a metric—and so misreading the metric's meaning.
  • Conflating the analyst's own judgement of worth with a description of how the actors themselves produce and contest worth.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between valuation and evaluation in this method?

Helgesson and Muniesa note that valuation usefully covers both senses at once: the production of worth (making something valuable, as in pricing or rating) and the assessment of worth (judging the value of something, as in peer review). English conveniently lets 'valuation' span both. The method studies the full arc—how worth is simultaneously produced and assessed in practice—rather than separating an objective value from a subjective judgement of it.

What is a 'valography'?

A valography is a close empirical study of valuation in action—an ethnographic or documentary account of how a particular instance of valuing actually unfolds: who does it, with which devices, following what procedures, invoking which criteria of worth, and with what consequences. The term signals the method's commitment to describing valuing as a situated practice rather than theorising value in the abstract, paralleling how an ethnography describes a culture in action.

How does this method relate to actor-network theory and market-device studies?

It is a close descendant. The STS work on market devices and performativity—how calculative tools and formulas help enact the realities they purport to measure—feeds directly into valuation studies, and many practitioners share ANT's commitment to following devices and associations symmetrically. Valuation studies adds an explicit focus on worth and its plural registers, and it brings ANT-style attention to devices into dialogue with cultural sociology's interest in evaluative criteria and legitimacy.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Helgesson, C.-F., & Muniesa, F. (2013). For what it's worth: an introduction to valuation studies. Valuation Studies, 1(1), 1-10.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.
  2. Lamont, M. (2012). Toward a comparative sociology of valuation and evaluation. Annual Review of Sociology, 38, 201-221.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.