Skip to content
Back to search results

Social Relations Approach

Introduced by
Naila Kabeer
Year
1994
Type
Applied gender analysis framework
Family
Gender and development planning frameworks
Font size

What does it do?

The Social Relations Approach, developed by Naila Kabeer at the Institute of Development Studies in the early 1990s, is a framework for analysing gender inequality as a product of social relations embedded in institutions rather than as a matter of women's roles alone.

It treats human well-being and empowerment as the goal of development, examines how four key institutions — the state, the market, the community, and the family or kinship — produce and reproduce inequality through their rules, resources, people, activities, and distribution of power, and traces the causes of inequality at immediate, underlying, and structural levels.

The intuition behind the method

Ask why a girl in a poor household is pulled out of school while her brother stays. The immediate cause might be a lack of school fees. But underneath sit decisions about who is worth investing in, and beneath those lie deep structures — laws, markets, customs, and family norms — that make daughters look like a poorer bet. Kabeer's framework refuses to stop at the visible roles women play; it asks how the rules and resources of the household, the market, the state, and the community combine to make that outcome seem natural, and it keeps the focus on whether interventions actually expand women's well-being and capacity to choose.

History

Naila Kabeer, an economist and social theorist at the Institute of Development Studies, set out the approach in her 1994 book Reversed Realities: Gender Hierarchies in Development Thought, which critiqued mainstream development planning for its gender blindness and proposed a relational, institutional alternative. She extended its empowerment dimension in a widely cited 1999 article, Resources, Agency, Achievements, defining empowerment as the expansion of the ability to make strategic life choices. The framework drew on feminist institutional economics and social-relations theory and was catalogued alongside the Harvard and Moser frameworks in the Oxfam Guide to Gender-Analysis Frameworks, where it is generally presented as the most structurally ambitious of the three.

When to use it

Use the Social Relations Approach when the aim is to understand and confront the institutional and structural roots of gender inequality rather than simply to catalogue women's roles, especially in policy analysis, programme design, and macro-level development work. It is well suited to revealing how the market, state, community, and family jointly produce disadvantage and to keeping empowerment and well-being as the measure of success. It is less appropriate when a rapid, concrete field profile is needed, since the framework is demanding, abstract, and data-hungry; its institutional and structural analysis can be hard to operationalise quickly and requires analysts comfortable with conceptual depth.

Limitations and considerations

  • Conceptually demanding and abstract, requiring analysts comfortable with institutional and structural analysis.
  • Data-hungry and slow compared with concrete role-mapping tools, making it harder to apply rapidly in the field.
  • Its breadth across four institutions and three causal levels can produce analyses too sprawling to translate into a focused plan.
  • Offers a powerful diagnostic but relatively little prescriptive guidance on how to implement institutional change.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Analyses gender inequality relationally and institutionally rather than reducing it to women's individual roles.
  • Shows how supposedly gender-neutral institutions such as the market and the state actively reproduce inequality.
  • Separates immediate, underlying, and structural causes, guarding against interventions that treat only symptoms.
  • Keeps human well-being and empowerment, defined as the capacity for strategic choice, as the explicit goal of development.

Applications

  • Analysing how the state, market, community, and household jointly produce a specific gender inequality such as girls' lower school enrolment.
  • Designing development policy that targets the underlying and structural causes of disadvantage rather than its symptoms.
  • Assessing whether an intervention expands women's agency and capacity for strategic life choices, not just their resources.
  • Examining how a market reform or social policy presented as gender-neutral redistributes power across the sexes.
  • Framing empowerment indicators around resources, agency, and achievements in monitoring and evaluation.

How it works

How it works

1

The approach starts from a concept of development as the expansion of human well-being, with three dimensions — survival, security, and autonomy — rather than economic growth or efficiency. It distinguishes well-being outcomes from the agency and resources that produce them, a distinction Kabeer later sharpened into her influential definition of empowerment as the expansion of people's ability to make strategic life choices in contexts where that ability was previously denied. Setting well-being and empowerment, not productivity, as the explicit goal frames every later step around whose welfare and whose choices an intervention serves.

2

Gender is then analysed not as a fixed attribute of individuals but as a set of social relations — the structural rules and practices that govern who has what, who does what, and who decides — which position women and men differently and unequally. The approach insists these relations are not confined to the household but run across institutions, so that the labels people carry (worker, citizen, household head, client) are themselves produced by relations of power. This relational lens is what distinguishes the framework from role-mapping approaches that take individuals and their tasks as the unit of analysis.

3

The heart of the framework is institutional analysis across four interlinked domains — state, market, community, and family/kinship — each examined along five dimensions: rules (how things are done), resources (what is used and produced), people (who is in, who is out, who does what), activities (what is done), and power (who decides and whose interests are served). The claim is that all institutions, even those presenting themselves as gender-neutral like the market or the state, carry and reproduce gender inequality. Mapping the five dimensions across the four institutions exposes how disadvantage is manufactured and transmitted between them.

4

Finally the analysis traces the causes of a given problem at three levels: immediate causes (the proximate factors visible at the point of the problem), underlying causes (the institutional rules and resource distributions that generate them), and structural or root causes (the deep, often taken-for-granted norms, laws, and economic structures). By distinguishing these levels, the framework guards against interventions that treat only symptoms and pushes analysts to identify the institutional and structural changes needed for lasting transformation, consistent with its well-being and empowerment goals.

Common pitfalls

  • Treating gender as a property of individuals or a list of roles, abandoning the relational lens that defines the approach.
  • Analysing only the household and ignoring how the market, state, and community produce and transmit inequality.
  • Stopping at immediate causes and designing interventions that relieve symptoms while leaving structural causes untouched.
  • Letting the four-institution, three-level matrix sprawl into description without converging on the changes that matter for well-being.

Frequently asked questions

How does the Social Relations Approach differ from the Harvard and Moser frameworks?

The Harvard Framework maps who does what and who controls what; the Moser Framework adds practical versus strategic needs and a policy spectrum. Kabeer's approach is more structural still: it treats gender as social relations embedded in four institutions — state, market, community, family — and traces causes at immediate, underlying, and structural levels. Where the others centre women's roles, the Social Relations Approach analyses the relations and institutions that produce inequality in the first place.

What are the four institutions in the framework?

The state, the market, the community, and the family or kinship. Each is examined along five dimensions — rules, resources, people, activities, and power. The central claim is that all four, including those that present themselves as gender-neutral such as the market and the state, carry and reproduce gender inequality, and that disadvantage is transmitted between them, so analysis cannot stop at the household.

How does Kabeer define empowerment in this framework?

In her 1999 article she defines empowerment as the process by which people who have been denied the ability to make strategic life choices acquire that ability. She breaks it into three interrelated dimensions — resources (the preconditions), agency (the process, including decision-making and bargaining), and achievements (the outcomes). This definition keeps the framework focused on expanding women's real capacity to choose, not merely on delivering inputs.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Kabeer, N. (1994). Reversed Realities: Gender Hierarchies in Development Thought. Verso, London.

    ISBN: 9780860915843
    Copied.
  2. Kabeer, N. (1999). Resources, agency, achievements: Reflections on the measurement of women's empowerment. Development and Change, 30(3), 435–464.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.