Skip to content
Back to search results

Responsible Research and Innovation Assessment

Introduced by
Jack Stilgoe, Richard Owen, Phil Macnaghten
Year
2013
Type
Normative governance and reflexive-assessment process
Family
Responsible innovation and technology governance
Font size

What does it do?

Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) assessment is an approach to governing science and innovation that asks not only whether a technology works but whether it is desirable, and seeks to align research and innovation with the values, needs, and expectations of society.

The influential Stilgoe-Owen-Macnaghten framework operationalises this through four dimensions—anticipation, reflexivity, inclusion, and responsiveness (AIRR)—that are built into the innovation process so that direction and purpose, not just risk and product, become objects of deliberate care.

The intuition behind the method

Conventional governance of technology tends to arrive late, asking after the fact whether a product is safe and acceptable. RRI flips this by treating the question 'should we be doing this, and in whose interest?' as part of the work of innovation itself. The AIRR framework gives this practical handles: anticipate where the innovation might lead before committing; reflect honestly on the assumptions, purposes, and uncertainties driving it; include diverse publics and stakeholders in the conversation rather than just experts; and—crucially—be willing and able to change direction in response to what anticipation, reflection, and inclusion reveal. Responsiveness is what makes the first three dimensions more than talk.

History

Responsible Research and Innovation crystallised around 2010-2013 in European science-policy discourse, building on earlier traditions of technology assessment, ELSI (ethical, legal and social implications) research, and anticipatory governance. Owen, Macnaghten, and Stilgoe's 2012 article reframed the agenda as 'science for society, with society', and their 2013 Research Policy paper articulated the four-dimensional anticipation-reflexivity-inclusion-responsiveness framework that became canonical. RRI was institutionalised as a cross-cutting priority in the European Union's Horizon 2020 programme, spawning assessment frameworks, indicators, and practical toolkits, and connecting to parallel North American work on anticipatory governance of emerging technologies such as nanotechnology.

When to use it

Use RRI assessment when the direction and societal acceptability of an emerging technology—not merely its technical performance or downstream risk—are at stake, and when there is genuine scope to shape how the innovation develops. It suits publicly funded research, emerging and potentially controversial technologies, and innovation systems seeking to build legitimacy and public trust. RRI assumes that innovation has a direction that can and should be deliberately steered, that diverse publics have a legitimate role in that steering, and that institutions are willing to act on what deliberation reveals. It is less applicable where direction is already fixed and irreversible, where there is no institutional willingness to respond, or where 'responsibility' risks becoming a procedural label with no real influence on practice.

Limitations and considerations

  • The framework is normative and process-oriented, offering no fixed metric of 'responsibility', which makes outcomes hard to assess objectively.
  • Responsiveness—the integrative dimension—is the hardest to achieve, and without it the approach can collapse into procedural box-ticking.
  • Meaningful anticipation and inclusion are resource-intensive and demand skills and time that many projects lack.
  • Powerful actors can co-opt RRI as a legitimation exercise, performing responsibility without ceding any real influence over direction.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Addresses the purposes and direction of innovation, not just its products and risks, broadening governance beyond safety and acceptability.
  • Provides a clear, actionable four-dimension framework (AIRR) that translates an abstract ideal into practices teams can adopt.
  • Embeds anticipation and public deliberation upstream, while there is still room to shape an emerging technology.
  • Builds legitimacy and public trust by aligning research with societal values and including affected voices in its framing.

Applications

  • Embedding responsibility criteria into research-funding calls and project evaluation (e.g. EU Horizon programmes).
  • Governing emerging technologies such as nanotechnology, synthetic biology, AI, and geoengineering.
  • Designing upstream public-engagement and deliberation around contested innovations.
  • Guiding corporate responsible-innovation and ethics-by-design practices in technology firms.
  • Structuring anticipatory and reflexive assessment within large research consortia and infrastructures.
  • Developing institutional indicators and toolkits to monitor RRI uptake across a research system.

How it works

How it works

1

Anticipate. Systematically explore the plausible intended and unintended consequences, opportunities, and risks of the innovation before they are locked in, using methods such as scenarios, horizon scanning, and 'what if' analysis. Anticipation widens the range of futures considered and surfaces issues while there is still room to act on them.

2

Foster reflexivity. Encourage researchers and institutions to examine critically their own assumptions, values, commitments, and the limits of their knowledge—holding a mirror to the purposes and motivations behind the work, and acknowledging that science cannot resolve every uncertainty or value question on its own.

3

Include. Open up the framing and direction of the innovation to a plurality of voices—publics, users, and affected stakeholders, not just technical experts—through deliberation, dialogue, and participatory methods, so that diverse perspectives genuinely shape the questions asked and the options considered.

4

Build responsiveness. Create the capacity and willingness to adjust the shape, direction, or pace of the innovation in light of what anticipation, reflexivity, and inclusion reveal. Responsiveness is the integrative dimension: without it the other three become procedural box-ticking rather than steering.

5

Integrate and govern. Embed the four dimensions into institutional practice—funding criteria, project design, governance structures, and monitoring—so that RRI is woven through the research and innovation system continuously rather than appended as a one-off ethics review, aligning the activity with societal values over its lifetime.

Common pitfalls

  • Treating RRI as a one-off ethics or compliance checkbox rather than a continuous, integrated practice.
  • Running inclusion exercises after key decisions are already made, so participation cannot actually change direction.
  • Implementing anticipation, reflexivity, and inclusion while neglecting responsiveness, leaving deliberation without consequence.
  • Using RRI language to legitimate a predetermined trajectory, eroding the very trust the approach aims to build.

Frequently asked questions

What do the four AIRR dimensions stand for?

AIRR denotes Anticipation, Reflexivity, Inclusion, and Responsiveness. Anticipation means systematically exploring an innovation's possible futures and impacts in advance; reflexivity means researchers and institutions critically examining their own assumptions, values, and the limits of their knowledge; inclusion means opening framing and decisions to diverse publics and stakeholders; and responsiveness means the capacity and willingness to change the innovation's direction in light of the first three. Responsiveness is the integrative dimension that gives the others practical force.

How does RRI differ from traditional research ethics or risk assessment?

Traditional ethics review and risk assessment typically focus on protecting subjects, ensuring compliance, and managing the downstream hazards of a more-or-less fixed product. RRI is broader and more upstream: it questions the purposes and direction of innovation ('should we, and toward what ends?'), engages publics in that framing, and seeks to steer the innovation while it is still malleable. It is continuous and integrated rather than a discrete checkpoint, and treats the trajectory of innovation, not just its safety, as the object of responsibility.

How is RRI related to technology assessment approaches like CTA and pTA?

RRI shares much DNA with constructive technology assessment (CTA) and participatory technology assessment (pTA): all aim to bring societal considerations into the development of technology early, while it can still be shaped, and all value broad participation. RRI can be seen as a later, policy-level synthesis and generalisation of these traditions, offering the AIRR framework as a way to embed their insights—anticipation, deliberation, and responsiveness—across an entire research and innovation system rather than within a single assessment exercise.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Stilgoe, J., Owen, R., & Macnaghten, P. (2013). Developing a framework for responsible innovation. Research Policy, 42(9), 1568-1580.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.
  2. Owen, R., Macnaghten, P., & Stilgoe, J. (2012). Responsible research and innovation: from science in society to science for society, with society. Science and Public Policy, 39(6), 751-760.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.