Number of Identified Specimens
- Introduced by
- R. E. Chaplin
- Year
- 1971
- Type
- Faunal quantification method
- Family
- Zooarchaeology
What does it do?
Number of identified specimens (NISP) is a fundamental zooarchaeological method that quantifies the abundance of faunal remains by counting all identifiable bone fragments or specimens in an assemblage.
Formalized by R. E. Chaplin and later refined by Donald Grayson and others, NISP is the most straightforward and widely used quantification metric in zooarchaeology. Despite its simplicity, NISP is sensitive to both cultural and taphonomic factors that affect preservation, fragmentation, and identification of bone assemblages.
The intuition behind the method
When archaeologists excavate an animal bone assemblage, they recover thousands of fragments in varying states of preservation. The simplest approach to quantifying the faunal assemblage is to count every identifiable bone fragment and assign it to a species. This count—the total number of identified specimens, or NISP—represents a direct tally of recoverable animal remains. NISP is influenced by both the original number of animals and the processes that affected the bones after deposition. A high NISP for one species might reflect high consumption of that animal, or alternatively, might reflect preservation factors that favor that species' bones.
History
NISP was formalized as a standard zooarchaeological metric by R. E. Chaplin in 1971, though simple bone counting had been practiced much earlier. Chaplin's systematic approach provided a foundation for quantitative zooarchaeology. Donald Grayson's influential 1984 monograph on quantitative methods elevated awareness of NISP's strengths and limitations, particularly its vulnerability to fragmentation bias. The 1990s-2000s saw development of refined quantification approaches that addressed NISP limitations, including weight-based metrics and element-specific counts. Today, NISP remains the most commonly reported zooarchaeological metric worldwide, typically used in combination with MNI and other methods.
When to use it
Apply NISP to all faunal assemblages as a standard quantification metric. NISP is particularly useful when comparing assemblage composition across multiple sites or time periods. Works well for assemblages of any size, from small samples to large collections. Most effective when combined with complementary quantification approaches such as MNI, bone weight, or element frequencies. Ideal as an initial descriptive metric before more specialized analytical approaches.
Limitations and considerations
- Heavily biased by fragmentation patterns; highly fragmented assemblages yield artificially high NISP values
- Does not account for differences in skeletal element representation or preservation potential
- Can overemphasize abundant but small-bodied species relative to rare but large-bodied fauna
- Influenced by differential preservation and recovery methods (sieving, flotation) that vary among sites
- Provides no direct information about the minimum number of animals represented in the assemblage
Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.
Strengths
- Simple to calculate and understand; no specialized anatomical knowledge required beyond basic species identification
- Applicable to assemblages of any size and composition
- Direct reflection of recovery effort and excavation methods
- Highly sensitive to changes in human subsistence and faunal procurement over time
- Can be applied to very fragmented assemblages where element identification is impossible
- Facilitates large-scale comparative studies across sites and regions
Applications
- Documenting shifts in human diet from hunting-gathering to agriculture by tracking NISP changes in wild versus domesticated fauna
- Comparing faunal assemblages across sites to understand regional economic differences and trade networks
- Assessing the impact of climate change on human subsistence by analyzing NISP changes through time in response to faunal turnover
- Identifying specialized hunting practices (e.g., mass drives or selective hunting) through examination of NISP patterns for specific prey species
- Understanding settlement patterns and seasonal occupation by analyzing NISP composition and distribution across site areas
How it works
How it works
Excavate and collect all faunal remains from archaeological contexts. Document excavation unit, level, stratigraphic association, and spatial coordinates. Collect systematically from all contexts, including screens and water flotation samples.
Wash, clean, and sort bone specimens. Identify specimens to species using comparative reference collections and published identification guides. Carefully handle and organize specimens by taxon to facilitate counting.
Count the total number of bone fragments identified to each species or genus. Record NISP values for each taxon. Aggregate data across analytical units (layers, excavation units, sites) as needed. Calculate NISP by bone element to examine which parts of the skeleton are represented.
Analyze NISP patterns to infer faunal composition, dietary preferences, and procurement strategies. Compare NISP frequencies across taxa to assess relative economic importance. Calculate diversity indices and other summary statistics.
Interpret NISP data in terms of human subsistence practices, animal availability, and post-depositional taphonomic processes. Recognize that NISP reflects complex interactions between hunting, butchering, consumption, discard, and preservation. Use NISP alongside MNI and other quantification methods for robust conclusions.
Common pitfalls
- Using NISP as the sole quantification metric without considering MNI or bone weight, leading to misinterpretation of diet composition
- Treating NISP values as directly comparable across sites with different fragmentation patterns or preservation conditions
- Ignoring size-class biases, where large animals are underrepresented due to fragmentation
- Failing to account for differential identification rates between taxa, where some species identifications are more reliable than others
Frequently asked questions
Why is NISP biased by fragmentation and how does this affect interpretation?
Fragmentation breaks individual bones into multiple fragments, each of which is counted as a separate specimen if identifiable. Sites with bones broken into small pieces will have high NISP values relative to assemblages where bones are intact, even if the original number of animals was identical. This makes NISP particularly unreliable for comparing assemblages with different preservation or butchering patterns. Analysts should note fragmentation patterns and preferentially use metrics less sensitive to breakage.
How should NISP be reported and what contextual information is necessary?
NISP should be reported by taxon (species or genus) with clear documentation of identification criteria and methods. Associated information should include total number of specimens, number of unidentified fragments, mesh size of screening, recovery methods (hand collection, sieving, flotation), and excavation context. Reported NISP values are meaningful only when these methods and context are transparent, allowing readers to assess comparability with other assemblages.
What is the relationship between NISP and MNI, and when should each be used?
NISP counts all identifiable bone fragments; MNI estimates the minimum number of animals. NISP is sensitive to fragmentation, while MNI is insensitive to it. For assemblages with many small fragments, NISP can be much larger than MNI, creating the false impression of dietary diversity. Best practice is to report both metrics. NISP is better for detecting temporal trends in faunal composition, while MNI is better for estimating the diversity of fauna.
How do differential recovery methods affect NISP comparisons?
Sites excavated with 1/4-inch screens will recover different proportions of small bones (fish, bird, small mammal) compared to sites with 1/2-inch screens or hand collection only. This affects NISP values for small fauna disproportionately. When comparing NISP across sites, it is essential to document and account for differences in screening mesh size, water flotation methods, and collection protocols. Ideally, assemblages should be subsampled to equivalent recovery standards before comparison.
Can NISP be used to estimate meat weight and dietary contribution?
Not reliably. NISP values for large animals (elk, cattle) and small animals (fish, birds) cannot be directly compared because individual large animals contribute more meat than individual small animals. To estimate dietary contribution, analysts typically convert NISP to bone weight or use published conversion factors relating bone counts to meat weight. However, such conversions introduce substantial uncertainty and are best used as rough approximations.
Related methods
Sources
Chaplin, R. E. (1971). The Study of Animal Bones from Archaeological Sites. Seminar Press.
Open publication referenceCopied.Grayson, D. K. (1984). Quantitative Zooarchaeology. Academic Press.
Open publication referenceCopied.Lyman, R. L. (2008). Quantitative Paleozoology. University of Chicago Press.
Open DOI referenceCopied.