Nominal Group Technique — Structured Group Consensus Method
- Introduced by
- André L. Delbecq and Andrew H. Van de Ven
- Year
- 1971
- Type
- Qualitative research method
- Family
- Consensus Methods
What does it do?
The Nominal Group Technique (NGT) is a structured group facilitation method designed to generate and prioritise ideas, problems, or solutions while ensuring equal participation from all members.
Developed by Delbecq and Van de Ven in 1971, it combines silent individual idea generation with structured group discussion and systematic voting to produce a ranked list of priorities. Unlike unstructured focus groups, NGT prevents dominant voices from suppressing quieter participants, making it especially valuable for needs assessment, program planning, and stakeholder priority-setting in applied research and policy contexts.
The intuition behind the method
Imagine a team of healthcare professionals trying to identify the most critical barriers to patient care — but in ordinary meetings, the senior doctor's opinion tends to silence everyone else. NGT solves this by first asking each person to write their ideas privately and independently, then sharing one idea at a time around the group in strict rotation, and finally voting privately on the ranked importance of all collected ideas. Because everyone writes before anyone speaks, no single voice dominates. The final ranked list reflects the collective judgement of the whole group, not just the loudest or most senior voice. It is group intelligence without group conformity pressure.
History
The Nominal Group Technique was developed by organisational theorists André Delbecq and Andrew Van de Ven and first described in their 1971 article in the Journal of Applied Behavioral Science. The term 'nominal' reflects the fact that participants operate as a group in name only during the idea-generation phase — they work independently rather than interactively, unlike conventional brainstorming. Delbecq, Van de Ven, and Gustafson consolidated the method in their 1975 handbook, which became the standard reference for program planners and applied researchers. From the 1980s onward, NGT was adopted widely in health services research, nursing, and public health for needs assessment and guideline development.
When to use it
NGT is appropriate when a research or planning team needs to identify, rank, and reach structured consensus on a set of priorities, needs, problems, or solutions from a defined stakeholder group. It is ideal when equal participation is critical — for example, when status differences, personality dominance, or cultural norms might otherwise suppress minority views. It suits needs assessments, program planning, policy prioritisation, curriculum development, and service evaluation. Ideal group size is 5–12 participants; for larger stakeholder populations, multiple independent NGT groups can be run in parallel and their outputs combined. NGT is not appropriate when the research goal is to explore the social dynamics of discussion, when in-depth narrative accounts of lived experience are needed, or when the question is purely exploratory and no definite set of options can be listed.
Limitations and considerations
- Requires a skilled facilitator to manage timing, neutrality, and group dynamics; a poorly run session can produce shallow or biased results.
- The method structures convergence: it is designed to produce a ranked list, not to explore open-ended complexity or contested meanings.
- The final ranked list reflects the priorities of the specific participants recruited; results are not statistically generalisable to the broader population.
- Logistical requirements — all participants must be co-present (physically or virtually) at the same time — can limit feasibility in dispersed or hard-to-reach populations.
Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.
Strengths
- Equal participation: the silent generation and round-robin phases structurally prevent dominant voices from monopolising idea generation.
- Efficiency: a well-facilitated NGT session produces a ranked consensus list from a group of 5–12 in two to three hours.
- Produces both qualitative data (the listed ideas and clarifications) and quantitative data (the aggregate ranked scores), supporting mixed-methods analysis.
- Reduces social conformity pressure relative to unstructured focus groups; anonymous voting protects individual judgement from status and peer influence.
- Versatile across disciplines — widely used in health services research, education, social policy, organisational development, and community planning.
Applications
- Identifying the most important barriers to healthcare access or service quality among clinical staff, patients, or community members.
- Prioritising research questions or outcome measures for a clinical trial or health technology assessment from the perspective of patient and public stakeholders.
- Ranking curriculum development priorities with faculty members or professional training bodies.
- Identifying key community needs or program goals in participatory action research and community development projects.
- Generating and prioritising policy recommendations among multidisciplinary expert panels in social policy or public administration.
- Establishing consensus on organisational improvement priorities in educational institutions or non-profit organisations.
How it works
How it works
The facilitator presents a clearly worded focus question to all participants simultaneously. Each participant silently and independently writes their responses on paper or cards for a defined period, typically 10–15 minutes. No discussion or sharing occurs at this stage. This silent phase is the defining feature of NGT: it produces a wider variety of ideas than open brainstorming because it eliminates social pressure, anchoring bias, and premature convergence before ideas are fully formed.
The facilitator goes around the group and asks each participant to share one item from their list in turn, recording each idea verbatim on a flip chart or shared display visible to all. Participants pass when they have no new items to add. This structured round-robin continues until all unique ideas are listed. No evaluation, criticism, or elaboration is permitted during this phase — only recording. The result is a comprehensive, pooled list in which every participant's contributions appear with equal status.
The facilitator leads a focused discussion of each listed idea, one by one. Participants may ask clarifying questions, explain the intent behind an item, or briefly discuss its meaning — but debate and advocacy are discouraged. The goal is shared understanding, not persuasion. Items that are duplicates or closely overlapping may be merged with the agreement of the group. This phase ensures that all participants vote on ideas they genuinely understand, not on labels they have misinterpreted.
Each participant privately and silently selects a subset of the listed ideas — typically 5 to 8 items — and ranks them by assigning numerical scores (e.g., the most important item receives the highest score). Votes are collected anonymously. The facilitator tallies the scores for each idea and calculates an aggregate rank. Private voting protects individual judgement from social influence and status pressure, producing a group ranking that reflects independent considered preferences rather than conformity.
The facilitator presents the aggregated ranking to the group, identifying the highest-priority items. A brief discussion of the results may follow to check whether the ranked list reflects the group's intent and to surface any surprising discrepancies between individual votes and the group total. The final ranked output — with the aggregate scores visible — constitutes the primary deliverable of the NGT session and is documented for reporting or further analysis.
Common pitfalls
- Poorly worded focus question: if the question is ambiguous, too broad, or leading, the ideas generated will be unfocused or biased — invest time in piloting and refining the focus question before the session.
- Allowing discussion during silent generation or round-robin phases: even brief verbal exchanges at these stages reintroduce conformity pressure and anchoring effects that the method is designed to eliminate.
- Too many or too few items to vote on: if the combined idea list is very long (more than 20–25 items), the ranking task becomes cognitively burdensome; the facilitator should group or merge clear duplicates during the clarification phase before voting.
- Recruiting a non-representative or internally homogeneous group: NGT surfaces the priorities of those in the room — if the participant sample systematically excludes important stakeholder perspectives, the ranked output will not reflect the breadth of relevant needs.
- Treating the ranked list as a final decision rather than structured input: NGT outputs are priority data to inform decision-making, not binding votes; communicating this distinction to participants and commissioners prevents misuse of results.
Frequently asked questions
How is NGT different from a focus group?
A focus group is an open, moderator-guided discussion that deliberately captures group interaction, disagreement, and the social construction of meaning. NGT suppresses open discussion during idea generation in order to ensure equal contribution and reduce conformity pressure, then uses structured voting to produce a ranked list of priorities. Use a focus group when you want to understand how people collectively make sense of an issue; use NGT when you need a structured, ranked consensus output from a stakeholder group.
How is NGT different from the Delphi method?
Both methods are designed to produce structured group consensus while minimising social conformity pressure. The key differences are format and iteration: the Delphi method is conducted asynchronously over multiple rounds of anonymous questionnaires, making it suitable for geographically dispersed expert panels. NGT is conducted in a single synchronous session with a small face-to-face (or videoconference) group. Delphi is better for large dispersed groups requiring multiple feedback iterations; NGT is faster and richer when participants can be brought together in real time.
How many participants does an NGT session need?
The optimal group size is 5–12 participants. Fewer than five reduces the diversity of ideas generated; more than twelve makes the round-robin sharing phase unwieldy and the clarification discussion too lengthy. When a larger stakeholder population must be consulted, multiple separate NGT groups can be run in parallel — each producing its own ranked list — and the results combined through a second-level analysis.
Can NGT be conducted online or virtually?
Yes. Virtual NGT using videoconferencing platforms combined with shared online whiteboards or collaborative documents (e.g., Miro, Google Jamboard, or survey tools for anonymous voting) is well-established in the literature following adaptations during the COVID-19 pandemic. The facilitator must pay additional attention to managing turn-taking and ensuring that the silent generation phase is genuinely silent and uninterrupted for all participants.
Does NGT produce qualitative or quantitative data?
Both. The listed ideas and clarification discussion yield rich qualitative data that can be subjected to thematic or content analysis. The voting and ranking phase produces numerical scores per item and an aggregate ranked list — quantitative data that can be reported descriptively or, across multiple NGT groups, analysed statistically. This dual-output character makes NGT naturally suited to mixed-methods research designs.
Related methods
Sources
Delbecq, A. L., & Van de Ven, A. H. (1971). A group process model for problem identification and program planning. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 7(4), 466–492.
Open publication referenceCopied.Delbecq, A. L., Van de Ven, A. H., & Gustafson, D. H. (1975). Group Techniques for Program Planning: A Guide to Nominal Group and Delphi Processes. Scott Foresman.
Open publication referenceCopied.