Metaphor Analysis — Conceptual and Critical Metaphor Analysis
- Introduced by
- George Lakoff & Mark Johnson (Conceptual Metaphor Theory); Jonathan Charteris-Black (Critical Metaphor Analysis)
- Year
- Theoretical foundation 1980; systematic research applications from 1990s onward
- Type
- Qualitative research method
- Family
- Textual Analysis
What does it do?
Metaphor Analysis is a qualitative method that identifies, classifies, and interprets the metaphors embedded in language to reveal how speakers and writers conceptualise experience, construct meaning, and exercise ideological influence.
Grounded in Lakoff and Johnson's Conceptual Metaphor Theory, it treats metaphor not as a literary decoration but as a fundamental cognitive structure — ARGUMENT IS WAR, TIME IS MONEY — that shapes how people think, reason, and act. It is widely applied in psychology, education, political discourse, health communication, and organisational research.
The intuition behind the method
When a politician describes immigration as a 'flood' or a doctor calls cancer a 'battle', they are not simply being colourful — they are imposing a conceptual frame that highlights certain features (volume, invasion, combat) and suppresses others (individual stories, chronic management). Metaphor Analysis makes these frames visible. A researcher collects texts in which participants or authors talk about a phenomenon, locates the systematic figurative mappings, asks which SOURCE domain (water, war, journey) is being projected onto which TARGET domain (immigration, illness, reform), and then asks whose interests that mapping serves. The analysis moves from linguistic surface to cognitive structure to social meaning.
History
The modern scientific study of metaphor was transformed by George Lakoff and Mark Johnson's 1980 book Metaphors We Live By, which argued that metaphor is a cognitive mechanism rather than a rhetorical device, organising abstract domains of experience through mappings from embodied, concrete source domains. Through the 1980s and 1990s, cognitive linguists (Lakoff, Turner, Kövecses) mapped hundreds of conceptual metaphors empirically. The Pragglejaz Group published the MIP identification procedure in 2007, and Steen and colleagues refined it into MIPVU in 2010, providing a replicable annotation standard. Jonathan Charteris-Black developed Critical Metaphor Analysis from the early 2000s, integrating corpus methods with critical discourse analysis to examine the ideological functions of metaphor in political and media texts.
When to use it
Metaphor Analysis is appropriate when the research question concerns how people cognitively frame an experience, issue, or phenomenon — how illness, leadership, change, learning, or policy is conceptualised in language rather than what attitudes or behaviours are measured. It suits exploratory and interpretive questions in education (how students conceptualise a subject), health (how patients talk about illness), political science (how leaders frame policy), and organisational research (how employees describe culture). It is NOT appropriate when the research goal is to measure the frequency of an attitude, test a hypothesis about behaviour, or generate a grounded theory of a social process; those purposes call for survey methods, experimental designs, or grounded theory respectively. A sufficiently rich textual corpus is a hard prerequisite — thin or highly structured data (closed questionnaires, tick-box surveys) will not yield meaningful metaphor analysis.
Limitations and considerations
- Inter-rater reliability in metaphor identification can be modest; the boundary between literal and metaphorical language is contested, and MIP/MIPVU does not eliminate judgment calls.
- Findings are context-specific and interpretive — they describe the conceptual framings in a particular corpus and cannot be statistically generalised to a population.
- The method does not capture non-linguistic meaning (gesture, image, tone), limiting its reach when multimodal data are relevant.
- Corpus compilation and systematic metaphor identification are time-intensive, especially for large datasets where software assistance is only partial.
Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.
Strengths
- Reveals unconscious cognitive frameworks that speakers themselves may not be aware of, providing access to implicit meaning not captured by explicit attitude measures.
- Applicable to any naturally occurring or elicited textual data — from clinical interviews to political speeches to social media corpora — without requiring participant reactivity.
- Grounded in a well-developed theoretical tradition (Conceptual Metaphor Theory; Critical Metaphor Analysis) with standardised identification procedures (MIP/MIPVU) that improve replicability.
- Bridges individual cognition and social discourse, making it useful for both psychological and critical-sociological research questions.
- Can be combined with corpus linguistics tools to handle large datasets, enabling both micro-level close reading and macro-level frequency analysis.
Applications
- Analysing how political leaders metaphorically frame economic crisis, immigration, or public health to mobilise support or assign blame.
- Examining the metaphors patients use to describe chronic illness or mental health conditions, informing clinical communication and therapeutic language.
- Investigating how students and teachers conceptualise learning, mathematics, or scientific inquiry to identify productive and obstructive frames for pedagogy.
- Studying organisational culture by eliciting and analysing the metaphors employees use to describe their workplace, leadership, or change processes.
- Tracking shifts in media framing of a social issue (e.g., climate change, migration) over time through corpus-based metaphor frequency analysis.
- Exploring cross-cultural differences in conceptual framing by comparing metaphors across languages or communities for the same target domain.
How it works
How it works
A text corpus is assembled that is appropriate to the research question: interview transcripts, parliamentary speeches, newspaper articles, social media posts, textbook excerpts, or written responses to prompts such as 'My organisation is like...' The corpus must be rich enough in naturally occurring or elicited language to yield a range of figurative expressions. Sampling decisions — purposive, criterion-based, or corpus-driven — are documented to allow replication and critical appraisal.
Metaphorical expressions are located using a principled identification procedure. The widely used MIP (Metaphor Identification Procedure) and its refined version MIPVU, developed by the Pragglejaz Group, provide step-by-step criteria: for each lexical unit, the researcher asks whether its contextual meaning differs from its basic (most concrete or bodily) meaning and whether the contextual meaning can be understood by contrast with that basic meaning. Expressions meeting both criteria are flagged as metaphorical.
Identified linguistic metaphors are grouped into conceptual metaphors — the underlying cognitive mappings that motivate multiple surface expressions. For example, 'attacking the problem', 'defending the position', and 'winning the argument' all instantiate the conceptual metaphor ARGUMENT IS WAR. Grouping is guided by the source domain: bodily experience, spatial orientation, journey, container, war, machine, organism, etc. This classification reveals the dominant conceptual structures in the corpus.
The analyst interprets what each dominant metaphor highlights, hides, and implies about the target domain, drawing on the social and discursive context. Critical Metaphor Analysis (Charteris-Black) additionally asks who benefits from the metaphor, which ideological assumptions it naturalises, and what alternative metaphors might reframe the issue. In psychological and educational applications the focus is more on cognitive and affective meaning than on power; the interpretive lens is adapted accordingly.
Findings are presented as a structured account of the most frequent or salient conceptual metaphors, illustrated with representative textual examples. Quantitative frequency counts may accompany the qualitative interpretation to show relative salience across groups or time periods. Reflexivity regarding the analyst's own interpretive choices and potential alternative readings is documented.
Common pitfalls
- Cherry-picking vivid examples rather than applying a principled identification procedure such as MIP/MIPVU — this produces a selective, non-replicable reading rather than a systematic analysis.
- Confusing linguistic metaphors with conceptual metaphors — individual expressions ('he attacked the argument') must be grouped into underlying mappings (ARGUMENT IS WAR) before interpretation is meaningful.
- Over-claiming ideological intent — not every metaphor is strategically deployed; many are frozen conventional expressions whose conceptual structure is only activated analytically. The analyst must distinguish salient, motivated metaphors from dead or conventional ones.
- Neglecting context — the same metaphor (e.g., 'the body of knowledge') can carry different implications in a medical, educational, or political context; interpretation must be grounded in the specific discourse community and situation.
- Treating elicited sentence-completion data ('X is like...') as equivalent to naturally occurring language — prompted metaphors reveal folk theories but may not reflect spontaneous conceptual structure in real discourse.
Frequently asked questions
How is Metaphor Analysis different from Discourse Analysis?
Discourse Analysis examines how language constructs social reality at the level of text and context — power relations, genre, ideology, and social identity are all in scope. Metaphor Analysis is more narrowly focused on figurative mappings between conceptual domains. The two often overlap: Critical Metaphor Analysis is explicitly a sub-strand of critical discourse analysis, using metaphor as the analytic entry point. A study can use both: discourse analysis for broad structural features and metaphor analysis to zoom in on conceptual framing.
Do I need a large corpus for Metaphor Analysis?
Not necessarily. Single-case or small-corpus metaphor analysis — for example, close reading of one interview or one speech — is legitimate and can yield rich interpretive insight. Larger corpora allow frequency claims and comparisons across groups or time points. The decision depends on your research question: depth of interpretation versus breadth of patterning. Whichever scale you use, the identification procedure should be documented and applied consistently.
What software tools support Metaphor Analysis?
For corpus-level work, concordancing software (AntConc, Sketch Engine, Wordsmith) helps retrieve lexical items associated with a source domain across large text collections. ATLAS.ti and NVivo can support coding and grouping of metaphorical expressions. Specialised tools such as MetaNet and MIPVU annotation guides assist systematic identification. However, conceptual grouping and interpretation remain human analytical tasks — no software automates the core cognitive work.
Can Metaphor Analysis be combined with quantitative methods?
Yes. Frequency counts of metaphor families across groups (patients vs. clinicians, left vs. right-wing newspapers) provide a quantitative dimension without requiring statistical inference. Some researchers combine corpus-based metaphor frequency with survey data to test whether conceptual framing predicts attitudes or behaviours — a form of mixed-methods design. The qualitative interpretive work, however, must precede quantification, because metaphors must be identified and categorised before they can be counted meaningfully.
What is the difference between Conceptual Metaphor Analysis and Critical Metaphor Analysis?
Conceptual Metaphor Analysis (stemming from Lakoff and Johnson) focuses on mapping the cognitive structure of source-to-target domain projections — its goal is descriptive and cognitive. Critical Metaphor Analysis (Charteris-Black) adds a normative and political dimension: it asks which metaphors are strategically chosen by powerful actors, what ideological work they do, whose interests they serve, and what alternative frames might exist. CMA is explicitly evaluative; Conceptual Metaphor Analysis aims to be descriptive.
Related methods
Sources
Lakoff, G., & Johnson, M. (1980). Metaphors We Live By. University of Chicago Press.
ISBN: 978-0226468013Copied.Charteris-Black, J. (2004). Corpus Approaches to Critical Metaphor Analysis. Palgrave Macmillan.
Open publication referenceCopied.