Skip to content
Back to search results

Explanatory Research — Explanatory Research Design

Introduced by
Formalized by Earl Babbie and Fred Kerlinger among others
Year
1960s–1980s (codified in behavioral and social science methodology)
Type
Non-experimental quantitative research design
Family
Survey / observational design
Font size

What does it do?

Explanatory research is a non-experimental quantitative research design that goes beyond describing a phenomenon to identifying why it occurs — examining the relationships or mechanisms that account for observed patterns.

Rooted in positivist social science methodology, it uses theory-driven hypotheses and statistical analysis to test whether specific variables explain variation in an outcome, without necessarily manipulating those variables.

The intuition behind the method

If descriptive research answers 'what is happening?' and exploratory research asks 'what might be going on?', explanatory research asks 'why is this happening?' Imagine you have already established that student motivation and academic achievement are correlated. Explanatory research goes further: it formulates a hypothesis grounded in a motivational theory, gathers data on the proposed explanatory variables (e.g., self-efficacy, goal orientation, parental support), and tests statistically whether those variables account for differences in achievement. The aim is to build or verify an explanation — a causal or relational account — not merely a description.

History

The distinction between descriptive, exploratory, and explanatory research purposes was systematized in social science methodology textbooks of the 1960s through 1980s, most notably in Fred Kerlinger's Foundations of Behavioral Research (1964, rev. 1986) and Earl Babbie's The Practice of Social Research (first edition 1975). These works established explanatory research as the third and most ambitious level of scientific inquiry — after description and exploration — in which the researcher tests a theoretical account of why patterns exist. The framework was widely adopted across sociology, psychology, education, and management research and remains central to graduate research methods curricula.

When to use it

Use explanatory research when a descriptive baseline already exists and the goal is to understand why or how observed patterns arise — testing specific theoretical explanations rather than merely documenting them. It suits situations where randomized experiments are impractical or unethical and where statistical control can substitute for experimental manipulation. It is appropriate when sample sizes are large enough for multivariate analysis and when validated measures of explanatory constructs are available. Do not use explanatory research when the phenomenon is so poorly understood that no credible theory yet exists (use exploratory research instead), when sample sizes are too small for the intended statistical model, or when the research question requires causal proof that only a controlled experiment can provide.

Limitations and considerations

  • Without random assignment, it cannot definitively establish causation — correlation and statistical control are not substitutes for experimentation.
  • Cross-sectional designs cannot rule out reverse causation or establish the temporal ordering of variables required for causal inference.
  • Explanatory power depends entirely on the quality of the theoretical framework; a misspecified model will produce misleading results even with clean data.
  • Measurement error in explanatory variables attenuates regression coefficients and may lead to underestimation of true relationships.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Moves inquiry beyond description to test theoretically derived explanations of why phenomena occur.
  • Applicable in contexts where experimental manipulation is impractical, unethical, or impossible.
  • Multivariate statistical controls allow examination of multiple explanatory variables simultaneously while holding others constant.
  • Compatible with large, representative samples, enabling generalization of the explanation to a defined population.
  • Cumulative: findings can be integrated across studies through meta-analysis to build stronger explanatory models.

Applications

  • Testing whether self-efficacy, task value, and parental support together explain variance in student academic achievement after controlling for prior attainment.
  • Examining which organizational factors (leadership style, communication climate, role clarity) account for differences in employee burnout rates across departments.
  • Investigating why certain neighborhoods have higher rates of chronic disease by testing explanatory variables such as food access, air quality, and socioeconomic deprivation.
  • Evaluating competing theoretical explanations of voter turnout by testing demographic, attitudinal, and structural predictors in a national survey dataset.
  • Analyzing the pathways through which training intensity, recovery practices, and psychological readiness explain performance variation among competitive athletes.

How it works

How it works

1

The researcher identifies a phenomenon that needs explaining and derives specific, theory-grounded hypotheses about why it occurs. These hypotheses specify which independent variables are expected to explain variation in the dependent variable and in what direction, drawing on prior literature or established theoretical frameworks.

2

A research design is chosen that allows the hypotheses to be tested with appropriate controls. Cross-sectional surveys, secondary data sets, or archival records are common. Because explanatory research is typically non-experimental, the researcher uses statistical controls (e.g., regression, ANCOVA, path analysis) to isolate the explanatory contribution of each variable rather than randomizing participants to conditions.

3

Data are collected from a sample that is large enough to detect the expected effect sizes and support the statistical techniques planned. Standardized instruments, validated scales, or administrative records are preferred to maximize measurement reliability. Representativeness of the sample matters because the goal is to generalize the explanation beyond the sample.

4

Inferential statistical methods — regression analysis, structural equation modeling, analysis of variance, or mediation/moderation analysis — are applied to test whether the hypothesized explanatory variables account for significant variance in the outcome. Goodness-of-fit statistics, effect sizes, and confidence intervals are reported alongside significance tests.

5

Results are interpreted in light of the original theoretical framework. The researcher evaluates whether the evidence supports, partially supports, or refutes each hypothesis, discusses alternative explanations, acknowledges the limitations of cross-sectional or non-experimental inference, and situates the findings within the broader literature.

Common pitfalls

  • Claiming causation from correlational evidence — explanatory research can support a causal interpretation but cannot prove it without experimental design or longitudinal data with proper temporal ordering.
  • Omitting relevant variables — confounding variables left out of the model inflate or deflate the apparent explanatory contribution of included variables, leading to biased estimates.
  • Underpowered samples — regression and SEM require adequate sample sizes relative to the number of predictors; rules of thumb suggest at least 10–20 cases per predictor for regression.
  • Treating statistical significance as synonymous with explanatory importance — a large sample can yield significant but trivially small effects; always report and interpret effect sizes.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between explanatory and confirmatory research?

The terms are closely related but carry different emphases. Explanatory research focuses on the goal — understanding why a phenomenon occurs — and encompasses a range of designs from regression-based surveys to path models. Confirmatory research specifically emphasizes pre-registered hypothesis testing in which the exact hypotheses, sample sizes, and analysis plan are specified before data collection, following the logic of strict hypothesis confirmation. All confirmatory research is explanatory in intent, but not all explanatory research meets the stricter protocol standards of confirmatory research.

Can explanatory research establish causation?

Non-experimental explanatory research can provide strong evidence consistent with a causal interpretation, especially when combined with longitudinal data, instrumental variables, or rigorous statistical controls, but it cannot definitively establish causation in the same way a randomized controlled experiment can. The researcher must acknowledge this limitation and discuss alternative explanations for the observed relationships.

How is explanatory research different from exploratory research?

Exploratory research is conducted when relatively little is known about a phenomenon and the goal is to generate hypotheses or identify relevant variables. Explanatory research begins where exploration ends: it assumes a sufficient theoretical basis already exists and tests specific hypotheses about why the phenomenon occurs. In practice, a research program often moves from exploratory to explanatory phases across multiple studies.

What statistical methods are typical in explanatory research?

Multiple linear or logistic regression, hierarchical regression, structural equation modeling (SEM), analysis of covariance (ANCOVA), mediation and moderation analysis (e.g., the PROCESS macro), and path analysis are all commonly used. The choice depends on the number and type of explanatory variables, the nature of the outcome, and whether mediating or moderating pathways are hypothesized.

How large a sample do I need?

Sample size requirements depend on the statistical technique, the number of predictors, and the expected effect size. For multiple regression, a common heuristic is 10–20 cases per predictor variable; for SEM, a minimum of 200 cases is often cited. Power analysis (e.g., using G*Power) before data collection is strongly recommended to ensure the study can detect the effect sizes specified by the theory being tested.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Kerlinger, F. N. (1986). Foundations of Behavioral Research (3rd ed.). Holt, Rinehart and Winston.

    ISBN: 978-0030417559
    Copied.
  2. Babbie, E. (2010). The Practice of Social Research (12th ed.). Wadsworth/Cengage Learning.

    ISBN: 978-0495598428
    Copied.