Skip to content
Back to search results

Discourse Completion Task

Introduced by
Shoshana Blum-Kulka, Juliane House & Gabriele Kasper (CCSARP project)
Year
1989
Type
Written/oral elicitation instrument for speech-act data
Family
Pragmatics / interlanguage pragmatics
Font size

What does it do?

The discourse completion task (DCT) is an elicitation instrument widely used in pragmatics to gather data on how people perform speech acts such as requests, apologies, refusals, and compliments.

Respondents read short descriptions of situations and write (or say) what they would utter in each, allowing researchers to collect comparable speech-act data across many speakers, languages, and cultures under controlled conditions. It was popularized by the Cross-Cultural Speech Act Realization Project (CCSARP) of Blum-Kulka, House, and Kasper in 1989.

The intuition behind the method

Studying how people apologize or make requests by waiting for those acts to occur naturally is slow and uncontrolled — the same situation almost never recurs across speakers. The DCT solves this by holding the situation constant: it hands every respondent the same described scenario ('You bump into someone and spill their coffee. You say...') and records their words. Because everyone responds to identical, parameter-controlled prompts, the researcher can compare strategies across cultures or learner groups cleanly, trading a measure of naturalness for a large gain in comparability and control.

History

The discourse completion task originated in studies of pragmatic transfer and was decisively established by the Cross-Cultural Speech Act Realization Project (CCSARP), reported in Blum-Kulka, House, and Kasper's 1989 volume Cross-Cultural Pragmatics: Requests and Apologies, which standardized both the instrument and a detailed coding framework for requests and apologies across languages. Kasper and Dahl's 1991 review situated the DCT within the broader methods of interlanguage pragmatics, and later work by Félix-Brasdefer and others critically compared DCTs with role plays and verbal reports, refining understanding of what each method does and does not capture.

When to use it

Use a DCT when you need comparable speech-act data from many speakers under controlled conditions — for cross-cultural pragmatics, interlanguage and second-language pragmatics, or studies that systematically vary power, distance, and imposition. It excels when natural occurrences would be too rare or uncontrolled to compare. It is less appropriate when the research question concerns authentic interactional dynamics, turn-taking, or negotiation, where role plays, conversation analysis, or naturalistic recordings are preferable, since DCTs capture offline, idealized production rather than real-time interaction.

Limitations and considerations

  • Elicits what respondents think they would say, not what they actually say, so responses may diverge from authentic use.
  • Written DCTs lose interactional features such as turn-taking, repair, and negotiation present in real conversation.
  • Responses are sensitive to scenario wording and to how much context is supplied, which can shape the output.
  • The offline, reflective nature of the task may favor more idealized, normative, or lengthy responses than spontaneous speech.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Yields large amounts of comparable data quickly by holding situations constant across many respondents.
  • Allows systematic control and manipulation of social variables (power, distance, imposition) that shape speech acts.
  • Enables clean cross-cultural and cross-linguistic comparison of pragmatic strategies.
  • Produces data in a form well suited to established coding schemes and statistical comparison, supporting replication.

Applications

  • Comparing how requests, apologies, refusals, and compliments are realized across languages and cultures.
  • Studying interlanguage pragmatics: how second-language learners' speech-act strategies differ from native speakers'.
  • Assessing the effects of instruction or study abroad on learners' pragmatic competence.
  • Building coded corpora of speech acts for typological or developmental pragmatic research.
  • Informing language-teaching materials and pragmatic assessment with controlled production data.

How it works

How it works

1

The researcher designs a set of situations engineered to elicit the target speech act, systematically varying contextual parameters known to affect pragmatic choices — social distance between interlocutors, relative power, and the degree of imposition. Each scenario gives enough context to constrain the response, and classic open-item designs leave a blank for the respondent's utterance, sometimes with a rejoinder to anchor the exchange.

2

The task is administered to respondents, who produce what they would say in each situation, in writing for the traditional written DCT or orally for spoken variants. Sampling is designed for the comparison of interest — for instance native speakers of two languages, or learners at different proficiency levels — and instructions emphasize spontaneous, natural responses.

3

The elicited responses are coded using a pragmatic coding scheme. The CCSARP framework, for example, segments a request or apology into its head act and its supportive moves, classifies the directness level and the internal and external modifications, so that complex utterances are reduced to comparable analytic categories with documented reliability.

4

The coded data are analyzed to compare strategy use across groups and across the manipulated situational parameters — for instance whether one culture favors more direct requests, or whether learners under-use mitigating downgraders relative to native speakers. Results are interpreted with explicit acknowledgment, following Félix-Brasdefer and others, that DCT data reflect what respondents believe they would say rather than naturally occurring talk.

Common pitfalls

  • Treating DCT responses as equivalent to naturally occurring speech rather than as elicited, metapragmatic production.
  • Writing scenarios that are culturally unequal across the groups compared, so the prompt itself biases the comparison.
  • Failing to balance or document the social variables (power, distance, imposition), making strategy differences uninterpretable.
  • Using inconsistent or unreliable coding of head acts and modifications, undermining cross-group comparability.

Frequently asked questions

Does a DCT capture how people actually speak?

Not exactly. A DCT captures what respondents report they would say in a described situation — offline, reflective, often written production. This typically differs from spontaneous talk in length, directness, and the absence of interactional features like negotiation and repair. DCT data are best treated as a controlled sample of pragmatic knowledge and strategy choice, valuable for comparison, rather than as a record of naturally occurring conversation.

What are the main variants of the DCT?

Beyond the classic open written DCT with a blank for the response, variants include the dialogue-completion form with a rejoinder that anchors the exchange, multiple-choice DCTs that constrain responses to preset options, and oral or computer-animated DCTs that present scenarios audiovisually and collect spoken responses. Each trades off control, naturalness, and ease of coding differently, so the choice follows the research question.

How are DCT responses coded for analysis?

Responses are segmented and classified with a pragmatic coding scheme, most influentially the CCSARP framework, which separates the head act (the core of the request or apology) from supportive moves, codes the level of directness, and tags internal and external modifications such as downgraders and grounders. Reliable, documented coding is essential so that strategy use can be counted and compared across groups and conditions.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Blum-Kulka, S., House, J., & Kasper, G. (Eds.) (1989). Cross-Cultural Pragmatics: Requests and Apologies. Ablex Publishing.

    ISBN: 9780893915131
    Copied.
  2. Kasper, G., & Dahl, M. (1991). Research methods in interlanguage pragmatics. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 13(2), 215–247.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.
  3. Félix-Brasdefer, J. C. (2010). Data collection methods in speech act performance: DCTs, role plays, and verbal reports. In A. Martínez-Flor & E. Usó-Juan (Eds.), Speech Act Performance: Theoretical, Empirical and Methodological Issues (pp. 41–56). John Benjamins.

    ISBN: 9789027219930
    Copied.