Skip to content
Back to search results

Three Horizons Framework

Introduced by
Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester (International Futures Forum)
Year
2016
Type
Pattern-mapping pipeline for transformative change over time
Family
Futures studies / transformation framework
Font size

What does it do?

The Three Horizons framework is a structured way of thinking about transformative change by mapping three overlapping curves of activity across time.

Developed within the International Futures Forum and given its definitive articulation by Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester and colleagues in their 2016 Ecology and Society paper, it distinguishes the first horizon (H1), the dominant present system that is declining in its fit with a changing world; the third horizon (H3), an emerging and viable future pattern that is currently marginal but growing; and the second horizon (H2), the turbulent zone of transition in which entrepreneurial innovations and experiments compete, some carrying the system toward H3 and others merely propping up H1. Rather than predicting a single future, the framework is a pathways practice that helps groups see the present as a contested landscape of patterns and locate their own intentions and actions within it.

The intuition behind the method

Picture three bell-shaped curves rising and falling across a single timeline. The first curve is the world as it is today: the established institutions, technologies, and habits that currently dominate but are slowly losing their grip as the context shifts under them. The third curve, far off and still small, is a fundamentally different way of doing things that fits the emerging future better — visible today only in fringe experiments and aspirations. Between them rises a second curve of disruptive innovation and entrepreneurial activity: the messy middle where new ideas clash with the old order. The crucial insight is that the same H2 innovation can play two opposite roles. It can be captured to extend the life of the dying first horizon, or it can become a stepping-stone that nurtures the third. Three Horizons gives a shared language for asking, of any trend or project, which horizon it belongs to and which future it serves — turning an abstract argument about change into a picture people can point at and reason about together.

History

The Three Horizons idea has roots in strategy and innovation management, where a three-horizon model of present, emerging, and future business was popularised in the late 1990s, but its distinctive futures-studies form was developed at the International Futures Forum by Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester and collaborators through the 2000s and 2010s. Sharpe's 2013 book Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope set out the practice as a way of working with hope and agency in the face of systemic change. The framework received its most influential scholarly articulation in the 2016 Ecology and Society paper by Sharpe, Hodgson, Leicester, Lyon and Fazey, which positioned it as a 'pathways practice for transformation' and connected it to sustainability science and social-ecological systems. Since then it has been widely adopted in sustainability transitions, public policy, and participatory foresight as a facilitative sense-making tool.

When to use it

Use the Three Horizons framework when a group needs to make sense of transformative, long-run change and to align around how present actions relate to a desired future, rather than to produce a point forecast. It is especially valuable for systemic challenges — sustainability transitions, organisational renewal, sectoral disruption — where the dominant system is visibly under strain, where promising but marginal alternatives exist, and where innovation is contested and could cut either way. The framework excels as a facilitated, participatory sense-making and dialogue tool that surfaces assumptions and gives diverse stakeholders a common language. It is less suited to situations demanding quantified probabilities, short-term operational planning, or precise prediction, and its value depends on the quality of the group's judgement, so it is best paired with evidence on trends and weak signals rather than used as a substitute for them.

Limitations and considerations

  • Relies on qualitative judgement and facilitation skill, so outputs are only as good as the participants' insight and honesty.
  • Offers no probabilities or quantitative rigour, making it weak where decisions require measured likelihoods or formal forecasts.
  • The clean three-curve picture can oversimplify systems with multiple competing futures or non-linear, discontinuous change.
  • The desirability framing around a preferred H3 can import bias, presenting one favoured future as inevitable rather than contested.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Provides an intuitive, visual shared language that lets diverse stakeholders reason together about long-term, transformative change.
  • Distinguishes innovations that genuinely seed the future (H2-plus) from those that merely prop up the incumbent system (H2-minus).
  • Holds present, transition, and future in a single picture, connecting strategic vision to concrete present action.
  • Assigns complementary roles — manager, entrepreneur, visionary — so different actors see their stake and avoid talking past each other.

Applications

  • Facilitating sustainability and energy transition dialogues that connect a declining present system to an emerging viable future.
  • Guiding organisational and institutional renewal by distinguishing innovations that renew the future from those that defend the status quo.
  • Structuring participatory foresight workshops that give diverse stakeholders a shared map of transformative change.
  • Analysing disruptive innovation in a sector to judge which experiments seed a new pattern and which entrench the incumbent.
  • Framing public policy and place-based strategy around a preferred third horizon and the transitional steps toward it.

How it works

How it works

1

The practice begins by framing the focal concern and the time horizon over which transformation is in play. The group names the system or question at issue — a city's mobility, an industry, an ecosystem, an organisation — and agrees how far ahead the third horizon should sit, far enough that a genuinely different pattern is conceivable. Sharpe and colleagues stress that the three horizons are not fixed dates but qualitatively different ways the future shows up in the present: as the prevailing pattern, as a pocket of the emerging future, and as the contested space between. Establishing this shared frame, with time on the horizontal axis and prevalence or fit on the vertical, sets up the canvas on which the three curves will be drawn.

Formula
\mathcal{H} = \{H_1, H_2, H_3\}\ \text{over time } t,\quad f_i(t) = \text{prevalence of pattern } i \text{ at } t
2

Next the group characterises the first horizon: the dominant, business-as-usual system that defines how things are done now. The key analytical move is to describe not only what H1 currently provides but why its fit with the world is declining — the pressures, contradictions, and signs of strain that mean the present pattern cannot simply continue. Sharpe and colleagues describe this as the manager's horizon, the one we depend on and keep running, while recognising that its prevalence curve is bending downward as the operating context changes around it. Naming what is valuable in H1, and what is becoming untenable, prevents both complacent defence and reckless dismissal of the existing system.

Formula
f_1(t)\ \text{decreasing: } \tfrac{d f_1}{d t} < 0,\quad H_1 = \text{dominant present system losing fit}
3

The group then turns to the third horizon: the genuinely viable future they aspire to or anticipate, a pattern that fits the emerging conditions far better than H1. This is the visionary's horizon, articulated not as a utopian wish-list but as a coherent alternative way the system could work, glimpsed today in marginal experiments, values, and weak signals. Sharpe and colleagues emphasise that H3 is about pattern rather than prediction: the analyst describes the qualities, relationships, and assumptions of a future that is presently small but growing. Holding a clear H3 gives direction to the whole exercise, because it is the destination against which transitional innovations are later judged.

Formula
f_3(t)\ \text{increasing: } \tfrac{d f_3}{d t} > 0,\quad H_3 = \text{emerging viable future pattern}
4

With the endpoints established, the group explores the second horizon, the zone of transition where the action and the uncertainty concentrate. H2 is the domain of entrepreneurial innovation, disruption, and experiment, and the framework's signature insight is that these innovations are inherently ambiguous. Sharpe and colleagues distinguish H2-plus innovations, which genuinely seed and grow the third horizon, from H2-minus innovations, which are absorbed by the incumbent system to sustain H1 a little longer. Mapping who is active in H2, what they are trying, and which way each initiative tilts turns the messy middle into an analysable space of competing pathways rather than undifferentiated 'change'.

Formula
f_2(t) = \text{peaked: } \arg\max_t f_2(t) = t^*,\quad H_2 = \text{transitional innovations } (H2^{+} \to H_3,\ H2^{-} \to H_1)
5

Finally the group synthesises the three curves into pathways and connects them to action. By overlaying the declining H1, the rising H3, and the peaking H2 between them, participants can trace how the system might transition — which H2 innovations to back, which H1 strengths to carry forward, and where the dangerous H2-minus traps lie. Bishop, Hines and Collins situate this kind of structured, multi-perspective mapping within the wider repertoire of scenario and foresight techniques, and the framework deliberately assigns roles — entrepreneur, manager, visionary — so that different actors recognise their stake. The output is less a forecast than a shared strategic conversation that orients present choices toward a preferred future.

Formula
\text{pathway} = \langle f_1 \downarrow,\ f_2 \rightarrow H_3,\ f_3 \uparrow\rangle,\quad \text{actions chosen by horizon role}

Common pitfalls

  • Treating the horizons as fixed time periods or dates rather than qualitatively different patterns coexisting in the present.
  • Misclassifying H2-minus innovations as genuine progress, mistaking activity that sustains H1 for movement toward H3.
  • Letting a single facilitator's or sponsor's preferred future dominate the H3 description and crowd out alternative visions.
  • Using the framework as a tidy presentation graphic while skipping the deliberative dialogue that gives it its value.

Frequently asked questions

Are the three horizons three points in time?

No. Although the framework is drawn on a timeline, the three horizons are not sequential dates but three qualitatively different patterns that all exist in the present. H1 is the currently dominant system, H3 is the emerging future already visible in pockets, and H2 is the contested transition space between them. The curves overlap precisely because today's world simultaneously contains the declining established order, fringe experiments pointing to a different future, and disruptive innovations whose direction is still being decided.

What is the difference between H2-plus and H2-minus?

Second-horizon innovations are inherently ambiguous, and Sharpe and colleagues distinguish two roles they can play. H2-plus innovations are stepping-stones that genuinely nurture and grow the third horizon, helping the new pattern take root. H2-minus innovations, by contrast, are captured or absorbed by the incumbent system and used to extend the life of the declining first horizon. The same technology or initiative can be either, depending on how it is deployed, which is why mapping the direction each H2 activity tilts is central to the practice.

Is Three Horizons a forecasting method?

Not in the predictive sense. It does not assign probabilities or attempt to say what will happen. Instead it is a sense-making and pathways practice that helps a group see the present as a landscape of competing patterns and decide how to act toward a preferred future. Its outputs are shared maps, conversations, and strategic orientations rather than forecasts, which is why it is usually facilitated participatively and paired with trend evidence rather than used to generate quantitative predictions.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Sharpe, B., Hodgson, A., Leicester, G., Lyon, A., & Fazey, I. (2016). Three horizons: a pathways practice for transformation. Ecology and Society, 21(2), 47.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.
  2. Bishop, P., Hines, A., & Collins, T. (2007). The current state of scenario development: an overview of techniques. Foresight, 9(1), 5-25.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.