Skip to content
Back to search results

Technological Frames Analysis

Introduced by
Wiebe E. Bijker; extended to organisations by Wanda Orlikowski & Debra Gash
Year
1995
Type
Qualitative interpretive method
Family
Social construction of technology
Font size

What does it do?

Technological frames analysis examines the shared assumptions, goals, and problem-solving strategies through which groups make sense of a technology and act upon it.

Introduced by Wiebe Bijker as part of the social construction of technology, a technological frame structures the interaction among members of a relevant social group and binds the meaning of an artefact to their concerns. Wanda Orlikowski and Debra Gash later carried the concept into organisations, showing how different stakeholder groups hold distinct frames about information technology and how the resulting frame incongruence shapes adoption and use. The method reconstructs these frames, analyses their content, and links them to technological outcomes.

The intuition behind the method

Think of a pair of tinted glasses that a group of people all happen to wear: the glasses do not change the object in front of them, but they make certain features stand out and others fade, and they suggest what the object is for and what problems it should solve. Engineers, managers, and users each wear differently tinted glasses when they look at the same new system, so they literally see different technologies. When the tints are similar, people cooperate smoothly; when they clash, the same software looks like a productivity miracle to one group and a surveillance threat to another. Technological frames analysis is the practice of figuring out what colour each group's glasses are and what happens when the colours do not match.

History

The concept of the technological frame was developed by the Dutch historian and sociologist of technology Wiebe Bijker, most fully in his 1995 book Of Bicycles, Bakelites, and Bulbs, as part of the social construction of technology (SCOT) programme he had co-founded with Trevor Pinch in the 1980s. Bijker used the frame to explain how relevant social groups attribute meaning to artefacts, how interpretive flexibility gives way to closure, and how an actor's inclusion in a frame confers semiotic power. In 1994 Wanda Orlikowski and Debra Gash transplanted the idea into organisational and information-systems research with their notion of technological frames and frame incongruence, providing a practical analytic vocabulary that has since been widely applied to IT adoption and implementation studies.

When to use it

Use technological frames analysis when you want to explain how different groups interpret the same technology and how those interpretations shape its design, adoption, or use—particularly in implementation studies and the social construction of artefacts. It suits cases with identifiable stakeholder groups, accessible interview and documentary data, and visible disagreement or negotiation over what a technology means and is for. The method assumes that meaning is group-relative, that frames can be reconstructed from actors' accounts, and that interpretive flexibility precedes closure. It is less appropriate when there is only one homogeneous interpretation, when the analyst seeks quantitative causal generalisation across many sites, or when the focus is on material infrastructure independent of how groups make sense of it.

Limitations and considerations

  • Frames are inferred interpretively, so reconstructions depend on the analyst's reading and the candour of informants.
  • The boundaries of relevant social groups can be ambiguous, and individuals may hold mixed or shifting frames.
  • It can underplay material constraints and power asymmetries that operate beyond shared meanings.
  • Static frame snapshots may miss how frames are negotiated and transformed over the lifecycle of a technology.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Explains why the same technology is experienced and used differently by different stakeholder groups.
  • Connects micro-level sense-making to macro-level outcomes such as adoption, resistance, and artefact stabilisation.
  • Provides actionable diagnosis of frame incongruence for managers and designers seeking smoother implementation.
  • Bridges STS theory and organisational and information-systems research, making it portable across fields.

Applications

  • Explaining how engineers, users, and critics shaped the design and stabilisation of historical artefacts such as the bicycle or fluorescent lighting.
  • Diagnosing why an enterprise information system was embraced by one department and resisted by another.
  • Studying the introduction of electronic health records and clashes between clinical, administrative, and IT frames.
  • Analysing user, designer, and regulator framings of emerging consumer technologies and platforms.
  • Informing change-management and design strategies by surfacing and reconciling incongruent stakeholder frames.

How it works

How it works

1

Begin by identifying the relevant social groups whose members share a way of attributing meaning to the technology—engineers, managers, users, regulators, or others—since a frame is defined by the group whose interaction it structures. Groups are recognised by the common interpretation they bring to the artefact rather than by formal organisational labels alone. The analyst delimits the groups empirically, allowing that some actors may belong to more than one.

2

Elicit each group's technological frame through interviews, documents, and observation, surfacing the assumptions, expectations, and knowledge that members hold about the nature, purpose, and use of the technology. Orlikowski and Gash propose examining domains such as the nature of the technology, its strategy, and its conditions of use. The goal is to reconstruct the taken-for-granted understandings that members would rarely articulate spontaneously.

3

Analyse the content of each frame: its goals, key problems, problem-solving strategies, requirements to be met, and the theories and tacit knowledge embedded within it. Bijker's framework attends to how a frame confers semiotic power, making some readings of the artefact obvious and others almost unthinkable. The analyst characterises how inclusion in the frame shapes perception and how the frame both enables and constrains action.

4

Compare frames across groups to assess their congruence or incongruence—where they align, diverge, or conflict in their assumptions about the technology. Orlikowski and Gash show that significant incongruence in frames is associated with difficulties, resistance, and unintended consequences in technology implementation. The analyst maps the specific dimensions on which frames clash rather than treating disagreement as undifferentiated.

5

Link the structure and (in)congruence of frames to technological and organisational outcomes: which design was adopted, how the artefact stabilised, why implementation succeeded or faltered. Bijker connects the dominance of a frame, and an actor's degree of inclusion in it, to the closure and stabilisation of artefacts. The analysis explains outcomes as the product of how groups interpreted the technology, not of the artefact's intrinsic properties alone.

Common pitfalls

  • Defining relevant social groups by formal job titles rather than by genuinely shared interpretations of the artefact.
  • Treating frames as fixed cognitive containers instead of evolving, contested resources for sense-making.
  • Reporting that frames 'differ' without specifying the dimensions and mechanisms of incongruence.
  • Reducing every implementation problem to frame incongruence while ignoring resources, incentives, and politics.

Frequently asked questions

How does a technological frame differ from a relevant social group?

A relevant social group is the set of actors who share a common interpretation of an artefact, while the technological frame is the structured content of that shared interpretation—the assumptions, goals, problems, and strategies that organise the group's interaction with the technology. In Bijker's account the two are tightly linked: the frame is what makes a collection of actors a group, and the group is what the frame structures. The frame is the meaning system; the group is the people who hold it.

What is frame incongruence and why does it matter?

Frame incongruence, in Orlikowski and Gash's terms, is a significant difference in the technological frames held by different groups—for example, managers seeing a system as a control tool while users see it as a work aid. They found that such incongruence is associated with implementation difficulties, conflict, and unintended uses. Diagnosing the specific dimensions of incongruence helps explain resistance and guides interventions to align expectations.

Is technological frames analysis the same as Goffman's frame analysis?

No. Goffman's frame analysis concerns how individuals organise everyday experience into interpretive frames, whereas technological frames analysis concerns the shared, group-level meanings attached specifically to technologies within STS and organisational research. Bijker's and Orlikowski and Gash's frames are about collective sense-making of artefacts and its consequences for design and use, drawing on the social-constructivist tradition rather than on interaction-order sociology.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Bijker, W. E. (1995). Of Bicycles, Bakelites, and Bulbs: Toward a Theory of Sociotechnical Change. MIT Press.

    ISBN: 9780262023764
    Copied.
  2. Orlikowski, W. J., & Gash, D. C. (1994). Technological frames: making sense of information technology in organizations. ACM Transactions on Information Systems, 12(2), 174-207.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.