Sociotechnical Imaginaries Analysis
- Introduced by
- Sheila Jasanoff & Sang-Hyun Kim
- Year
- 2009
- Type
- Qualitative interpretive and comparative method
- Family
- Co-production
What does it do?
Sociotechnical imaginaries analysis studies the collectively held, institutionally stabilised, and publicly performed visions of desirable futures that societies attach to science and technology.
Introduced by Sheila Jasanoff and Sang-Hyun Kim in their 2009 comparison of nuclear power in the United States and South Korea, the concept treats imaginaries as more than rhetoric: they are co-produced with the material and political order, shaping how technologies are designed, governed, and lived. The method reconstructs these visions from public discourse, traces how they become embedded in institutions and policy, and compares how the same technology animates different imaginaries across nations or eras.
The intuition behind the method
Every powerful technology arrives wrapped in a story about the good life it will help us reach—nuclear power as national security and abundant energy, the internet as a frontier of freedom, AI as either liberation or ruin. These stories are not idle daydreams; they are shared scripts that tell a society what future is worth striving for and what role science and technology should play in getting there. Because the scripts differ from country to country and decade to decade, the same reactor can mean 'safe modern progress' in one place and 'risky imposition' in another. Sociotechnical imaginaries analysis is the practice of reading these collective scripts and showing how they get written into laws, budgets, and machines.
History
The concept of sociotechnical imaginaries was introduced by Sheila Jasanoff and Sang-Hyun Kim in a 2009 Minerva article comparing the development and governance of nuclear power in the United States and South Korea, where the same technology was animated by strikingly different national visions—containment of risk versus aspiration to modernity. The framework drew on Jasanoff's idiom of co-production, in which the natural and social orders are produced together, and on earlier work on imaginaries by Benedict Anderson and Charles Taylor. The approach was elaborated and refined across many cases in the 2015 edited volume Dreamscapes of Modernity, which broadened the unit of analysis beyond the nation-state and consolidated sociotechnical imaginaries as a major analytic in contemporary STS.
When to use it
Use sociotechnical imaginaries analysis when you want to understand how collective visions of the future shape, and are shaped by, the development and governance of science and technology—especially in cross-national or historical comparison. It suits questions about why similar technologies are governed differently across societies, how states and institutions justify large technological programmes, and how public futures are co-produced with material and political order. The method assumes that imaginaries are durable, collective, and traceable in public discourse and institutions, and that interpretation can recover their normative content. It is less appropriate for fine-grained studies of individual cognition, for purely technical performance questions, or when no rich public discourse or institutional record exists to analyse.
Limitations and considerations
- Reconstructing a 'collective' imaginary risks overstating coherence and homogeneity within heterogeneous publics.
- The interpretive identification of visions depends on the analyst's reading of necessarily selective corpora.
- It can be difficult to establish the causal weight of an imaginary relative to interests, resources, and contingency.
- The concept's breadth invites loose application, with 'imaginary' stretched to cover any vision or narrative.
Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.
Strengths
- Links culture, politics, and technology by showing how shared visions of the future are co-produced with material order.
- Powerful for comparative analysis, explaining why similar technologies are governed differently across nations and eras.
- Captures the normative and affective dimensions of technology—hopes, fears, and notions of the good life—that other methods miss.
- Connects discourse to durable institutional outcomes, avoiding the reduction of imaginaries to mere talk.
Applications
- Comparing national imaginaries of nuclear energy, renewable transitions, or climate engineering and their governance.
- Analysing visions of artificial intelligence, biotechnology, or space exploration in state and corporate strategy.
- Studying how smart-city, digital-government, or platform futures are promised and institutionalised.
- Examining how research-funding agendas and innovation policy encode particular futures as desirable.
- Tracing public and historical imaginaries embedded in museums, world's fairs, and media representations of technology.
How it works
How it works
Define the object of study: a particular technology, sector, or future-oriented project, and the collective (typically a nation, but possibly an organisation or movement) that holds visions about it. Jasanoff and Kim ground imaginaries in specific cases such as nuclear power, allowing the analyst to bound the inquiry. The analyst specifies which desirable (or feared) futures, attainable through science and technology, are at stake.
Assemble a corpus of discourse and material in which the imaginary is articulated and performed: policy documents, legislation, expert and commission reports, speeches, media coverage, museum exhibits, and visual or promotional material. Because imaginaries are publicly performed, the analyst gathers sources across official, expert, and popular registers. The corpus is selected to capture how the vision is stated, justified, and circulated.
Identify the visions of desirable futures encoded in the corpus—what good is promised, what risks are downplayed or foregrounded, what social order the technology is meant to secure. The analyst reads for the normative content (what kind of life is held to be attainable) and the attribution of that future to scientific and technological capacity. These visions are distinguished from mere policy goals by their collective, durable, and future-oriented character.
Trace how the imaginary becomes stabilised and embedded in institutions, regulations, infrastructures, and practices, following the co-production of the vision with the material and political order. The analyst shows how an imaginary is enacted through law, funding, expert bodies, and technological design, and how it is reproduced or contested over time. This step distinguishes a fleeting promise from an imaginary that has acquired institutional durability.
Compare imaginaries across cases—different nations, periods, or social groups confronting the same or similar technology—to reveal how shared technical capacities give rise to divergent visions and orders. Jasanoff and Kim's contrast of US and South Korean nuclear imaginaries shows containment versus aspiration as organising logics. Comparison denaturalises each imaginary by demonstrating that it could have been otherwise.
Common pitfalls
- Treating an imaginary as uniformly shared when it is in fact contested, layered, or held only by elites.
- Confusing a transient political promise with a durable, institutionally embedded imaginary.
- Selecting sources that confirm a presumed national vision while ignoring counter-discourses and dissent.
- Asserting co-production without tracing the concrete institutional, legal, or material mechanisms that embed the vision.
Frequently asked questions
How is a sociotechnical imaginary different from a discourse or a narrative?
A sociotechnical imaginary is more specific and more consequential than a generic discourse: it is a collectively held, institutionally stabilised vision of a desirable future attainable through science and technology, and it is co-produced with material and political order. Where a narrative may be ephemeral or individual, an imaginary endures, is publicly performed, and becomes embedded in laws, funding, and infrastructures. The emphasis on institutional embedding and co-production distinguishes it from analysis of discourse alone.
Why is comparison so central to the method?
Comparison—across nations, periods, or groups confronting similar technologies—reveals that imaginaries are contingent rather than dictated by the technology itself. Jasanoff and Kim's contrast of US and South Korean nuclear programmes showed how the same artefact supported a logic of containment in one society and of aspiration in another. By showing that things could have been imagined otherwise, comparison denaturalises each vision and exposes the work of co-production.
Does an imaginary have to be held by an entire nation?
Not necessarily. The original 2009 study took the nation as its unit, but the 2015 Dreamscapes volume explicitly broadened the scope to imaginaries held by organisations, professions, social movements, and transnational communities. What matters is that the vision is collectively held, durable, and institutionally performed rather than the mere preference of an individual. The relevant collective is specified empirically as part of defining the object of study.
Related methods
Sources
Jasanoff, S., & Kim, S.-H. (2009). Containing the atom: sociotechnical imaginaries and nuclear power in the United States and South Korea. Minerva, 47(2), 119-146.
Open DOI referenceCopied.Jasanoff, S., & Kim, S.-H. (Eds.). (2015). Dreamscapes of Modernity: Sociotechnical Imaginaries and the Fabrication of Power. University of Chicago Press.
ISBN: 9780226276359Copied.