Skip to content
Back to search results

SES Framework

Introduced by
Elinor Ostrom
Year
2009
Type
Multi-tier diagnostic framework for sustainability of coupled human-natural systems
Family
Social-ecological systems / sustainability science
Font size

What does it do?

The social-ecological systems (SES) framework, set out by Elinor Ostrom in her 2009 Science paper, is a multi-tier diagnostic structure for analyzing why some coupled human-natural systems are governed sustainably and others are not.

It treats a social-ecological system as the interplay of four core subsystems, a resource system, the resource units it produces, a governance system, and the users, all embedded in broader social, economic, and political settings and related ecosystems. Each core subsystem unpacks into second- and lower-tier variables, giving a shared, nested vocabulary of dozens of attributes that can be drawn on selectively for a given question. The framework extends Ostrom's earlier Institutional Analysis and Development work to tightly coupled human-environment systems and is designed to support cumulative, comparable diagnosis of sustainability, including the conditions under which users self-organize to manage a resource.

The intuition behind the method

Studying whether a fishery, forest, or watershed will be sustained is hard because everything matters: the size and productivity of the resource, how predictable it is, how many users depend on it, how much they trust each other, what rights and monitoring exist, and how the wider economy and politics press in. The SES framework's idea is to give all these moving parts a common map so that researchers studying very different systems can describe them in the same terms and accumulate knowledge instead of each inventing their own categories. It nests the variables in tiers: at the top, four big boxes, the resource system, the resource units, the governance system, and the users; under each, a structured menu of more specific attributes you can zoom into when they are relevant. You do not use all of them every time. Instead you select the variables that are diagnostic for your question, much as a doctor runs the tests relevant to the symptoms, and then you ask how those attributes combine to produce the interactions and outcomes you observe, especially whether users are likely to organize themselves to govern the resource well.

History

The SES framework crystallized Elinor Ostrom's long program on common-pool resources and institutions into a single coupled-systems diagnostic. Building on the Institutional Analysis and Development framework and the empirical findings of Governing the Commons, Ostrom published the framework in her 2009 Science article, A General Framework for Analyzing Sustainability of Social-Ecological Systems, which introduced the four core subsystems, their second-tier variables, and the roughly ten variables affecting self-organization. Her 2011 Policy Studies Journal article clarified the relationship between the SES framework and the IAD framework from which it grew. After her 2009 Nobel Prize, the framework was widely adopted and extended by sustainability scientists, who elaborated the variable hierarchy, built coding databases, and applied it across fisheries, forestry, water, and beyond, making it a backbone of contemporary social-ecological systems research.

When to use it

Use the SES framework when you are studying a tightly coupled human-environment system, such as a fishery, forest, irrigation system, rangeland, or watershed, and you want a structured, comparable way to diagnose its sustainability or its potential for self-governance. It is well suited to comparative and cumulative research, because its shared multi-tier vocabulary lets findings from different systems be combined, and to mixed-methods diagnosis that draws on ecological and social data together. It is less appropriate when you need a predictive dynamic model of system behavior over time, where simulation or systems-dynamics methods fit better, or when the question is purely social or purely ecological with no genuine coupling; for the institutional detail of the governance subsystem it nests naturally with the IAD framework and the commons design principles.

Limitations and considerations

  • The large variable menu can become unwieldy, and selecting and operationalizing the right tiers requires substantial expertise and judgment.
  • It is a framework, not a predictive theory, so it organizes diagnosis but does not by itself forecast system dynamics over time.
  • Measuring many second-tier variables consistently is data-intensive, and comparability suffers when studies operationalize them differently.
  • Cross-scale and external drivers, captured only loosely as settings and related ecosystems, can be underweighted relative to the focal SES.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Gives coupled human-natural systems a shared multi-tier vocabulary, enabling comparable, cumulative diagnosis across very different cases.
  • Integrates ecological and social variables in one structure rather than treating the human and natural sides separately.
  • Is diagnostic and selective, letting researchers draw the variables relevant to a question instead of forcing an exhaustive checklist.
  • Directly operationalizes the question of when users self-organize, linking a set of measurable attributes to the likelihood of self-governance.

Applications

  • Diagnosing the sustainability of fisheries, forests, irrigation systems, and rangelands as coupled human-natural systems.
  • Assessing whether and where resource users are likely to self-organize to manage a commons.
  • Building comparable case databases that synthesize findings across many social-ecological systems.
  • Structuring interdisciplinary research so ecological and social variables are integrated under a common vocabulary.
  • Informing resource-governance policy by identifying which subsystem attributes drive observed social and ecological outcomes.

How it works

How it works

1

The first step is to delineate the social-ecological system as four interacting core subsystems, the resource system, the resource units, the governance system, and the users, set within external social, economic, and political settings and linked to related ecosystems. Ostrom's framework makes these four subsystems plus their context the top-level architecture for any SES. Drawing this boundary identifies what counts as the system under study and locates the human and ecological components on a single shared map, which is the precondition for comparable analysis across cases.

Formula
SES = (RS,\, RU,\, GS,\, U)\ \text{embedded in social, economic, political settings } S \text{ and ECO}
2

Each core subsystem is then decomposed into second-tier variables, such as the size, productivity, and predictability of the resource system, the mobility and economic value of resource units, the rules and organizations of the governance system, and the number, knowledge, and norms of the users. The 2009 framework laid out this structured menu of attributes, which subsequent work elaborated into a deeper multi-tier hierarchy. Unpacking the subsystems supplies a precise, controlled vocabulary so that an attribute named in one study means the same in another, enabling cumulative knowledge.

Formula
RS=\{RS_1..RS_k\},\ RU=\{..\},\ GS=\{..\},\ U=\{..\}\ \text{(second-tier variables)}
3

Because the full menu is large, the analyst selects the subset of variables diagnostic for the specific question rather than measuring everything. Ostrom emphasized that the framework is a diagnostic toolkit from which one draws the relevant tiers and variables for the problem at hand, not a checklist to be exhaustively completed. Choosing the diagnostic variables, guided by theory and prior findings about which attributes drive the outcome of interest, keeps the analysis tractable and focused while remaining anchored in the shared vocabulary.

Formula
V^* \subseteq \bigcup(\text{tiers}),\quad V^* = \text{variables diagnostic for the question}
4

The selected variables are then related to the system's interactions and outcomes. Interactions, such as harvesting, information sharing, conflict, monitoring, and self-organizing activities, arise from the configuration of the subsystems and produce outcomes measured by social performance, such as efficiency and equity, and ecological performance, such as resource sustainability. The framework places interactions and outcomes at the center, fed by the four subsystems and feeding back onto them. Analyzing this linkage is what turns a descriptive inventory of attributes into an explanation of why a system performs as it does.

Formula
(I, O) = \Phi(RS, RU, GS, U \mid S, ECO),\quad I=\text{interactions},\ O=\text{outcomes}
5

A signature use of the framework is diagnosing the likelihood of self-organization. Ostrom's 2009 paper highlighted about ten second-tier variables, including the size and productivity and predictability of the resource system, the mobility of resource units, and the number of users, leadership, shared norms, and knowledge of the SES, that jointly affect whether users will organize to govern the resource. Assessing how these variables line up in a given case yields a diagnosis of whether self-governance is likely to emerge and be sustained, connecting the framework directly to the policy question of when to rely on user self-organization versus external intervention.

Formula
\Pr(\text{self-organize}) = h(\text{size},\, \text{productivity},\, \text{predictability},\, \text{leadership},\, \text{norms},\, \dots)

Common pitfalls

  • Treating the framework as a mandatory checklist and trying to fill in every variable rather than selecting the diagnostic ones.
  • Describing the subsystems but never linking them to interactions and outcomes, so the analysis stays descriptive.
  • Operationalizing second-tier variables idiosyncratically, which destroys the comparability that is the framework's main payoff.
  • Ignoring the external social, economic, and political settings and related ecosystems, and analyzing the focal SES as if it were closed.

Frequently asked questions

How is the SES framework different from the IAD framework?

They are closely related and were both developed by Ostrom. The IAD framework is a general institutional-analysis scaffold centered on the action situation and its rules, applicable to any collective-action problem. The SES framework extends and specializes that thinking for tightly coupled human-environment systems, replacing the generic structure with four concrete subsystems, the resource system, resource units, governance system, and users, and a rich multi-tier menu of ecological and social variables. In Ostrom's 2011 account, the SES framework nests the IAD's action situation inside the interactions of these subsystems, so IAD supplies the institutional detail while SES supplies the coupled-system architecture.

Do I have to measure all the SES variables to use the framework?

No. Ostrom designed the framework explicitly as a diagnostic toolkit, not a mandatory checklist. The full multi-tier hierarchy contains far more variables than any single study needs, and the intended practice is to select the tiers and variables that are diagnostic for your particular question, guided by theory and prior findings about what drives the outcome you care about. Trying to populate every variable is a common misuse that makes the analysis unwieldy; the value lies in using the shared vocabulary to measure the relevant subset comparably.

What does the framework say about when communities can govern resources themselves?

Self-organization is one of the framework's headline applications. Ostrom's 2009 paper singled out roughly ten second-tier variables that jointly raise or lower the chance that users will organize to govern a resource, including the size, productivity, and predictability of the resource system, the mobility of the resource units, and, among users, the number involved, leadership, shared norms or social capital, and knowledge of the system. By assessing how these line up in a case, the framework yields a structured diagnosis of whether self-governance is likely to emerge, helping decide when to support user self-organization rather than impose external control.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Ostrom, E. (2009). A General Framework for Analyzing Sustainability of Social-Ecological Systems. Science, 325(5939), 419-422.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.
  2. Ostrom, E. (2011). Background on the Institutional Analysis and Development Framework. Policy Studies Journal, 39(1), 7-27.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.