Skip to content
Back to search results

Sense-Making Methodology

Introduced by
Brenda Dervin
Year
1998
Type
Methodology and metaphor for studying how people make sense across discontinuity
Family
Information behavior / constructivist user studies
Font size

What does it do?

Sense-Making Methodology, developed by Brenda Dervin from the 1970s onward and synthesized in her 1998 overview, is a theory and method for studying how people construct meaning as they move through life and are repeatedly stopped by gaps in their understanding.

Its central metaphor pictures a person moving through time-space, halted at a moment of discontinuity (a gap), and building a bridge across it by seeking and using information. Rather than classifying users by demographic traits, Sense-Making asks what situation a person was in, what gap or question they faced, and what help or use they sought — the situation-gap-use triad — elicited through the distinctive Time-Line and Micro-Moment interview. The approach reframes information not as an objective thing transmitted but as a construction people make sense of in context.

The intuition behind the method

Imagine walking along a path and suddenly hitting a ravine: you cannot keep going until you build some kind of bridge. Dervin's idea is that life is full of these moments — a confusing diagnosis, a broken appliance, an unfamiliar bureaucracy — where our ordinary sense of how things work runs out and we stop, stuck. At that gap we ask questions and reach for help; the answers we use are the planks of the bridge that gets us moving again. The power of this picture is that it shifts attention away from who the person is (their age, job or education) and toward what they are facing right now. Two very different people in the same kind of gap may need the same help, and the same person in different gaps needs different help. Sense-Making studies information by zooming in on these stopped moments and asking, in the person's own terms, what was in their way and what would have bridged it.

History

Brenda Dervin developed Sense-Making from the 1970s as a critique of source- and system-centered communication and information research that classified audiences by demographics and treated information as objective messages. Drawing on constructivist and phenomenological ideas, she proposed studying communication and information seeking as situated acts of meaning construction, formalizing the situation-gap-use metaphor and the Time-Line and Micro-Moment interview methods. Her 1983 conference overview and her 1998 Journal of Knowledge Management synthesis, 'Sense-making theory and practice,' consolidated the approach. Over subsequent decades Sense-Making became a foundational user-centered methodology in library and information science, communication and knowledge management, influencing reference practice, user studies, and the broader turn toward studying information behavior from the user's perspective.

When to use it

Use Sense-Making Methodology when you want to understand information needs and use from the user's own perspective, in context, and especially when conventional demographic or system-centered approaches fail to explain behavior. It is well suited to studying how people cope with confusing, novel or troubling situations, to redesigning services around real questions rather than assumed audiences, and to comparing needs across diverse populations through a shared situational lens. It is less appropriate when you need quick quantitative prevalence estimates, when the task is routine known-item retrieval with no real discontinuity, or when resources do not allow the intensive, in-depth interviewing the method demands. The approach is fundamentally qualitative and constructivist, so it fits exploratory, theory-building, and service-design goals better than confirmatory hypothesis testing.

Limitations and considerations

  • Intensive interviewing and coding make it labor-intensive and hard to scale to large samples.
  • Its constructivist stance and bespoke vocabulary can be difficult to operationalize consistently across analysts.
  • Findings are situational and interpretive, so generalization and quantitative prevalence claims are limited.
  • Reliance on recall of past stopped moments introduces memory and reconstruction bias.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Centers the user's own sense-making, eliciting needs in context rather than imposing system- or expert-defined categories.
  • The situation-gap-use triad is content- and demographic-neutral, allowing comparison of information needs across very different people and topics.
  • The Time-Line and Micro-Moment interview yields concrete, event-grounded accounts that resist vague generalization.
  • Provides a coherent theory-and-method package linking a constructivist view of information to practical service and system design.

Applications

  • Studying how people seek and use information when coping with confusing health, civic or everyday situations.
  • Redesigning library reference and information services around users' actual questions rather than assumed audience types.
  • Comparing information needs across diverse populations using the demographic-neutral situation-gap-use lens.
  • Informing user-centered system and interface design that enters dialogue to discover gaps and intended uses.
  • Evaluating communication campaigns and knowledge-management practice by how well they bridge audience gaps.

How it works

How it works

1

The methodology starts from its core metaphor: a person moves through time and space, is stopped by a gap (a moment of discontinuity where prior sense no longer suffices), and bridges that gap to continue. This is a deliberate ontological commitment — information seeking is modeled as gap-bridging across discontinuity, and information itself is treated as a human construction, not an objective substance that exists independently of the people making sense of it. Adopting the metaphor reorients the whole inquiry around movement, blockage and bridging rather than around messages and channels.

Formula
\text{Situation}\ \xrightarrow{\ \text{Gap}\ }\ \text{Outcome},\quad \text{movement halted at a gap requiring a bridge}
2

Each stopped moment is then decomposed into three elements: the Situation (the context in time and space where the person was stopped), the Gap (the question, confusion or sense-need that halted them), and the Use (the help they sought and how they intended to use it). This situation-gap-use triad is the analytic unit. Crucially, people are characterized by the gaps they face and the help they need, not by static demographic categories, which lets the methodology compare information needs across very different individuals who share a situational structure.

Formula
M = (S,\,G,\,U),\quad S=\text{situation},\ G=\text{gap/question},\ U=\text{use/help sought}
3

Data are gathered with Dervin's signature interview techniques: the Time-Line interview asks a person to reconstruct an experience as a sequence of steps or events, and at each step the Micro-Moment questions probe the situation, the gaps, and the help sought and used. By walking through the timeline moment by moment and consistently asking the same gap-bridging questions, the interview elicits richly contextual, comparable accounts of how the person made (or failed to make) sense, grounded in concrete events rather than generalizations.

Formula
\text{Time-Line: } e_1\to e_2\to\cdots\to e_n,\quad \forall e_i\ \text{elicit } (S_i,G_i,U_i)\ \text{(Micro-Moment)}
4

Analysis maps gaps to uses, categorizing the kinds of help people sought by the structure of their questions and needs rather than by subject or demographic group. Dervin's gap and use categories (for example, questions oriented to understanding causes, locating things, or projecting consequences) allow the analyst to see patterns in how particular kinds of discontinuity drive particular kinds of help-seeking. This produces a situational, needs-based picture of information behavior that travels across topics and populations.

Formula
U_i = f(G_i \mid S_i),\quad \text{help-needs categorized by question type, not demographic}
5

Finally, the findings inform the design of dialogic, situation-responsive services and systems. Because needs arise from gaps rather than fixed user types, effective information services must enter into dialogue to discover the person's situation, gap and intended use, then bridge accordingly. Sense-Making thus underwrites reference interviewing, user-centered system design and communication practice that adapts to the sense a person is trying to make, rather than pushing predefined content at presumed audience segments.

Formula
\text{system}^{*}=\arg\max\,\Pr\bigl(\text{bridge}\mid (S,G,U)\bigr),\quad \text{dialogic, situation-responsive}

Common pitfalls

  • Reverting to demographic categorization of users, which abandons the method's defining situational, gap-based stance.
  • Collecting timeline events without consistently probing situation, gap and use at each micro-moment, losing the analytic triad.
  • Treating information as an objective thing to be delivered rather than a construction the person must make sense of.
  • Designing services around assumed audiences instead of entering dialogue to discover the actual gap and intended use.

Frequently asked questions

What is the situation-gap-use triad at the core of Sense-Making?

It is the three-part analytic unit Dervin uses to describe a moment when someone is stopped and seeks information. The Situation is the time-space context in which the person was halted; the Gap is the question or sense-need that stopped them; and the Use is the help they sought and how they planned to use it to move on. By characterizing people through the gaps they face and the help they need rather than through fixed demographic traits, the triad lets researchers compare information needs across very different individuals and topics.

How does the Micro-Moment Time-Line interview work?

The respondent reconstructs an experience as a time-line — an ordered sequence of steps or events that actually happened. At each step (each micro-moment) the interviewer asks a consistent set of questions probing what the situation was, what gaps or confusions arose, and what help the person sought and how they used it. Anchoring questions to concrete events rather than asking for general opinions produces detailed, comparable, context-rich accounts of how the person made sense, which is what the analysis then categorizes.

How does Sense-Making differ from system-centered information studies?

System- and source-centered studies start from messages, channels and audience demographics, treating information as an objective thing to be transmitted to defined groups. Sense-Making instead starts from the user's situated act of constructing meaning, treats information as a human construction, and characterizes need by the gap a person faces rather than by who they are. The practical implication is that good services and systems must be dialogic and situation-responsive — discovering each person's situation, gap and intended use — rather than pushing predefined content at presumed audience segments.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Dervin, B. (1998). Sense-making theory and practice: an overview of user interests in knowledge seeking and use. Journal of Knowledge Management, 2(2), 36-46.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.