Second-Level Agenda Setting
- Introduced by
- Maxwell McCombs and colleagues (Weaver et al.)
- Year
- 1981
- Type
- Analysis of the transfer of attribute salience from media to public
- Family
- Agenda-setting research
What does it do?
Second-level (attribute) agenda setting extends classic agenda-setting theory from the salience of objects — which issues or people the public thinks about — to the salience of their attributes — which characteristics the public associates with them.
The method codes the attributes media emphasize when covering an object and correlates that attribute agenda with the attributes salient in public perceptions.
The intuition behind the method
First-level agenda setting shows that the more the news covers an issue, the more important the public thinks it is. Second-level agenda setting asks a subtler question: among the many features of a candidate or issue, which ones rise to prominence in people's minds? If coverage of a politician dwells on competence and ethics, those become the lenses through which the public sizes them up. So the analysis builds two attribute agendas — what media stress and what the public stresses — and measures whether the media's attribute emphasis transfers to the public's, separating substantive attributes (issue positions, qualifications) from affective ones (positive, negative, neutral tone).
History
The seeds of attribute agenda setting appear in Weaver, Graber, McCombs, and Eyal's 1981 study of the 1976 U.S. presidential election, which examined candidate images alongside issues. McCombs and colleagues later formalized the 'second level' in the 1990s, with Spanish-election studies among the canonical demonstrations of attribute salience transfer. The concept sharpened the relationship between agenda setting and framing and led, ultimately, to network agenda setting (the third level), which models the transfer of relationships among attributes rather than attributes in isolation.
When to use it
Use second-level agenda-setting analysis when your interest is not whether an object is salient but which of its characteristics dominate public perception, and whether media emphasis shapes that. It suits studies of candidate image, country and corporate reputation, and issue characterization, and it pairs naturally with first-level agenda setting and framing. It assumes attributes can be reliably coded in coverage and validly elicited from the public, and that salience can be meaningfully ranked. It is less appropriate when objects lack stable attributes, when public attribute salience cannot be measured cleanly, or when you need causal proof of transfer — the correlational design shows correspondence, not causation, so experimental or over-time evidence is needed to support a media-to-public influence claim.
Limitations and considerations
- Correlational design cannot establish that media attribute emphasis causes public attribute salience.
- Defining and bounding the attribute set is judgment-laden and affects the resulting correlation.
- Overlaps conceptually with framing, prompting debate about whether attribute agenda setting and framing are distinct.
- Public attribute salience is hard to measure cleanly, especially with closed-ended scales that may impose attributes.
Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.
Strengths
- Extends agenda setting from importance to characterization, capturing how media shape the image of objects.
- Distinguishes substantive from affective attribute agendas, offering a richer account than object salience alone.
- Bridges agenda setting and framing, providing an operational link between the two traditions.
- Applies across domains — political image, reputation, and country branding — with a consistent salience-transfer logic.
Applications
- Analyzing how media coverage shapes the attributes the public associates with political candidates.
- Studying country image and nation branding through attribute salience transfer in international news.
- Examining corporate reputation as the transfer of emphasized company attributes to public perception.
- Comparing substantive versus affective attribute agendas across outlets and over a campaign.
- Linking attribute agenda setting to framing analyses of the same coverage.
How it works
How it works
The analyst identifies the object(s) of interest — a candidate, country, company, or issue — and a set of attributes (substantive characteristics and affective tone) along which the object can be described.
A content analysis codes how frequently and prominently media coverage emphasizes each attribute of the object, producing a media attribute agenda; intercoder reliability is established for the attribute codes.
Public attribute salience is measured through surveys or open-ended responses asking what comes to mind about the object, yielding a parallel public attribute agenda.
The media attribute agenda is correlated with the public attribute agenda (typically a rank-order or product-moment correlation across attributes); a strong positive correlation indicates attribute salience transfer — second-level agenda setting.
Formula
\rho = \mathrm{corr}\!\left(S^{\text{media}}_{a},\, S^{\text{public}}_{a}\right)Common pitfalls
- Imposing a fixed attribute list on the public via closed questions, manufacturing correspondence with the media agenda.
- Inferring causal transfer from a single cross-sectional correlation without temporal ordering.
- Conflating substantive and affective attributes into one index, hiding which dimension transferred.
- Treating second-level agenda setting and framing as identical, ignoring the applicability-versus-salience distinction.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between first- and second-level agenda setting?
First-level agenda setting concerns the salience of objects — whether the public considers an issue or person important, driven by how much coverage it receives. Second-level agenda setting concerns the salience of attributes — which characteristics of that object become prominent in public perception, driven by which attributes coverage emphasizes. First level is about what to think about; second level is about how the object is characterized.
How is attribute agenda setting different from framing?
They overlap and are sometimes equated, since both concern emphasis on aspects of an object. The common distinction is mechanism: attribute agenda setting describes the transfer of attribute salience via accessibility, while framing emphasizes the applicability of considerations and the construction of interpretive packages. Many scholars treat second-level agenda setting as the salience-transfer face of framing, while others insist framing's interpretive, package-based logic is theoretically distinct from mere attribute prominence.
What are substantive and affective attributes?
Substantive (cognitive) attributes are the descriptive characteristics of an object — a candidate's issue positions, qualifications, or ideology. Affective attributes are the evaluative tone associated with the object — positive, negative, or neutral. Second-level analyses typically build separate agendas for each, because media and public can correspond strongly on one dimension and weakly on the other, and reporting them separately reveals which kind of salience transferred.
Related methods
Sources
McCombs, M. E., & Shaw, D. L. (1972). The agenda-setting function of mass media. Public Opinion Quarterly, 36(2), 176–187.
Open DOI referenceCopied.Weaver, D. H., Graber, D. A., McCombs, M. E., & Eyal, C. H. (1981). Media Agenda-Setting in a Presidential Election: Issues, Images, and Interest. New York: Praeger.
ISBN: 9780275907389Copied.