Skip to content
Back to search results

Responding to Peer Reviewer Comments: Revision Letter and Manuscript Revision

Introduced by
Journal editors and publishing community; formalized by Clydesdale et al. and ICMJE
Year
2005
Type
Guideline
Family
publication-process
Font size

What does it do?

A response to reviewers (or 'revision letter') is a formal document that authors submit alongside a revised manuscript, addressing each reviewer comment point-by-point.

The response letter shows the editor and reviewers that you have carefully considered their feedback, explained changes made in light of their suggestions, and justified any points of disagreement. A thoughtful, respectful response to reviewers significantly increases the likelihood of acceptance; a dismissive or defensive response can lead to rejection despite good science. The response letter is not an argument but a demonstration of engagement, transparency, and scientific integrity.

The intuition behind the method

Peer review feedback can feel harsh or unfair. Authors' first instinct is often defensiveness ('The reviewer missed the point,' 'That criticism is wrong'). However, the goal of the response letter is not to win an argument with reviewers but to show the editor that you are a professional who takes feedback seriously and has made your manuscript stronger as a result. Even if a reviewer's comment is technically incorrect, the response letter is an opportunity to clarify your work, not to shame the reviewer. Reviewers are volunteers; they made mistakes or misunderstood something, which your response can address. Editors read both the reviewer comments and your response; a professional response that addresses concerns transparently builds editor confidence in your work and increases acceptance likelihood. Moreover, addressing reviewer concerns often does strengthen the manuscript, even if you initially disagreed with the feedback.

History

The formal revision response letter is a relatively recent practice in academic publishing. Before the 1990s, authors would simply resubmit a revised manuscript without a detailed response. As peer review became more systematized and reviewer burden increased, editors began requiring structured responses to help them track changes and verify that concerns were addressed. Clydesdale et al.'s 2013 article in the British Journal of Ophthalmology ('How to Write a Response to Reviewers') formalized best practices and was widely cited. Today, most journals (especially those using ScholarOne or Editorial Manager submission systems) request or require a response letter. Some journals provide templates or guidance; others leave format to the author. The ICMJE Recommendations emphasize transparent engagement with reviewers as part of the publication process.

When to use it

Prepare a response to reviewers whenever you receive reviewer comments requiring revision ('minor revisions' or 'major revisions'). Always submit a response letter, even for minor revisions; it shows professionalism and helps the editor track changes. For 'desk rejections' (rejection without peer review), there is no reviewer feedback to respond to; you may write a brief response to the editor explaining why the manuscript should be reconsidered (rarely successful, so usually not recommended). For 'accept with minor revisions,' a brief response acknowledging the comments and confirming changes is sufficient (can be shorter than a full revision response).

Limitations and considerations

  • Requires emotional resilience: responding professionally to harsh or unfair criticism is emotionally demanding; many authors struggle with this.
  • Time-consuming: thoroughly addressing all comments and revising the manuscript takes weeks; tight deadlines may force rushed responses.
  • Cannot guarantee acceptance: even a perfect response does not guarantee acceptance; the editor has final say and may choose to reject.
  • Risk of over-revision: sometimes authors change too much in response to feedback, diluting the original contribution; selectivity is needed.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Demonstrates professionalism: a well-written response shows the editor that you are a serious researcher who takes feedback constructively.
  • Increases acceptance likelihood: most editors and reviewers view a thoughtful response as a positive sign; it often tips the decision toward acceptance.
  • Clarifies misunderstandings: if a reviewer misunderstood a point, the response provides an opportunity to clarify without having to rewrite the manuscript.
  • Strengthens the manuscript: even if you initially disagreed with feedback, engaging with it often improves clarity or completeness.
  • Builds editor confidence: a professional response builds trust that you will be a cooperative, collegial author; editors value this for future submissions.

Applications

  • Revising your first submission: anticipate that you will receive revision requests; plan to spend weeks addressing reviewer feedback and preparing a thorough response letter.
  • Responding to desk rejection: rare, but if you believe the desk rejection is unjustified, you can write a brief response to the editor explaining the manuscript's merit and requesting reconsideration (but success rate is <5%).
  • Handling major revisions: organize your response by reviewer; if two reviewers made similar comments, address them together (e.g., 'Multiple reviewers noted that Methods were unclear...'). This shows you have synthesized the feedback.
  • Disagreeing with a reviewer: if you genuinely believe a reviewer is wrong (and have evidence), respectfully explain your position with citations. However, consider whether a minor change might address the concern without compromising your work.

How it works

How it works

1

To prepare a revision response: (1) Read all reviewer comments carefully and take time before responding—24 hours minimum to get over initial emotional reaction. (2) Create a master list of all reviewer comments, organizing by reviewer and by topic. (3) For each comment, decide: (a) Do I agree? If yes, what change will I make? (b) Do I disagree? If so, what evidence or reasoning supports my position? (c) Can I clarify the point without changing the manuscript? (4) Make changes to the manuscript first. Highlight changes (track changes in Word or similar) so reviewers can see what was revised. (5) Prepare the response letter as a structured document. Format: List each reviewer comment (quoted or paraphrased), numbered (e.g., 'Reviewer 1, Comment 1', 'Reviewer 1, Comment 2', etc.). For each comment, provide a response in one of these formats: 'We agree. We have [changed/clarified/added X] in the manuscript (see page X, lines Y–Z).' or 'Thank you for this suggestion. We have [made change] because [reason]. See page X.' or 'We respectfully disagree with this comment. [Explain your reasoning with citations or data]. However, we have [made change] to improve clarity.' (6) Keep tone professional, objective, and respectful. Avoid defensiveness, sarcasm, or dismissiveness. (7) Use formal language and complete sentences (not bullet points, which feel abrupt). (8) If a comment addresses something already in the manuscript, cite the location: 'As stated on page 4, lines 10–15, we collected...'. (9) If you made substantial changes in response to a comment, explain the change and why it strengthens the manuscript. (10) At the end of the response letter, include a brief summary statement: 'We have carefully revised the manuscript in response to all reviewer comments. We believe the revised version is significantly strengthened and ready for publication.' (11) Attach the response letter and marked-up manuscript to your resubmission.

2

A quality response to reviewers meets these criteria: (1) Completeness: every reviewer comment is addressed; no comments are ignored or dismissed. (2) Specificity: for each change, cite the page and line numbers in the revised manuscript; vague references ('fixed throughout' without specificity) are not acceptable. (3) Tone: professional, respectful, objective; free from defensiveness, sarcasm, or hostility. (4) Transparency: the response explains the reasoning behind each change, not just stating what was changed. (5) Accuracy: claims in the response are verifiable in the revised manuscript; any citations or references mentioned are correct. (6) Conciseness: responses are brief and focused; unnecessary elaboration undermines credibility. (7) Organization: comments are organized logically (by reviewer or by topic); the structure makes it easy for the editor to verify that all concerns are addressed. (8) Engagement: the response demonstrates that you value the feedback and have thought carefully about how to address it; even disagreements are stated respectfully with evidence.

3

The editor reads your response letter alongside reviewer comments and the revised manuscript. The editor verifies: (1) Did the author address all comments? (2) Are the changes substantial and appropriate? (3) Is the response respectful and professional? (4) Does the revised manuscript reflect the changes described in the response? If yes to all, the editor is likely to recommend acceptance (though may still send to reviewers for verification of major revisions). If the response is dismissive, incomplete, or argues with reviewers without evidence, the editor may reject or request further revision. A second round of review may occur; reviewers will check whether their concerns were adequately addressed. A professional, substantive response increases the likelihood that reviewers and editors will feel their feedback was valued and acted upon, improving chances of acceptance.

Common pitfalls

  • Defensive tone: phrases like 'The reviewer is wrong' or 'This criticism is unfounded' signal defensiveness and reduce editor confidence. Instead: 'We believe the reviewer may have misunderstood; we clarified this in the manuscript (page X).'
  • Incomplete responses: ignoring some reviewer comments or responding superficially ('As noted by Reviewer 1, we made minor revisions') without specifying what changed.
  • Vague citations: saying 'We clarified this throughout the manuscript' without page numbers; editors cannot verify the claim.
  • Overcomplaining: lengthy explanations of why a reviewer was wrong or impractical suggestions that you cannot implement ('We cannot recruit more participants as requested' if the study is already complete) undermine your credibility.
  • Changing the manuscript without explanation: if a change is made in response to a comment, explain it in the response letter. Reviewers check that changes are appropriate; unexplained changes may raise concerns.
  • Arguing with reviewers: tone matters. If you disagree with a comment, explain respectfully why (with evidence) and offer an alternative approach. Do not lecture reviewers or imply they are ignorant.

Frequently asked questions

What tone should I use in a response to reviewers?

Professional, respectful, objective. Imagine the response is being read by a committee evaluating your professionalism; maintain that standard. Use formal language ('We appreciate the suggestion' not 'Thanks for the note'). Acknowledge the reviewer's effort ('We thank Reviewer 2 for their thorough evaluation'). Explain changes without justifying or defending ('We clarified this in the Methods' rather than 'We did clarify this; Reviewer 2 must have missed it'). Even if you disagree, frame it positively ('We considered this suggestion. However, [explain why you made a different choice]').

Should I address reviewer comments I disagree with?

Yes, all comments should be addressed, including those you disagree with. For disagreement, explain your reasoning with evidence (citations, prior studies, logic). Option 1: 'We respectfully disagree because [explanation with evidence]. However, we have [made a change to improve clarity] even if not strictly necessary.' Option 2: 'We understand Reviewer 1's concern. However, [explain why your approach is appropriate based on literature or methodology].' Always be respectful; never imply the reviewer is wrong or foolish. End with a positive frame: 'We believe the current approach is appropriate, and we have clarified this in the manuscript.''

How long should a response letter be?

Typically 1–3 pages for minor revisions, 3–5 pages for major revisions. Length depends on the number and complexity of comments. Each comment deserves a complete (but concise) response. Avoid excessive elaboration; editors prefer clear, focused responses. A rule of thumb: if a response to a single comment exceeds 3–4 sentences, you may be over-explaining. Trim to the essentials.

What if a reviewer asks for something I cannot do (e.g., recruit more participants, conduct additional experiments)?

Explain clearly and respectfully why the request cannot be fulfilled ('The recruitment phase has closed; we cannot enroll additional participants'). Offer an alternative if possible ('However, we have [conducted a sensitivity analysis / consulted unpublished data / explained the limitation in the Discussion]'). Editors understand that some requests are impractical; transparency about constraints builds credibility. Do not ignore the request or submit without addressing it.

Should I cite the page and line numbers for every change?

Yes, for every change that you have made in response to feedback. Format: 'See page 3, lines 12–18' or 'Page 4, paragraph 2.' This makes it easy for the editor and reviewers to verify that your claim is accurate. Without specific citations, reviewers may not trust that you actually made the change they requested.

Can I refuse to make a change a reviewer requested?

Technically yes, but explain why. If a requested change contradicts your findings, methodology, or interpretation, state this clearly with evidence. Example: 'Reviewer 1 suggests we analyze the data with [method]. However, [method] is not appropriate for [reason, e.g., our data violate the assumption of normality]. We have instead used [your method], which is standard for [context].' The editor will weigh your reasoning against the reviewer's concern. Most editors side with authors if the reasoning is sound and supported by citations.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Clydesdale, G. J., Seymour, K. J., & Toy, M. S. (2013). How to write a response to reviewers. British Journal of Ophthalmology, 97(1), 1–2.

    Open publication reference
    Copied.
  2. Wager, E., & Wieland, B. (2011). Responsibilities of journal editors. Lancet, 337(9834), 1807–1809.

    Open publication reference
    Copied.
  3. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (2023). Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals.

    Open publication reference
    Copied.