Skip to content
Back to search results

Occupational Gender Segregation Index

Introduced by
Otis Dudley Duncan & Beverly Duncan
Year
1955
Type
Distributional segregation index
Family
Labour-market segregation indices
Font size

What does it do?

Occupational gender segregation indices measure how unevenly women and men are distributed across occupations.

The most widely used is the Duncan and Duncan index of dissimilarity, introduced in 1955, which gives the share of women (or men) who would have to change occupations for the two distributions to match. Together with margin-free alternatives and decompositions into horizontal and vertical components, these indices are the standard tools for quantifying the sex segregation of labour markets.

The intuition behind the method

Even when women and men participate in the labour market at similar rates, they often cluster in different jobs — women in care, clerical, and service work, men in trades, transport, and engineering. The dissimilarity index captures this clustering with a single number: it asks what fraction of one sex would have to move to a different occupation so that both sexes were spread across occupations identically. A value of 0 means women and men are distributed the same way; a value near 1 means they work in almost entirely separate occupational worlds.

History

Otis Dudley Duncan and Beverly Duncan introduced the index of dissimilarity in a 1955 American Sociological Review paper that clarified the relationships among competing segregation measures, originally in the context of residential segregation; the measure was quickly adopted for occupational sex segregation. Later scholars addressed its margin-dependence: Maria Charles and David Grusky developed log-multiplicative models in Occupational Ghettos (2004), and Robert Blackburn and colleagues formalised the horizontal–vertical decomposition, reframing segregation as a multidimensional phenomenon rather than a single quantity.

When to use it

Use occupational segregation indices to measure and compare the extent to which women and men work in different jobs, to track changes over time, and to study the link between segregation and the gender pay gap. They are well suited to descriptive and comparative labour-market analysis. Use margin-free variants and decompositions when comparing across countries or periods with different occupational structures or female participation, and be cautious treating a single dissimilarity value as comparable across studies using different occupational classifications.

Limitations and considerations

  • The basic dissimilarity index is sensitive to the occupational classification's granularity and to the marginal distributions.
  • It is descriptive: it quantifies segregation but does not explain its causes or its consequences for pay.
  • A single index can mask whether segregation is horizontal (difference) or vertical (hierarchy), which differ in normative significance.
  • Comparisons across countries are fragile when occupational coding schemes are not harmonised.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • The dissimilarity index has a direct, intuitive interpretation as the share who would have to switch occupations to equalise distributions.
  • Computable from standard sex-by-occupation employment tables available in most labour statistics.
  • Extends to margin-free and size-standardised forms that support valid cross-national and over-time comparison.
  • Decomposable into horizontal and vertical components that separate difference from hierarchy.

Applications

  • Measuring the extent of sex segregation in national and regional labour markets.
  • Tracking whether occupational segregation has declined as female labour-force participation has risen.
  • Comparing segregation patterns across countries using margin-free, size-standardised models.
  • Linking the vertical component of segregation to the gender pay gap in decomposition studies.
  • Studying segregation in education by field of study as a precursor to occupational segregation.

How it works

How it works

1

The labour force is cross-tabulated by sex and a set of occupational categories, giving the number of women and the number of men in each occupation. The granularity of the occupational classification matters: finer categories typically reveal more segregation than broad ones, so the classification scheme must be reported alongside any index value.

2

The index of dissimilarity D sums, across occupations, the absolute difference between each occupation's share of all women and its share of all men, then halves the total. The result ranges from zero (identical distributions, no segregation) to one (complete segregation). Its appealing interpretation is the share of women — equivalently of men — who would need to switch occupations to eliminate the difference between the two distributions.

Formula
D = \tfrac{1}{2}\sum_{i=1}^{k}\left|\dfrac{F_i}{F} - \dfrac{M_i}{M}\right|
3

Because the basic dissimilarity index is sensitive to the marginal distributions — the overall sex composition of the labour force and the relative sizes of occupations — analysts use margin-free or size-standardised variants. Charles and Grusky advocate log-multiplicative models that separate segregation from the marginal sizes, allowing meaningful comparison across countries and over time when occupational structures and female participation differ.

4

Segregation is further decomposed into a horizontal dimension (women and men in different but not necessarily unequal occupations) and a vertical dimension (concentration in higher- or lower-status, better- or worse-paid positions). Blackburn and colleagues formalise this split, arguing that overall segregation can be high while the vertical, inequality-bearing component is modest, or vice versa, so the two dimensions carry different normative weight.

Common pitfalls

  • Comparing dissimilarity values computed with different occupational classifications as if they measured the same thing.
  • Ignoring marginal effects, so that a change in the index reflects shifting occupation sizes rather than real desegregation.
  • Reading high overall segregation as high inequality without separating its vertical component from its horizontal component.
  • Treating the index as causal evidence about discrimination rather than a description of the distribution.

Frequently asked questions

What does a dissimilarity index of 0.5 mean?

It means that half of women (equivalently, half of men) would have to move to a different occupation for women and men to be distributed identically across occupations. The index runs from zero, where the two sexes have the same occupational distribution, to one, where they share no occupations. The interpretation depends on the occupational classification used, so the categories should always be reported.

Why use margin-free indices instead of the simple dissimilarity index?

The simple dissimilarity index changes when the overall share of women in the labour force or the relative sizes of occupations change, even if the underlying tendency to segregate does not. Margin-free and log-multiplicative measures, such as those Charles and Grusky use, hold the marginals constant so that comparisons across countries and over time reflect genuine differences in segregation rather than differences in labour-force composition.

What is the difference between horizontal and vertical segregation?

Horizontal segregation is the tendency for women and men to work in different occupations that are not necessarily ranked — for example nursing versus carpentry. Vertical segregation is concentration at different levels of a hierarchy, with one sex over-represented in higher-status, better-paid positions. The same overall index value can reflect very different mixes of the two, and only the vertical component maps cleanly onto inequality, which is why decomposition matters.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Duncan, O. D., & Duncan, B. (1955). A methodological analysis of segregation indexes. American Sociological Review, 20(2), 210–217.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.
  2. Charles, M., & Grusky, D. B. (2004). Occupational Ghettos: The Worldwide Segregation of Women and Men. Stanford University Press.

    ISBN: 9780804748803
    Copied.
  3. Blackburn, R. M., Jarman, J., & Brooks, B. (2000). The puzzle of gender segregation and inequality: A cross-national analysis. European Sociological Review, 16(2), 119–135.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.