Skip to content
Back to search results

Most Significant Change for Development

Introduced by
Rick Davies & Jess Dart
Year
2005
Type
Participatory, story-based monitoring and evaluation technique
Family
Participatory monitoring and evaluation
Font size

What does it do?

The Most Significant Change (MSC) technique is a participatory, story-based approach to monitoring and evaluating development programmes that dispenses with predefined indicators.

Developed by Rick Davies and elaborated with Jess Dart in their widely used 2005 guide, it works by systematically collecting stories of significant change from those closest to a programme and then filtering and selecting the most significant of them through deliberative panels at successive levels of the organisational hierarchy. The result is a structured, dialogical account of what stakeholders themselves judge to be the most important outcomes of an intervention.

The intuition behind the method

Conventional monitoring asks 'did we hit the targets we set in advance?' MSC asks a different question: 'of all the changes you have seen, which one matters most, and why?' Field staff and participants tell short, concrete stories of change; panels of managers and stakeholders then read batches of these stories, choose the one they consider most significant, and document the reasons for their choice. As selected stories travel up the hierarchy, the values and judgements that drive the selection become explicit and debatable. Over time the organisation learns not just what changed but what it collectively considers valuable, capturing unanticipated and hard-to-measure outcomes that indicator-based systems miss.

History

The technique originated in the mid-1990s with Rick Davies's doctoral work on monitoring a Christian Commission for Development in Bangladesh programme, where he sought a way to monitor an unpredictable, participatory programme without imposing external indicators. Jess Dart adapted and tested it in Australian agricultural and natural-resource contexts, and their 2003 article in the American Journal of Evaluation framed it as a dialogical, story-based evaluation tool. The 2005 guide, co-authored by Davies and Dart and distributed through the mande.co.uk network, codified the steps and spread the approach widely across NGOs and donor agencies as a recognised participatory monitoring and evaluation method.

When to use it

Use MSC for monitoring complex, participatory, or open-ended development programmes where outcomes are diverse, emergent, or hard to specify in advance, and where capturing unanticipated change and stakeholder values matters more than measuring against fixed targets. It complements rather than replaces quantitative indicator systems and is especially useful for empowerment, governance, and capacity-building work. It is poorly suited where precise, comparable, attributable effect sizes are required, where there is no genuine intention to deliberate over and act on the stories, or where staff cannot commit to the recurring rounds of collection, selection, and feedback the technique demands.

Limitations and considerations

  • Does not produce representative or statistically generalisable findings, since selected stories are deliberately the most significant rather than typical.
  • Selection by panels introduces bias toward dramatic, positive, or politically convenient stories unless deliberately counterbalanced.
  • Labour-intensive and dependent on sustained facilitation, recurring panels, and feedback over multiple rounds.
  • Provides weak evidence of attribution, as a story rarely isolates the programme's causal contribution from other influences.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Captures unanticipated and hard-to-measure outcomes that predefined indicators systematically overlook.
  • Makes the values and selection criteria of different organisational levels explicit and open to debate.
  • Builds staff and stakeholder ownership and analytical capacity through participation in selection panels.
  • Requires no specialist measurement skills and produces concrete, communicable narratives useful for reporting and learning.

Applications

  • Monitoring empowerment, governance, and rights-based programmes whose outcomes resist predefined indicators.
  • Capturing unanticipated effects of community development and natural-resource-management interventions.
  • Surfacing diverse stakeholder perspectives in participatory monitoring and evaluation systems.
  • Generating concrete narratives for donor reporting, advocacy, and organisational learning.
  • Complementing quantitative logframe or results-framework monitoring with qualitative depth.

How it works

How it works

1

Stakeholders agree a small number of broad 'domains of change' — deliberately loose categories such as changes in people's livelihoods, in participation, or in the nature of the programme itself — rather than precise indicators. These domains frame the kinds of stories sought without prescribing what counts as success, leaving room for unexpected outcomes to emerge.

2

Field-level staff and programme participants are periodically asked a simple question: looking back over the period, what was the most significant change in a given domain, and why is it significant to you? Each respondent records a short narrative describing who was involved, what happened, and the reason it mattered, so the story carries both the event and the storyteller's judgement of value.

3

The collected stories are read by panels at the next level up — for example field teams, then regional managers, then senior staff or donors. At each level the panel discusses the batch, selects the single most significant story per domain, and documents the criteria behind its choice. This iterative filtering means only the stories judged most significant survive the climb, while the recorded selection criteria reveal the implicit theory of value at each level.

4

The selected stories and the reasons for their selection are fed back to those who supplied them and, where possible, the events described are verified by revisiting the field. Feedback closes the loop, builds shared understanding of what the organisation values, and guards against fabricated or exaggerated accounts, turning the exercise into ongoing organisational learning rather than a one-off data grab.

Common pitfalls

  • Collapsing the loose domains of change into rigid indicators, which defeats the purpose of leaving room for emergent outcomes.
  • Skipping the documentation of selection criteria, losing the most valuable output: the reasoning behind what counts as significant.
  • Treating MSC as a stand-alone evaluation that proves impact, rather than one strand of a broader mixed-methods system.
  • Omitting verification and feedback, which erodes trust and allows exaggerated or fabricated stories to dominate.

Frequently asked questions

How does MSC differ from collecting success stories?

Success stories are usually selected ad hoc for communications and carry no systematic method. MSC is a structured process: stories are collected against agreed domains of change, deliberately selected through panels at successive hierarchy levels, and accompanied by documented reasons for each selection. The discipline lies less in the stories themselves than in the recorded, debatable judgements about why one change is more significant than another, which makes the organisation's values explicit and the process auditable.

Can MSC measure programme impact or attribution?

Not on its own. MSC is strong at revealing what changed and what stakeholders value, but a single narrative rarely isolates the programme's causal contribution from other factors. It is best used alongside indicator-based monitoring and, where attribution matters, theory-based or experimental impact evaluation. MSC's contribution is depth, plausibility, and unanticipated outcomes, not statistically defensible effect sizes.

Why are the domains of change kept deliberately loose?

Tightly defined domains would function like indicators and pre-judge what counts as success, suppressing the unexpected changes MSC is designed to surface. Loose domains — such as 'changes in people's lives' — give storytellers latitude to report what they genuinely find significant, while still providing enough structure to sort and compare stories during selection.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Davies, R., & Dart, J. (2005). The 'Most Significant Change' (MSC) Technique: A Guide to Its Use. CARE International, Oxfam, et al.

    Open publication reference
    Copied.
  2. Dart, J., & Davies, R. (2003). A Dialogical, Story-Based Evaluation Tool: The Most Significant Change Technique. American Journal of Evaluation, 24(2), 137-155.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.