Skip to content
Back to search results

Lysholm Knee Scale

Introduced by
Jörg Lysholm, Johan Gillquist
Year
1982
Type
Patient self-report and functional testing
Family
knee-specific outcome
Font size

What does it do?

The Lysholm Knee Scoring Scale is an 8-item knee outcome instrument developed by Swedish orthopedic surgeons Lysholm and Gillquist in 1982 to evaluate knee ligament surgery results.

Published in the American Journal of Sports Medicine, the Lysholm Scale was among the first validated knee outcome measures and remains widely used in clinical practice and orthopedic research, particularly in studies of anterior cruciate ligament injuries and knee ligament reconstruction.

The intuition behind the method

The Lysholm Scale represents a seminal contribution to knee outcome measurement, predating modern comprehensive scales like the IKDC by two decades. Despite its age, the Lysholm remains valuable for its simplicity, brevity, and strong validation in ACL injury and ligament surgery populations. The instrument asks patients directly about pain, swelling, instability, and functional limitations (walking, stairs, squatting, running), synthesizing these into a 0–100 score where higher values indicate better knee function. Lysholm thresholds (poor <65, fair 65–83, good 84–90, excellent 91–100) are clinically intuitive and widely recognized in orthopedic literature.

History

The Lysholm Knee Scale was developed by Swedish orthopedic surgeons Jörg Lysholm and Johan Gillquist at the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm, Sweden, to standardize knee ligament surgery outcome assessment. Published in 1982, it was among the first validated knee outcome measures in the orthopedic literature and became the de facto standard in ACL research for decades. While newer, more comprehensive scales (IKDC, KOOS) have since been developed, the Lysholm remains widely used, particularly in older literature and in clinicians familiar with the scale. It has been translated into >30 languages and remains a reference standard for historical comparison in knee outcome research.

When to use it

The Lysholm Scale is indicated for patients with knee ligament injuries (particularly ACL tears) and post-reconstruction rehabilitation. It is especially valuable in settings with longitudinal ACL cohort data, as many published studies from the 1980s–2010s used Lysholm as their outcome measure, allowing historical comparisons. The Lysholm is less comprehensive than modern scales like the IKDC (which has 18 items and stronger psychometric data), but its brevity is advantageous in high-volume clinics or when rapid assessment is needed. Use Lysholm when historical continuity with previous literature is important, or when time constraints limit use of longer scales. For new studies without historical anchors, consider IKDC as the preferred alternative.

Limitations and considerations

  • Less comprehensive than modern scales; 8 items is brief but may miss nuances captured by IKDC's 18 items (e.g., activity-specific function, sport readiness differentiation).
  • Primarily validated in ACL injury populations; validity in other knee pathologies (meniscal injury, osteoarthritis, patellar pain) is less robust than disease-specific scales.
  • Ordinal response options (e.g., 'limp: slight vs. moderate') are subjective and may be interpreted differently by patients; no visual anchors or examples provided.
  • Scoring can be error-prone if performed manually; precise point values for each response option must be followed; electronic scoring is strongly recommended.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Excellent test–retest reliability (ICC 0.84–0.94) and internal consistency; well-validated in ACL injury and knee ligament populations over four decades of clinical use.
  • Brief (8 items) and rapid administration (5–10 minutes); straightforward scoring yields 0–100 scale with clinically intuitive thresholds (poor/fair/good/excellent).
  • Highly responsive to knee ligament surgery outcomes; sensitive to improvements from ACL reconstruction and physical rehabilitation; widely used in orthopedic literature, enabling historical comparison and meta-analysis.
  • No cost, no copyright restrictions, freely available in multiple languages; easily implementable in paper or electronic format.

Applications

  • Post-ACL reconstruction outcomes: tracking functional recovery at 3, 6, 12 months post-op; scores >80 often used as a threshold for return-to-sport clearance in competitive athletes.
  • Knee ligament injury trials: used as a primary or secondary outcome in randomized controlled trials comparing ACL surgical techniques, graft types, or rehabilitation protocols; enables meta-analysis with historical ACL cohorts.
  • Longitudinal cohort studies: repeated Lysholm administration over years to track long-term knee function following ACL injury or reconstruction; sensitive to development of osteoarthritis or re-injury.
  • Clinical outcomes registries: integrated into orthopedic surgery registries and electronic health records for standardized outcome reporting and benchmarking across institutions.

How it works

How it works

1

The Lysholm Scale consists of 8 items: (1) Limp (5 options: none, slight, moderate, severe, unable to walk); (2) Support/Crutches (5 options: none, cane needed, one crutch, two crutches, unable to walk); (3) Locking (4 options: no locking or catching, catching without locking, locking occasionally, locking frequently); (4) Instability (5 options: never, occasional during sports, occasional during normal activities, frequent during normal activities, constant); (5) Pain (6 options: none, inconstant, slight during normal activities, marked during normal activities, severe during normal activities, constant); (6) Swelling (4 options: none, slight after exceptional activities, moderate after exceptional activities, moderate during normal activities); (7) Stair climbing (4 options: no problems, slight problems, one step at a time, unable); (8) Squatting (4 options: no problems, slight problems, moderate problems, unable). The patient completes the form independently in 5–10 minutes, selecting the single best response for each item. No equipment or clinician involvement is needed beyond form distribution.

2

Each item is assigned points based on the response selected (typically ranging 0–10 or 0–25 per item, depending on the number of options). Raw points are summed across all 8 items, yielding a raw total score. This raw score is converted to a 0–100 scale using the formula: (raw total / maximum possible raw score) × 100. The exact point values for each option are standardized in the original 1982 publication. Total Lysholm Score ranges 0–100. Higher scores = better knee function. Some items are reverse-scored (e.g., 'constant instability' = 0 points; 'never' = 25 points).

3

Lysholm Score interpretation: 91–100 = excellent knee function (minimal symptoms, return to normal activities and sport); 84–90 = good (mild symptoms, return to sport possible); 65–83 = fair (moderate symptoms, some functional limitations, return to sport questionable); <65 = poor (significant symptoms and functional limitations). In ACL reconstruction literature, a score >80 is often used as a threshold for return-to-sport clearance, though this depends on the patient's baseline and specific sport demands. Change of 5–10 points is clinically meaningful; improvement >15 points indicates substantial functional recovery. Note: Lysholm scores may vary slightly based on scoring variant (original vs. modified versions); specify the version used.

Common pitfalls

  • Using an outdated or non-standardized scoring variant; multiple versions of the Lysholm exist (original 1982, modified versions); always specify which version and cite the exact scoring algorithm used.
  • Assuming a Lysholm score of 80 is 'acceptable' without considering the patient's baseline and functional goals; a sedentary elderly patient may be satisfied with 70, while a competitive athlete requires >90.
  • Administering Lysholm in the immediate post-op period (first 2 weeks); scores will be artificially low (often <30) due to acute swelling and pain. Baseline at 4–6 weeks post-op is standard.
  • Comparing Lysholm scores across studies without verifying identical scoring methods; small variations in point assignment can cause score differences of 5–10 points, affecting interpretation.

Frequently asked questions

How does the Lysholm Scale differ from the newer IKDC Subjective Knee Form?

Lysholm has 8 items and a simpler structure; IKDC has 18 items and is more comprehensive. IKDC is more responsive to change and has stronger modern validation data. Lysholm is preferred for historical continuity (older literature used Lysholm) or when time is limited. IKDC is preferred for new research without historical anchors. Both are valid; choose based on your study's needs.

What is the minimal clinically important change (MCID) on the Lysholm Scale?

Published MCID data are limited; an estimated change of 5–10 points is considered clinically meaningful, with >15 points indicating substantial improvement. Context matters: in an athlete post-ACL surgery, improvement from 45 to 75 (+30) is clearly meaningful; improvement from 85 to 90 (+5) in a patient already doing well may be within measurement error.

Should I use Lysholm or IKDC for my new ACL reconstruction study?

For a new study without historical data to compare, use IKDC; it is the modern standard with better validation and responsiveness. Use Lysholm only if you need to compare with historical Lysholm data (e.g., matching a 1995 cohort) or if time/resource constraints are severe. If possible, administer both IKDC and Lysholm to allow future researchers to map your data to other studies.

Can I use Lysholm for non-ACL knee conditions like meniscal injury or osteoarthritis?

Lysholm is primarily validated in ACL populations and is less robust in other knee pathologies. For meniscal injury or OA, consider condition-specific scales (e.g., FAOS for foot/ankle, or KOOS for knee OA, which is similar to IKDC structure). If Lysholm is used, validate its appropriateness for your specific knee condition and report limitations.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Lysholm J, Gillquist J. Evaluation of knee ligament surgery results with special emphasis on use of a scoring scale. Am J Sports Med. 1982;10(3):150-154.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.