Skip to content
Back to search results

EQUATOR Network: Standards for Reporting Health Research

Introduced by
EQUATOR Network (founded 2006); hosted by University of Oxford
Year
2006
Type
Standard
Family
reporting-standard
Font size

What does it do?

EQUATOR (Enhancing QUAlity and Transparency Of health Research) is a global network that develops, endorses, and promotes reporting guidelines for health and life sciences research.

Founded in 2006 and hosted by the University of Oxford, EQUATOR maintains a library of 500+ guidelines covering study designs (randomized trials, observational studies, systematic reviews, case reports, qualitative research, etc.). Major guidelines include CONSORT (randomized controlled trials), STROBE (observational studies), PRISMA (systematic reviews and meta-analyses), and CARE (case reports). These guidelines specify which items must be reported and how to report them, reducing inconsistency and enabling readers to assess study validity. Many journals now require adherence to relevant EQUATOR guidelines.

The intuition behind the method

Inconsistent reporting of study methods and results makes it difficult for readers to evaluate research quality and impossible to compare findings across studies. Before EQUATOR guidelines, researchers reported studies idiosyncratically: some disclosed randomization details, others did not; some reported all outcomes, others reported only significant ones. This inconsistency hid methodological flaws and enabled selective reporting. EQUATOR guidelines (CONSORT for trials, STROBE for observational studies, PRISMA for reviews) standardize reporting. For example, CONSORT requires authors to report allocation concealment method, blinding status, and the number of dropouts with reasons—items often omitted in non-CONSORT era papers, concealing bias. Adherence to guidelines improves transparency, enabling readers and systematic reviewers to assess validity. The guidelines are evidence-based: items are selected because they predict bias risk or enable synthesis.

History

EQUATOR was founded in 2006 by an international consortium of researchers, journal editors, and methodologists led by David Moher (University of Ottawa) and Douglas Altman (University of Oxford). The network was inspired by earlier work on reporting standards, particularly CONSORT (Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials), published in 1996 to improve reporting of randomized controlled trials. CONSORT was successful: journals adopting it showed improved reporting quality. EQUATOR formalized the process and expanded to cover all major study designs: STROBE (2007, observational studies), PRISMA (2009, systematic reviews, updated 2020), CARE (2013, case reports), and many others. In 2015, the British Medical Journal published Moher et al.'s influential paper 'Guidelines for Reporting Health Research: A User's Manual,' which accelerated adoption. Today, EQUATOR is endorsed by major journals (Lancet, JAMA, BMJ, etc.), funders (NIH, Wellcome Trust), and registration platforms (ClinicalTrials.gov). The network maintains an online resource (equator-network.org) with downloadable checklists and training materials.

When to use it

Use EQUATOR guidelines for all primary research (trials, observational studies, qualitative research, case reports) and for systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Major journals in medicine, nursing, public health, psychology, and allied health now endorse EQUATOR guidelines. Check your target journal's author guidelines; most will reference the relevant guideline. If guidelines are not explicitly required, using them demonstrates rigor and improves chances of acceptance. Preprints and open-access platforms increasingly request EQUATOR compliance. International registries for trials (ClinicalTrials.gov) and systematic reviews (PROSPERO) also reference EQUATOR guidelines.

Limitations and considerations

  • Guideline proliferation: with 500+ guidelines, choosing the correct one is sometimes difficult; some guidelines are better established than others.
  • Space constraints: comprehensive reporting of all guideline items may exceed journal word limits; supplementary materials are then required.
  • Complexity: guidelines require knowledge of methodological terminology (e.g., 'allocation concealment,' 'intention-to-treat analysis'); authors must educate themselves.
  • Cultural variation: some guidelines are more widely adopted in certain regions (CONSORT is universal; some newer guidelines are less established).
  • Enforcement: many journals list EQUATOR guidelines but do not enforce compliance; authors may submit non-compliant manuscripts without penalty.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Standardization: guidelines ensure consistent reporting across journals and studies, enabling comparison and synthesis.
  • Transparency: guidelines mandate reporting of methodological details that reveal bias risk (e.g., allocation concealment, reasons for dropouts).
  • Improves quality: studies reporting to guidelines show lower bias; authors must address key methodological items, improving rigor.
  • Facilitates systematic reviews: consistent reporting across primary studies enables systematic reviewers to extract data and assess quality using a standard framework.
  • Supports evidence synthesis: adherence to guidelines enables meta-analyses; non-adherent papers are often excluded due to missing data.

Applications

  • Publishing a randomized trial: use CONSORT checklist (~27 items); include CONSORT flow diagram showing participant flow through enrollment, allocation, follow-up, and analysis phases.
  • Publishing an observational study (cohort, case-control, cross-sectional): use STROBE checklist (~22 items) to ensure transparent reporting of design, participants, outcomes, and analysis.
  • Publishing a systematic review or meta-analysis: use PRISMA checklist (~27 items); include PRISMA flowchart showing study selection process; use PRISMA extension for network meta-analysis if applicable.
  • Publishing a case report: use CARE checklist (~13 items) to report patient characteristics, timeline, diagnostics, interventions, and outcomes consistently.

How it works

How it works

1

To use EQUATOR guidelines: (1) Identify your study design (randomized trial, cohort study, case-control, systematic review, case report, qualitative study, etc.). (2) Go to equator-network.org and search for the guideline matching your design. Download the checklist and/or flowchart. (3) The guideline will list items that must be reported (e.g., 'Report the process used to generate the random allocation sequence'). (4) For each item, ensure your manuscript addresses it. Organize your reporting according to IMRaD structure, but include all guideline items. (5) Complete the checklist alongside guideline items; tick off each item as it is reported. (6) Submit the completed checklist with your manuscript per journal instructions. Examples: CONSORT checklist for trials (~27 items), STROBE checklist for observational studies (~22 items), PRISMA checklist for systematic reviews (~27 items), CARE checklist for case reports (~13 items). Use the flowchart (e.g., CONSORT flow diagram showing participant flow through trial phases) to visually communicate study design.

2

Quality EQUATOR-compliant manuscripts meet these criteria: (1) Completeness: all guideline items are reported in the manuscript (either in main text or supplementary materials). (2) Accuracy: reported items match the methods actually used (no inconsistencies between what is claimed and what was done). (3) Clarity: items are reported clearly and transparently, enabling readers to assess bias risk. (4) Appropriate guideline: the correct guideline for the study design is used (CONSORT for RCTs, STROBE for cohorts, etc.). (5) Flowchart included: when applicable (trials, reviews), the guideline's flowchart is presented (CONSORT flow diagram, PRISMA FLOW). (6) Completeness of disclosure: important methodological details are reported, not hidden in supplementary materials or omitted. Peer reviewers and editors verify compliance by checking the guideline checklist against the manuscript.

3

Journals that endorse EQUATOR guidelines may require submission of the completed checklist. Some journals desk-reject manuscripts that do not report guideline items; others provide the checklist to reviewers for evaluation. Adherence to guidelines improves likelihood of acceptance because editors and reviewers trust that key items have been addressed. After publication, readers can quickly assess study validity by checking whether guideline items are reported (e.g., was allocation truly concealed in a trial?). Systematic reviewers assessing study quality use guideline items as the framework for risk-of-bias assessment. Non-adherence to guidelines signals lower methodological quality or transparency, damaging credibility.

Common pitfalls

  • Using the wrong guideline: applying CONSORT (for trials) to an observational cohort study results in reporting of inappropriate items.
  • Incomplete reporting: checking off checklist items in the supplementary checklist but failing to report them in the manuscript itself.
  • Hidden reporting: mentioning guideline items briefly or in supplementary materials while key details are absent from the main text.
  • Misunderstanding items: misinterpreting what a guideline item requires (e.g., thinking 'randomization' means reporting a random number generator, not the full allocation sequence generation and concealment method).
  • Ignoring flowcharts: omitting CONSORT flow diagrams (trials) or PRISMA FLOW diagrams (reviews) when they are central to communicating study design.

Frequently asked questions

Where do I find the correct guideline for my study?

Visit equator-network.org and use the 'Search Guidelines' tool. Enter your study type (e.g., 'randomized controlled trial,' 'observational cohort study') and the site will list relevant guidelines. Most guidelines have been adapted for specific study types (e.g., CONSORT has extensions for cluster trials, non-pharmacological interventions, herbal interventions). Download the full guideline (includes explanation and examples) and the checklist.

Is submitting the completed checklist mandatory?

Depends on the journal. Some journals require the completed checklist (check author guidelines). Others recommend it but do not require it. Best practice: always complete the checklist and submit it with your manuscript or include it as a supplementary file. Some journals include the checklist in the peer review process; reviewers will note any missing items.

Can I use one guideline for studies with mixed designs (e.g., a trial with embedded qualitative component)?

Use the primary guideline for your main design, plus supplementary guidelines for secondary components. For example, a trial with qualitative interviews would use CONSORT + COREQ (Consolidated criteria for Reporting Qualitative research). Check EQUATOR for extensions and combinations.

What if my study does not fit neatly into a guideline category?

EQUATOR has guidelines for many designs: RCTs, observational studies, qualitative research, diagnostic accuracy, prognostic models, systematic reviews, case reports, animal studies, network meta-analyses, implementation science, etc. If your design is not listed, consult the EQUATOR website or contact EQUATOR directly. Use the guideline for your primary design and adapt as needed.

Can I use EQUATOR guidelines for a preprint or non-journal publication?

Yes. Guidelines are useful for any research communication: preprints (arXiv, bioRxiv, medRxiv), open-access repositories, institutional repositories, and dissertations. Adherence to guidelines increases clarity and credibility regardless of publication venue.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Moher, D., Altman, D. G., Schulz, K. F., Simera, I., & Wager, E. (2012). Guidelines for reporting health research: A user's manual. British Medical Journal, 345, e5997.

    Open publication reference
    Copied.
  2. EQUATOR Network (2023). Enhancing the QUAlity and Transparency Of health Research. Retrieved from https://www.equator-network.org/

    Open publication reference
    Copied.
  3. Page, M. J., McKenzie, J. E., Bossuyt, P. M., et al. (2021). The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. British Medical Journal, 372, n71.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.