Skip to content
Back to search results

Co-Production Assessment

Introduced by
Elinor Ostrom
Year
1996
Type
Service-relationship assessment framework
Family
Public-service production studies
Font size

What does it do?

Co-production assessment analyses how public services are produced jointly by professional providers and the citizens, clients or communities who use them, rather than delivered to passive recipients.

The concept was developed by Elinor Ostrom and colleagues and sharpened in her 1996 article, which argued that the inputs of "regular producers" such as teachers, police or doctors and those of citizen "co-producers" are often complementary, so that neither can produce the service well alone. The framework assesses what citizens contribute, how their inputs combine with professional inputs, and the conditions under which this combination creates synergy. Its purpose is to identify and strengthen the joint production at the heart of many public services.

The intuition behind the method

A teacher cannot educate a child who will not study, a doctor cannot cure a patient who ignores treatment, and police cannot keep order without residents who report crime and watch out for neighbours. In each case the professional supplies expertise and the citizen supplies effort, information or behaviour, and the service only materialises when the two inputs combine. Ostrom called this co-production: the output is literally produced by both sides together. Co-production assessment treats the citizen not as a customer at the end of a delivery pipe but as a partner on the production line, and asks how to make that partnership work — because when citizen inputs dry up, no amount of professional effort can compensate.

History

Co-production was developed in the 1970s and 1980s by Elinor Ostrom and colleagues at the Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis at Indiana University, originally through studies of policing in Chicago that showed citizen cooperation was essential to public safety. Ostrom, who later won the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences for her work on governing the commons, articulated the development implications in her 1996 article on coproduction, synergy and development. The concept was revived in the 2000s and 2010s by scholars such as John Alford, Tony Bovaird, Elke Loeffler and Victor Pestoff, who extended it to a wide range of public services and to debates on public-service co-creation.

When to use it

Use co-production assessment when a service's outcomes depend substantially on what users or communities do, not just on what professionals deliver, and you want to understand and strengthen that joint contribution. It suits education, health, public safety, environmental management, social care and community development, and it is valuable when professional inputs alone are failing to produce results. The framework assumes that citizen and professional inputs are at least partly complementary, that citizens are willing and able to contribute under the right conditions, and that the service genuinely admits joint production. It is less appropriate for purely professional or technical services where citizens cannot meaningfully contribute, and it must be applied carefully to avoid celebrating burden-shifting as empowerment. It complements collaborative-governance and administrative-burden analyses by focusing on the production relationship itself.

Limitations and considerations

  • Citizen inputs are heterogeneous and often hard to measure, complicating quantitative assessment of their contribution.
  • Distinguishing genuine synergy from simple input substitution requires careful analysis that data may not always support.
  • The framework can be misused to legitimise shifting costs and labour onto citizens under the banner of participation.
  • Co-production depends on citizen willingness and capacity, which vary by group, risking deepened inequality if not addressed.

Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.

Strengths

  • Reconceives citizens as essential producers rather than passive recipients, revealing dependencies that conventional service analysis misses.
  • The complementarity-and-synergy logic explains how citizen and professional inputs together can outperform either alone.
  • Identifies actionable enabling conditions — institutions, incentives and trust — that managers can strengthen to mobilise citizen inputs.
  • Applies across diverse services from policing to health to education, offering a unifying account of joint production.

Applications

  • Analysing community policing and neighbourhood-watch arrangements where resident information and vigilance co-produce public safety.
  • Assessing chronic-disease management and public-health programs that depend on patient self-care and behaviour change.
  • Studying education outcomes as the joint product of teacher instruction and student and parental effort.
  • Evaluating environmental and natural-resource management where users co-produce monitoring and stewardship.
  • Examining social-care and community-development programs that mobilise volunteers and service users as producers.

How it works

How it works

1

The analyst specifies the service in question and identifies the regular producers — the public employees and professionals whose job it is to deliver it. This establishes the conventional production side and the boundary of the service, clarifying exactly what output is being created. Defining the service precisely matters because the scope for co-production varies enormously: some services are largely professional, while others, such as education, health or safety, are intrinsically co-produced.

2

The analyst documents the contributions that citizens, clients or communities make to producing the service: the effort of a patient following a treatment regimen, the information a resident gives the police, the parental support behind a child's learning, the volunteering that sustains a community program. These inputs are treated as genuine factors of production, not as optional extras. Mapping them reveals how much of the service actually depends on user behaviour and where citizen effort is essential.

3

The analyst examines how citizen and professional inputs combine, distinguishing cases where they are complementary — so that more of one raises the productivity of the other — from cases where they merely substitute. Ostrom's key insight is that co-production can generate synergy, producing more or better service than the sum of inputs delivered separately. The assessment looks for this multiplicative complementarity and for the technical features of the service that make it possible.

4

The analyst identifies the conditions that enable or undermine co-production: legal and organisational arrangements that invite citizen contribution, incentives and trust between citizens and officials, the absence of barriers that crowd out citizen effort, and the capacity of communities to organise. Ostrom stressed that supportive institutional design and a credible, accountable government are needed for citizens to invest their inputs. Where these conditions are missing, co-production stalls and citizens disengage.

5

Finally, the analyst evaluates what the co-production arrangement produces in terms of service quantity, quality, cost and broader effects such as community capacity and trust. Outcomes are interpreted in light of the complementarity and enabling conditions, distinguishing genuine synergistic co-production from token participation or from burden-shifting that simply offloads work onto citizens. This step supports recommendations to redesign roles, incentives and institutions to strengthen productive joint production.

Common pitfalls

  • Rebranding austerity-driven offloading of work onto users as empowering co-production while ignoring the burden it imposes.
  • Assuming all citizens can contribute equally and so designing arrangements that advantage the already-resourced and widen inequality.
  • Treating any citizen participation as co-production, even where inputs merely substitute for rather than complement professional effort.
  • Neglecting the enabling conditions of trust and accountable institutions, so citizen inputs are invited but never materialise.

Frequently asked questions

What exactly counts as co-production?

Co-production occurs when the inputs of regular producers — public professionals — and the inputs of citizens or clients combine to produce a public service, such that the service depends on both. A patient adhering to treatment, a resident reporting crime, or a student studying are co-producing health, safety and education respectively. The defining feature is that citizen effort is a genuine factor of production, not merely consultation or feedback, which distinguishes co-production from participation or customer involvement.

Why does Ostrom emphasise complementarity and synergy?

Because the power of co-production lies in inputs that reinforce each other rather than simply adding up. When citizen and professional inputs are complementary, more of one raises the productivity of the other, so coordinated joint effort can yield more service than the same resources used separately — the synergy Ostrom highlighted. If the inputs merely substitute, there is little special gain. Identifying genuine complementarity is therefore central to judging whether co-production is worth designing for.

Isn't co-production just a way to cut costs by making citizens do the work?

It can be misused that way, and critics warn against rebranding cost-shifting and austerity as empowerment. Genuine co-production is about mobilising complementary citizen inputs to produce better outcomes under enabling conditions of trust and support, not about offloading professional responsibilities onto users. A careful assessment distinguishes synergistic co-production that adds value from burden-shifting that simply moves work, and it attends to whether all citizens can contribute or only the already-advantaged.

Related methods

Sources

  1. Ostrom, E. (1996). Crossing the Great Divide: Coproduction, Synergy, and Development. World Development, 24(6), 1073–1087.

    Open DOI reference
    Copied.