Alliance Network Analysis
- Introduced by
- Skyler Cranmer, Bruce Desmarais & Elizabeth Menninga
- Year
- 2012
- Type
- Network analysis and inferential network modeling of interstate alliances
- Family
- Network & graph analysis for IR
What does it do?
Alliance network analysis studies international alliances as a graph of states linked by formal security commitments, and models how that network forms and evolves.
Rather than treating each alliance dyad as independent, it uses network science and inferential models such as the exponential random graph model (ERGM) — applied to alliance data by Cranmer, Desmarais, and Menninga (2012) — to capture the complex dependencies, such as a state's tendency to ally with its allies' allies, that ordinary dyadic regression assumes away.
The intuition behind the method
Alliances are not isolated handshakes between pairs of states; they form a web in which my ally's ally is often my ally too, hubs like great powers anchor dense clusters, and bridging states connect otherwise separate blocs. If you analyze each alliance pair as if it were independent, you miss exactly these structural forces — and you violate the statistical independence that dyadic regression requires. Alliance network analysis instead models the whole web at once: it measures structural features like clustering and centrality, and it asks whether observed alliances are more transitive, more centralized, or more reciprocal than chance, while still allowing state and dyad attributes to matter.
History
Network thinking has long shadowed alliance research — balance-of-power and bloc imagery are inherently relational — but rigorous inferential network modeling arrived with the spread of exponential random graph models in the 2000s. Cranmer, Desmarais, and Menninga's 2012 article in Conflict Management and Peace Science brought ERGMs to the alliance network, showing that complex dependencies like transitivity must be modeled to understand alliance formation. The approach is part of a broader turn toward network analysis across international relations, including trade, conflict, and intergovernmental organizations.
When to use it
Use alliance network analysis when alliance ties are interdependent and you want to explain the structure of the alliance system or test whether endogenous network processes — transitivity, preferential attachment, brokerage — shape who allies with whom, beyond state and dyad attributes. It is appropriate whenever ignoring network dependence would bias inference, which is the norm for relational IR data. It is less necessary when ties are genuinely independent, when the question is purely about exogenous dyadic predictors, or when the network is too small or too dense for stable ERGM estimation, where descriptive analysis or simpler models suffice.
Limitations and considerations
- ERGM estimation via MCMC can suffer model degeneracy, where the fitted model places nearly all probability on empty or complete graphs.
- Results are sensitive to which network statistics are specified; omitting a relevant dependence term biases the others.
- Large state systems and long time spans strain computation and may require temporal ERGM or separable temporal models.
- Alliance coding choices (defense pacts vs. ententes, formal vs. informal) materially change the network and thus the conclusions.
Source conditions do not replace independent scientific review or validation by an analysis engine.
Strengths
- Models network dependence explicitly, correcting the independence violation that biases ordinary dyadic regression on relational data.
- Tests substantive structural hypotheses — transitivity, centralization, brokerage — directly as model parameters.
- Integrates endogenous network effects with exogenous nodal and dyadic covariates in a single coherent model.
- Connects IR to a mature toolkit of network science and inferential network modeling, including temporal and valued extensions.
Applications
- Explaining alliance formation as a function of both state attributes and endogenous network structure.
- Identifying structurally pivotal states (hubs and brokers) in the international security network.
- Detecting blocs and polarization in the alliance system and tracking their change over time.
- Studying the co-evolution of the alliance network with conflict and trade networks.
- Forecasting alliance ties and assessing network resilience to the removal of key states.
How it works
How it works
States are represented as nodes V and alliance commitments as edges E, yielding a (typically undirected) graph in which the adjacency entry e_ij is one when states i and j share a formal alliance. Because alliances change, the graph is usually a sequence of yearly snapshots, drawn from sources such as the Correlates of War formal alliance data.
Formula
G = (V, E),\quad V=\text{states},\; e_{ij}=1 \text{ if } i,j \text{ allied}Descriptive network statistics summarize structure: degree (how many allies a state has), centrality measures (which states are structurally pivotal), density, clustering or transitivity (the prevalence of closed triangles), and community detection (the blocs into which the system divides). These quantify intuitions about alliance hubs, blocs, and bridges.
Formula
C_i = \sum_{j} a_{ij},\quad \text{(degree, centrality, community structure)}An exponential random graph model expresses the probability of the entire observed network y as proportional to the exponential of a weighted sum of network statistics g — counts of edges, triangles, shared partners, and covariate effects X such as joint democracy or capability. The θ parameters weight how much each structural feature drives the network; κ is the normalizing constant over all possible graphs.
Formula
\Pr(Y=y) = \frac{\exp\!\big(\boldsymbol{\theta}'\mathbf{g}(y,X)\big)}{\kappa(\boldsymbol{\theta})}Parameters θ are estimated by maximum likelihood, in practice via Markov chain Monte Carlo because κ is intractable. The conditional (change-statistic) form shows the model as a logit for each tie given the rest of the network: a positive triangle parameter means an alliance is more likely when it would close a triangle, formalizing the 'ally of my ally' tendency net of node and dyad attributes.
Formula
\hat{\boldsymbol{\theta}} = \arg\max \; \ell(\boldsymbol{\theta}\mid y),\quad \text{logit}\,\Pr(Y_{ij}=1\mid y_{-ij}) = \boldsymbol{\theta}'\delta_{ij}\mathbf{g}(y)Common pitfalls
- Fitting an ERGM with triangle terms that induce degeneracy instead of using curved/geometrically weighted statistics (GWESP) designed to avoid it.
- Analyzing a temporal alliance network with a cross-sectional ERGM, ignoring the persistence of ties across years.
- Interpreting centrality descriptively as influence without a model that separates structure from node attributes.
- Comparing networks built from different alliance definitions or COW versions as if they measured the same system.
Frequently asked questions
Why not just use logistic regression on alliance dyads?
Because alliance ties are not independent: whether states i and j ally depends on their other ties (their shared partners, their positions as hubs or brokers). Ordinary logit on dyads assumes independence, which alliance data violate, biasing standard errors and missing exactly the structural processes of interest. ERGMs generalize logit to model the whole network, with the conditional form reducing to a logit for each tie given the rest of the graph.
What is model degeneracy in ERGMs and how is it handled?
Degeneracy occurs when a fitted ERGM concentrates almost all probability on degenerate graphs (empty or complete), so the model cannot reproduce a realistic network. It commonly arises with raw triangle counts. The standard remedy is to use geometrically weighted statistics — GWESP for transitivity, GWDEGREE for the degree distribution — which dampen the explosive feedback and make estimation stable.
How are changing alliances over time handled?
With temporal extensions. The temporal ERGM (TERGM) and the separable temporal ERGM (STERGM) model how the network at one time depends on its previous state, separating the formation and dissolution of ties. These let researchers study alliance persistence and change rather than treating each year as an independent snapshot.
Related methods
Sources
Cranmer, S. J., Desmarais, B. A., & Menninga, E. J. (2012). Complex dependencies in the alliance network. Conflict Management and Peace Science, 29(3), 279–313.
Open DOI referenceCopied.