Skip to content

Compare methods

Compare source explanations, strengths, limitations and references for up to four methods.

7 results
Criterion Instrumental Neutron Activation Analysis Ceramic Petrography Strontium Provenance
Overview
  • Instrumental neutron activation analysis (INAA) measures trace element concentrations in archaeological artifacts by bombarding samples with neutrons and analyzing the resulting gamma-ray emissions. Developed as a systematic archaeological method by Michael Glascock and colleagues, INAA provides chemical fingerprints of ceramics, obsidian, and other materials that reveal sourcing and provenance. The method is non-destructive, highly sensitive, and capable of detecting 30+ elements simultaneously.
  • Ceramic petrography analyzes pottery through microscopic examination of thin sections cut from pottery sherds. This method determines clay sources, identifies non-plastic inclusions (temper), and reconstructs pottery production technology. Pioneered by Peter Stimmung and others, ceramic petrography reveals whether pottery was made locally or imported, and whether specific production groups or workshops created vessels with distinctive raw material recipes.
  • Strontium isotope provenance analysis uses the ratios of strontium-87 to strontium-86 in human skeletal remains to determine geographic origin and track human mobility and migration. Developed by Jonathan Ericson in the 1980s, this method exploits the fact that strontium isotope ratios in the environment vary geographically based on underlying geology. When individuals consume food and water from a specific region, they incorporate that region's characteristic strontium isotope signature into their bones and teeth, creating a geochemical fingerprint of their residence.
Use and interpretation
  • Apply INAA when precise chemical sourcing of artifacts is required. Particularly valuable for pottery and obsidian. Works well combined with petrographic analysis. Most effective in multisite regional studies tracking ceramic trade. Requires access to nuclear reactor facilities.
  • Apply ceramic petrography when studying pottery production, sourcing, and exchange. Particularly valuable for distinguishing local from imported pottery in multisite regional studies. Effective for identifying workshop production groups and tracing trade networks. Works well combined with chemical analysis (ICP-MS, INAA) for robust sourcing conclusions.
  • Apply strontium isotope analysis when studying human mobility, migration patterns, or residential histories in archaeological populations. Most valuable in regions with geologically distinct areas (volcanic highlands versus coastal lowlands, for example) that produce distinguishable isotopic baselines. Works well for studying trade patterns, marriage exchanges, and population movement. Best applied to well-preserved bone or tooth enamel. Most reliable when multiple individuals are analyzed, allowing assessment of population-level patterns.
Strengths
  • Non-destructive measurement of artifact composition
  • Measures 30+ elements simultaneously with high precision
  • Provides objective, quantitative data allowing statistical comparison
  • Creates chemical fingerprints diagnostic of specific sources
  • Applicable to diverse artifact types (ceramics, obsidian, metals)
  • Non-destructive observation of sample microstructure using standard petrographic techniques
  • Identifies both natural and intentional temper, revealing production technology
  • Cost-effective compared to chemical analysis
  • Can identify distinctive clay and temper combinations diagnostic of specific regions or workshops
  • Provides information about clay sourcing and subsistence practices
  • Provides direct geochemical evidence of childhood residence and geographic origin
  • Can identify first-generation migrants versus locally-born individuals in skeletal populations
  • Particularly effective in geologically heterogeneous regions with distinct isotopic signatures
  • Works well for studying marriage patterns and kinship residence in prehistoric societies
  • Tooth enamel is highly resistant to post-depositional alteration, providing reliable childhood residence information
Limitations
  • Requires nuclear reactor access, limiting availability
  • Expensive and time-consuming analysis
  • Requires adequate reference samples from known clay sources
  • Chemical composition alone cannot identify specific source without regional baseline data
  • Cannot determine clay origin without understanding geochemistry of source materials
  • Cannot pinpoint specific clay sources without reference samples from regional clay deposits
  • Limited chemical specificity; many regions have similar mineral assemblages
  • Requires experienced petrographer to identify minerals and interpret compositions
  • Post-firing chemical alteration can obscure original composition
  • Best used in combination with other analytical methods (chemistry, typology)
  • Effectiveness depends on sharp geographic variation in baseline strontium isotope ratios; regions with uniform geology yield uninformative results
  • Requires detailed geological and faunal baseline data for proper interpretation; absence of local reference data limits conclusions
  • Cannot distinguish between residence in different regions with similar strontium isotope ratios
  • Does not provide information about length of residence; individuals could have lived in the region for years or decades
  • Limited to skeletal samples with good collagen preservation (for bone-based analysis)
Common pitfalls
  • Assuming chemical similarity equals same source without adequate regional baseline data
  • Ignoring natural variation in elemental composition within a single clay deposit
  • Over-interpreting chemical differences between samples as evidence of different sources when within-group variation is large
  • Failing to collect reference materials from potential clay sources in the region
  • Assuming vessels with identical petrographic composition are from the same source without considering regional clay similarity
  • Over-interpreting minor compositional differences as evidence of distinct production sources
  • Neglecting to sample reference clays and tempers from the region, making source attribution difficult
  • Confusing natural mineral variation in clays with deliberate temper addition
  • Applying published strontium isotope baselines from distant regions without verifying local geological variation
  • Assuming all individuals with non-local isotope ratios are migrants, ignoring the possibility of similar baseline values in different regions
  • Failing to collect and analyze faunal samples from the site and surrounding region to establish meaningful baselines
  • Including bone samples without confirming that diagenetic alteration has not affected isotope values; tooth enamel is more reliable
Introduced by
  • Michael Glascock
  • Peter Stimmung
  • Jonathan Ericson
Year
  • 1992
  • 1976
  • 1985