Skip to content

Compare methods

Compare source explanations, strengths, limitations and references for up to four methods.

7 results
Criterion Fisher-Pry Substitution Model Trend Impact Analysis Emerging Issues Analysis
Overview
  • The Fisher-Pry Substitution Model, introduced by John Fisher and Robert Pry of General Electric in 1971, is a foundational technique for forecasting technological substitution — the process by which a new technology displaces an older one. Its empirical premise, supported by dozens of historical cases from synthetic to natural materials and from one manufacturing process to another, is that the fractional market share captured by the new technology follows a logistic (S-shaped) growth curve. The model's elegance lies in a transformation: when the takeover ratio f/(1-f), the ratio of the new technology's share to the old's, is plotted on a logarithmic scale against time, the substitution traces a straight line. This linearization makes it easy to fit, interpret, and extrapolate substitutions from sparse early data, which is why the Fisher-Pry curve remains a workhorse of technological forecasting.
  • Trend impact analysis (TIA) is a forecasting method that marries quantitative extrapolation with expert judgment about disruptive future events. Developed by Theodore Gordon and colleagues at The Futures Group in the early 1970s and later codified in the Millennium Project's Futures Research Methodology, it starts from a 'surprise-free' baseline produced by fitting and projecting a historical time series. It then asks which unprecedented events — events with no historical analog that ordinary extrapolation cannot anticipate — could deflect that trend, and with what probability, magnitude, and timing. Through Monte Carlo simulation those probabilistic impacts perturb the baseline, yielding not a single line but a probability envelope that shows how the trend might bend if the unexpected occurs.
  • Emerging Issues Analysis (EIA) is a horizon-scanning method, associated with Graham Molitor and the Hawai'i School and codified in the Millennium Project's Futures Research Methodology, for detecting issues at the earliest, weakest-signal stage — long before they register as trends or reach public consciousness. Its organizing idea is that issues, like technologies, follow an S-curve of public attention: they begin in obscure, marginal sources, accelerate as advocates and specialists pick them up, and only later become widely recognized trends and finally mainstream concerns. The strategic value of catching an issue on the flat, early part of that curve is enormous, because that is when there is the most time and the most room to respond. EIA therefore deliberately scans the fringe — specialist literature, activist publications, patents, subcultures, marginal voices — to spot the small clouds on the horizon and position them on the issue lifecycle.
Use and interpretation
  • Use the Fisher-Pry model when one technology, product, material, or process is clearly displacing another in a shared market or function, and you have a time series of the new alternative's fractional share that already shows the substitution underway. It is ideal for forecasting how quickly the takeover will complete and when key share thresholds will be crossed, especially when early data are limited but a logistic mechanism is plausible. It is poorly suited to cases where multiple technologies compete simultaneously (where multi-mode substitution models are needed), where the new technology may not go to completion, where the market itself is the thing growing rather than a share being transferred, or very early before any substitution trend is visible. It also presumes the displaced technology is not itself improving fast enough to reverse the trend.
  • Use trend impact analysis when you have a meaningful historical time series to extrapolate but suspect that unprecedented events could materially bend the trend over the forecast horizon. It is well suited to medium- and long-range forecasting of quantities such as demand, adoption, prices, or capacity where surprise-free projection is a credible starting point yet plainly insufficient, and where domain experts can name disruptive events and judge their probability and impact. TIA is most informative when those events are genuinely novel — lacking historical precedent — and consequential enough to justify the elicitation effort. It is less appropriate when no usable baseline exists, when the variable is dominated by interactions among many events better handled by full cross-impact simulation, or when the relevant future is so qualitatively open that narrative scenario methods are a better fit than a perturbed quantitative trend.
  • Use Emerging Issues Analysis when your aim is genuine early warning — spotting issues, threats, and opportunities while they are still weak signals and before competitors, regulators, or the public have noticed. It is well suited to long-range strategy, policy planning, and foresight programs that need a continuous radar over the fringe and a structured way to judge an issue's maturity and runway. It pairs naturally with scenario and alternative-futures work, supplying the emerging issues that seed divergent images of the future. It is less appropriate when you need quantitative forecasts or probabilities, when the relevant developments are already mainstream trends (where trend-impact methods fit better), or when there is no capacity to sustain ongoing scanning, since EIA's value comes from continuity and from disciplined attention to unconventional sources.
Strengths
  • Reduces S-shaped substitution to a straight line, making fitting, diagnosis, and extrapolation simple and transparent.
  • Requires only a fractional-share time series and yields interpretable parameters: a rate and a midpoint.
  • Delivers a single intuitive summary of speed — the ten-to-ninety-percent takeover time ln(81)/alpha.
  • Validated across many historical technological substitutions, giving it strong empirical pedigree.
  • Combines the rigor of quantitative extrapolation with expert judgment about novel events that data alone cannot reveal.
  • Replaces a single forecast line with a probability envelope, communicating uncertainty and asymmetric risk honestly.
  • Represents impacts as time-shaped functions, capturing onset delays, transient shocks, and permanent level shifts.
  • Is transparent and decomposable, so analysts can trace how each event contributes to deviations from the baseline.
  • Provides maximum lead time by catching issues on the flat early part of the attention S-curve.
  • Deliberately scans unconventional, fringe sources that mainstream forecasting overlooks.
  • Frames issue maturity explicitly via the S-curve and a staged issue lifecycle.
  • Feeds scenario and alternative-futures work with the emerging issues that drive divergence.
Limitations
  • Assumes substitution proceeds to completion, which fails when the incumbent survives or rebounds.
  • Handles only one-to-one substitution; simultaneous multi-technology competition needs richer models.
  • Forecasts are fragile in the early phase when few points constrain the slope and midpoint.
  • The constant-rate logistic shape ignores shocks, policy shifts, and improvements in the old technology.
  • Forecasts depend heavily on subjectively elicited event probabilities, magnitudes, and timings, which are hard to validate.
  • The standard formulation treats unprecedented events as independent, ignoring interactions that cross-impact methods capture.
  • A credible surprise-free baseline is required, so the method falters where history is short or structurally unstable.
  • Choosing the form of the impact functions involves judgment that can materially shape the resulting envelope.
  • Detection is highly judgment-dependent, with a real risk of false positives from noise and false negatives from missed signals.
  • It is qualitative and non-probabilistic, offering no likelihood that an issue will mature.
  • Effectiveness requires sustained, resource-intensive scanning rather than a single exercise.
  • Distinguishing a true emerging issue from a passing fad is inherently uncertain at the earliest stage.
Common pitfalls
  • Extrapolating from too few early data points, where the fitted slope is highly uncertain.
  • Applying the model when the market is expanding rather than a fixed share being transferred.
  • Ignoring that the displaced technology may improve and halt or reverse the substitution.
  • Forcing a single logistic on data that actually reflect several overlapping substitutions.
  • Letting the baseline extrapolation dominate so that implausibly few or weak events are added, collapsing the envelope to the naive trend.
  • Including events that are not truly unprecedented, double-counting effects already embedded in the historical data.
  • Assuming event independence when the listed events plainly reinforce or preclude one another.
  • Presenting the envelope as an objective confidence interval rather than a structured expression of expert judgment.
  • Scanning only mainstream media, which guarantees issues are caught late, not early.
  • Treating every novel item as an emerging issue, drowning the watch list in noise.
  • Confusing an already-recognized trend with an emerging issue and losing the lead-time advantage.
  • Running EIA once rather than as a continuous monitoring process, so rising issues go untracked.
Introduced by
  • John C. Fisher & Robert H. Pry (General Electric)
  • Theodore J. Gordon (The Futures Group / Millennium Project)
  • Graham T. T. Molitor; Hawai'i School / Millennium Project
Year
  • 1971
  • 1972
  • 2009